XXII.HUMAN EVOLUTION (see Freeman and Herron
(2001) Chapter 16 and Chapter 7 and lecture notes on human
macroevolution, on human microevolution,
and on human behavior)
Terms to know: the molecular clock hypothesis, heterosis, local
adaptation, heritability, altruism, kin selection, sexual selection.
Questions:
-
What living species are most closely related to humans? What DNA
data were used to study the relationships between humans and their very
closest relatives? Why was this region of DNA used rather than one
of the other DNA regions? What is a potential problem with using this region?
-
Give an example of a human characteristic for which ontogeny recapitulates
phylogeny? Give an example of a human characteristic for which ontogeny
does not recapitulate phylogeny. Which of these has evolved through
paedomorphosis? Which through terminal addition? Which follow
von Baer's Law? Give the phylogenetic evidence that supports your
answers.
-
The phylogeny obtained using the molecular clock for human populations
looks something like the tree below. Explain what this phylogeny,
if it is correct, indicates about the geographic origin of humans.
-
Explain how the date of the ancestor to modern humans in the tree shown
above was determined. What kinds of information were needed?
Upon what assumption is this method based?
-
The fossil record and the molecular clock hypothesis based phylogeny shown
above differ with regard to the time when the ancestor to modern humans
dispersed from Africa. How do they differ? Give possible explanations
for the discrepancy.
-
How have different molecular techniques been used to distinguish between
the African Replacement Model and the Multiregional Model of human origin?
How does the possibility of gene flow make it difficult to clearly distinguish
between these models?
-
What is the most common way in which single-gene human genetic diseases
are coded (i.e. are they dominant? recessive? codominant?). Give
an evolutionary explanation for this.
-
Sickle-cell anemia and cystic fibrosis are genetic diseases that
are much more common than are most human genetic diseases. Give an
evolutionary explanation for the relatively high frequency of these diseases
compared to other genetic diseases.
-
Use skin pigmentation in humans to illustrate the concept of local
adaptation.
-
What does allozyme information indicate about the relative importance of
gene flow versus genetic drift in humans in general? Based on this
information, do you expect a large amount of local adaptation?
-
Why is it difficult to determine the heritability of human behavioral traits
such as IQ? What methods are used to determine heritability in other
species, and why are these problematic in humans? Are these methods
expected to overestimate or underestimate the heritability of human behavioral
acts? What methods HAVE been used to estimate heritability of human
behaviors? What is the basis for these methods (why should they provide
estimates of heritability)? Why are these methods problematic?
When we start discussing heritability of traits such as IQ, we get into
is an area in which it is hard to be objective -- do you think you are
evaluating this information in a way that is as unbiased as you would if
you were considering a study of some other species and some other trait?
-
What is sociobiology? What is human sociobiology? Upon what
assumptions does human sociobiology depend? Give examples of sociobiological
explanations for specific behavioral acts in humans. Do you think
these are reasonable?
-
In a cross-cultural study of many human societies, the following pattern
was observed. Human societies generally have some form of marriage,
but there is a fair amount of variation in sexual fidelity. In some societies,
there are high levels of sexual intercourse outside marriage. In
such societies, men generally leave their possessions to the children of
their sisters, not to the children of their own marriage. In other
societies, there are low levels of sexual intercourse outside marriage.
In such societies, men leave their possessions to the children of their
marriage. Give an explanation of this situation based on kin selection.
Can you think of another hypothesis that could explain this behavior?
-
Describe the study of human mate choice based on odor. What other
aspect of a male was apparently indicated by his odor (other than how he
smelled?) With which hypothesis of sexual selection is this study
most consistent? Explain why.
-
Compare human behavior to the behavior of related species. What similarities
are there between humans and their close relatives? What differences
are there? If humans and their close relatives share particular behavioral
traits, does this mean that these behavioral acts are the natural and appropriate
behavioral acts of humans? Why/ why not?