Vicknair helped the UT Martin volleyball team to back-to-back Ohio Valley Conference regular season championships in 2001 and 2002, along with an OVC tournament title and a berth in the NCAA tournament in 2002. She is the only volleyball player to ever be a four-year All-OVC selection. She graduated as the career-record holder in assists (5,050) and still holds that record by more than 1,700 assists. Vicknair graduated as the OVC all-time assists leader and still ranks No. 4 all-time.