Thank you for agreeing to evaluate an article for The Internet Encyclopedia of
Philosophy (www.iep.utm.edu). All of our
correspondence is through e-mail and so we request that you submit your report via e-mail to the IEP
editor who contacted you. You can include your report either in the body of an
e-mail message, or as an attachment. Your report should include one of the
following recommendations:
(1) acceptance in its current form with no revisions;
(2) acceptance contingent on some revisions;
(3) rejection with an invitation to revise and resubmit;
(4) rejection with no invitation to resubmit.
Your recommendation should be justified by an analysis of the essay that
describes its strengths and weaknesses and includes whatever comments or
suggestions you believe would be helpful to the author. In most cases the report
itself will be sent to the author just as you provide it.
Accordingly, please specify any remarks to the editors that should not be sent
to the author. In considering your recommendation regarding publication in the IEP, please take note of our Statement of Purpose:
The Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy was founded in 1995 for the purpose of providing detailed, scholarly information on key topics and philosophers in all
areas of philosophy. The IEP is free of charge and available to all internet users world wide. The present staff of 25 editors and approximately 200 authors hold doctorate degrees and are professors at colleges and universities around the world, most notably from the United States, Great Britain, and Australia. The submission and review process of articles is the same as that with printed philosophy journals, books and reference works. The authors are specialists in the areas in which they write, and are frequently leading authorities. Submissions are peer reviewed by specialists according to strict criteria. Unlike most printed philosophy reference works, the IEP is continually revised and updated. It is among the most heavily accessed philosophy sites on the Internet and receives over 5,000 visitors daily.
Although it is not necessary, you may wish to consult our "Guidelines for
Authoring Articles"
(http://www.iep.utm.edu/1/author.htm).
Thank you again for your help to the profession.
James Fieser (jfieser@utm.edu)
Bradley Dowden (dowden@csus.edu)
|
