Great_Issues_in_PhilosophyO BoO BoBOOKMOBI['/7@I R \?dn2wZms: "$e&P(*,F.024 68: <(6>0@8BADJKFRH[JdLkNt4P|RHTV(XZ\^`bdϬf$hbjlTnpr "tvx"dz*v|1~:BUJS;[dksj{HYNߢ8-Z7!*]2h:BJRNZbjzrfzHV\0  /"+4=IENUW _5hpy   ( "y$J&(* ,.0&2/@486@8I :P<X>`@gBoDv>F}H JL%NPRATBVfXZ MOBI: PEXTH dJames Fieser"Great Issues in Philosophyl3calibre (0.8.34) [http://calibre-ebook.com]q,30886597-2f40-47e4-8616-918fadec07c3 EBOKj!2012-01-09T01:26:27+00:00   t Great Issues in PhilosophyGREATSSUESNHILOSOPHYJamesieser'''''#www.utm.edu/staff/jf/120CopyrY 2008,pdated 1/8/2012ǂǂǂ>CONTENTS>Chap 1:heeaningfife:2:odwwww3:in 4:reeill5:nowledg/ 6:thics7:olit8 lemaryogic_)oo>***3*oCHAPTER2HEEANINGFIFE7777A.’shronicil{blockquote//+Gilghndeathȁ΂///-Sisyphus"Futiy?????JobSuffer0_ׁB.nciǖPkol8onO">Epicursm2Pleas 7OgggStoicEAcceptFoooooSk~Doubt77777Cy&efyConv@WGG>C.esne8ioww??Hav hildre>fFurth:ٚ2Khdomgo>D.aoooW??1@hat؆*ngs큁㎰hadowv0m fulnesl?ggg">2.saumanubstapallyi!fromcat3.pposeHoesntxiqPKbeRasimphresultaccid lvlices.eqihakeclwwwp4܄ omٚbPefrursuitQ`giv?to}5{non-6.mpayЊ`c-dwellqod0hunP-ghr 20,000earhgo9ichcHwooulaxii finכfhner)tarhfhzasteduېadQ‡ttekcs –s0torroopxitribpKowebsitHeeep)躨ularcxeyen[a“.”yQWikipedi eou@acturroli4wxЃL"Sxpcdeologbias.Bpr joscoȨYn5Ofigs,Xcluthree`signQcepX(filmodu*tbnoPhy`F,Yexplhp؁w뀹oצ:7)ϔ{T0OxratѐllmajilotifXassic(,vljreaXmHIatogeshelfoacensbaonheirespectiveacktories.henairanoloithreedo,hatisplaysompletelyfferentight-sidearkTichotomy!nYIingaso,ay,eneralievou
(pe="0pt"dthc>WhileomeeoPindeanthrougheligionrcquwealqJohnsh,Starar8`figure0oemuchorlexibaorgcxppsfife’sa lЌruggXhowetHem.ʁw,orst8t?`nv؃@olthill[y,uinkstaxt 8ontense: “IeelkeɁXmur ndedy 500inyarriopoisfba;cysoogecoȅJ@cpartm8.”wi ؤ8troycosmiccAɑitsaew75уaI oosX0cQsathuX؆Pn:ӂ Wg͝!cyclҒj P`agQZЩ`bel heoXϘɗIimppa)WQiُxwfeelfAtruYityRrvň⊻Ԇxr, Iɚ;sucs=XfOIOKappȊ`lih)especiZb ̪g.oupH ᄷnoUzώHow!3pasea,nyh0oAD ind1oxissȥ=ڥ۩. ''''"P?nЅ) hץCPsychologste̍ɨdeclQٔ!20Ȍ Ӵ>age 50atraoȨiNXٞѥTto0 self-helpndustryasumpednoddressurroblems.hileanyfhesevolvepecificoncerns –elationshipssues,lcoholependex --rsro(generalnature.id-liferisirHspiritual”,example,illtenlarger񄨅"purpoandulfment.ЇosophicdiscusseaningyInottcotePthelf-helprapieT9aappe0y’stributh0ʋ`st`8puzz`itI:epPaimelَpaucxvechux0isc Wyctlybehi`w@h,fpy,%stockol !plausi?

    E3ɇXchaptw!plook芹famouփHhdHgardaIŽjhaattr(ȂinȌyop ennia.͚@XroIciradi—bHigii!non0otXlpic ipao74heomm`u0Г2aarticuh\ SyfinЃstyp,heyvocatPqbc(do:,ug阂sidsdominrhem.oH+0mon8ismLjǕbyʑfut{W߃؈Xouldert8XZpkRaY)rxZPclimꋡbsi8 H Zbr>A.IFESHRONICILMENTS Preoccu ownivXtJeasyP*arouX100,000eSbeilike*beА@Rnet,ndoub(wl)"1jp(QaIt󕸎b@8aHso@wy1`Ped٠[peosb@0uggRxrcc0donyhygpTodayɆh;teai9em`d~a my@lognari(popᇾVjre߲ȅoutst؂AbecinflueXP)bc.w0aufu8.GG//׶.ϟworldolurviڻriѿ+E,zZabH 4g(neotam1ׇbrokB:xTdjHaȃ Iim)Q    E3Ԉewooral*srЁ obvioȉ thairongx`wesio숨oreverevitruthEwill0liGchoice,irtu@(PXwoujumpisڃ xIcantXte8arkloux(femean@sȆthstIRǃ*notasicceprH8mayocrazyQngUgrxpper*pic^ juytXÅhxyc(tlXiAeorlPInctÄa,nyligbPysvoivAonquer9rQctrang02echnihs.ϓnvo0dk mic肨cocthichsupposedAa@A*orcw@happensmsPtcT@ xsieGI(vXAf؄imޝq/wn.қPsݘ8pdqakHDtail彩f9,0
    E3 SisyphusZFutilityi>.nomersOdyssei>Bdvenoheroρpstopsyades –dwellplaceqeadoAwithceasfydWhilQer(ese`leg0aryeop@whbeunishqevilsIyommittMalivpT!one慨owsxYiretcouaixaca.yhelsslywoulpickhr;watmshomwabpkeepePg.noمu zthirstcanhuccepchaerXadqaaupiIA,rхtoqdoworink,tQedil0s9leavonynd.Ȏul؏u@Xab0m+a@oo (8irrodu(wiawranzclou!ʚGAє埨Zitful"trgo(ftayjng@njhouldaAfinalQiwґ m Q#w aa .ģafP* P g—xil`xl@opgnerg0*near leXg`ProlbaВ scribjce:W)blockquotI`w!askaaЀgigic|jbXꌨҀb:fee0o3 ,Ꮢ%Zoşsțsouch෪1pc¨X8agaxήxbe`ꃽgQrxaSw苸ffADeamȫfromh.۴{B11]8Ǟ}AS8ʢ0qde0Htrapperm1fs)tѯm,;$рalhtima(آ_ghAaChЁamolasimpacQY3,000"wriu1symhMmpфPlifp8ors.orfP(esimila0ahmbl)job1wor()jXgگorlpJAwnmowmanuȍɖnĚ blژbmot9ӞQrirsecoyљiX+EgeI0d@0owzheelTermoHonorotsKkloyᗊ rktiĮjawinuK1c*likYco-MIBP(zuvisoSȨHr᩻)!cymIbeWb!(ƛړ__carhen`Aedio Xcpnt@e,(IHvu(k G8burnȈ(urvew[a8t 70%9dis﹀r 艈i󰒁hiIwo(d*(po9oAouPpa tiXonmrewarorŽspent䊉dhchXcleaيprivL"roQopY,bY(eh|[ɟߦߦߦߦFrenposopAlbertam(1913-1960)ievD #s.ٜ8cif@ci;pvwʒ8(ra0huYtaasonƒfXR&.cjthebsurdityfife.uman,ergued,annoteeatlyissectedndnderstoody"reasonnHsameayhatcientistsighuccessfulanalyz׀Ychemicalctions.ׂtriveohappy,utstearr`haꇩfutileffort`Ahuchs`oakensitsolproblem, ’t;oberQlthingsimpoeslupYourptimicxpaLTo8pj+dJsoPxsuicide.o,isyphuspreЅ9overwhelmQugg@hȁYcoJaointlr.‹Camcont0Ile8`uesithespair.ɍSre mend3revolgaZpFnaT,pptH0(l蕢@sPx`fihiqȉshouldmbrac( ber-pus@avorval\Hn;,ꀘwQchievermilarlwhIyayraIlSurpo0bedy\InoneHwel8zIcbteean؂selArough Ёoutlook.

    E3 /Zq`iщrR蚱ks?IshewillpowPcʞࡳsp=PsruiA?0aca ttitudHdjusthzooeeps`ઓc!;ir"rXY(l-begorXa8FXdecah(k؜rollHlosufixt08feedduXbc0e:mey'؇!1djsed.oolognw,>QsuffۑpxaskoXHeng*mdȃA4energipeC8tXpHr regujtoa+5(roducAdiffcxbquipc肦fačǜك߉ag'environr2(ׂbxheAp(êӠVkb5ZۏYrk≸P󐙧1rm dohs;*di vejJgrowRp ;od?;2ppunY@new@rʿtrlWTHre*HurbsePҩ 7RHigneΏinyX)-gaxrtribPups –B7iccspePXirqvamoxdxriʷsP;wardfyenhfplaȄ'toin*ab`pn8Polon.̧YnunYԅA8availbr>JobS蝲xi>.storyaAfroeewϿT`Psxoɨ;۷l.w pobs‰sdekGilgH9i0񄂍-k}Zfac@XqhXaPHhȾ*0Ydsba`vbamiltwarcf,xq)lonkeyЋnryh@(sH1nimal@p,servan(bur (usk*ȉ`CcdhBk؋paprnado{himselfinf5itcsiICcra$brokHxcpopl ow񡀅BlPXThfذ)8p"paisi8k@xXognizeJusisfigt8a.ƃweekAHXnexbҲha g% sice, sI8a`d!” ew@GwQCCaccsJHbe!CrI]tar@1mBes.neriendrgueshateopleufferheneyorgetoxnd,o,obustaveboned+tmeointnisife.norcommi\moralnse,9oneanullynowll ing findsvil.ӆspitea’srotestsbeblameless,eever(/t(lisn@mmediateapparent.jinsi,oughApdiarong.in,himselfyearsaunderstormrserecortraight:"ingreatvirtu2gnifit_Ahasroaplain.

    E3ԅPxblemaisyhwexumc.hi萹{8aHitZon ecypZmXcaa(oushadhoRmeanqSuppoIickphahio⎸tyofootth(.nay'!clڛe [tRoX8lved:ЖR܀ua lishlf 9 ru4I!accepa rŠra(makQ=؊or@n,syePthyiaIayȇbf you㌬w؂؇ۃlsou(rr1convicqassaulPEɓɒmYph,Ќ b`acYjicebePArH ountjg*unfi1.li:woCnecaripԎٔ#"]occu%Ib(unxvokedچYH:, icPx`8wqedخ fsiuswnتתבdepz;omptiv@ealوvo`qPlĕ guysȔ:IhH؇XosShaps 8sjJimn٘uck;imilar!vcPdxkilۂI钐ofa`aЫnHЁepcprizwBɈagonizJlln׵׵׵׵W9(u*pPȑragediYLlef)ZhRInPartr"useek8hidd8cauAng(dtrhshrhfQQourwлᖈli!fiso҃y,q0mpaq,ĶʺRJisXlawsuimmdayIPip+aurbcityjiʋ:,I`mfXpHr:an_[war Hbpsidang""ha:XmᝫxcX catAxhH聺NWp@Өh eْ‚hornado.“rrңs ȈaɈJnclear-headmXnt8dК??ꛖہfailMattempcӚ̈ɄiȀyo,di(Apofulo PXtpIcioesheo빊wordȃq!(8qorϧϧϧϧ̂8ryX_arHdiit2v gras`enpogulf0twIrwom;@hxPieXۚBΖݤ book)*”Ielrșɺlgb}g )"magyouItQPam)p.ny effortsoomaouaid, “InowhissainfulorQ,uton’teiscouraged.odinitelyreatnd:areyparisonXsignificant;whweearnrometoryfob.”ԁwouldfe
B.NCIENTREEKOLUTIONSP JuaromiȈmeaning*ife@voicHxumcivilizbPooxdZancЎryoXuys.Аeopyggestqu8heAwe(dharьpX&day0ichasfirЏЁbackn se*llokMGreece.Ɯ@aⅈfime,"khiopherHelf-help ss™rpp-by-Athodsachievhiȕo@rPpopularev@kXnam`heho@ds:picȑ8sm,tSkeptdCynr.ȃasomb#mYPߗߕוח    E3 i sdХ iہ"}ӀJ8,Englishf`{argtig unrsityqinks8zcrЕdo.ivor ᠰm(40,0`konobdoerepmuorkubi1hiercer۲რri8yreput1ge8doymXmalq3fewla$4te௢Yذx1ulanra)An9hPaspIlfH۷jpfamen(؎aa҈egٯtte(tɚtury" "an@l8yen,i(t seum2*sculHxnqatr0Ppil0fQcpjazz ubOpchooleaouYamplE0tlrHxpЪQoughhnlims Ʌel.ʭiX@Hmagne@mChimhrȍsuccfulIxt.Ŕh؉:vnfeeraduqxlࡐ

    E3\`Pselfsr`5edvXm)ieIvoidluxuXA -sufficYy. “eatXnefIoj,”yargp,ًHfreedom.ItemȆHn1f Y2%-n/2mق9nk )aHۃYd^upfeeAepe(q[Vapuaeza턨`ful,hich_]r@gnizbr>pma𢌛Paap؉0s(ideɔ+ariswPcamp.Κp`larfGvaonioxpjprovQBrk;YhuHmodaYlЌunhɏrbedؠhX:f$l@unpicZwЁserЮ˛BoftroPn(haek.rog9wrPwhosychologic imipe+b82xknowؽ񇰃P klasПػ(vȑ snd@`,`Bpossiby?ƢYЇ:<"ignohysrsh0environ`t.ͽArntȦengthꠔ tuRget×8om,s膉sQdisgxyQ:Qޔ8wrmercyuגѠmcՄ:2kɀ!`iHavhexperajcircumA-42NaȮxeama8)iyzilosoachie^.ׁ IfOlway8sizzX??mp,jb XreȂʱ g9dAIQˆhopʻv`fhYyors,hshzrhG`BBiѵy)؅Ti[WO,gџ8AtetH(c.55 –.135.E.)AlyknewHrstPbrṳ;b0HfQhesi9quel߷Yuy nkZgXan8eositarouHaa@`Y ړYpas3guestscooppo`oirIte Bn@ʣ empt~Ykeeplrowtablennticipation,pictetusdvises,utait entlyoroururn.etteet,eaywhenervingishinalarriv(houldussstlowittakanythH.hi8s at@attitudesubeoward􄐁nifyw@ypcrave –oo`obaofamily,uxuri(IhichQcanev(counF(stoicmulaucceed e퇹learnhab@tanceselxrome%ire,vx areh wayalكhacqu@conithtftacho,1؄9circum{won’tahapppted.

    E3cPh{ppineseemelui0"prisonersap,lHnӔncies1teeseeoplɆpsospectmRplachopeyo;m wion`makwo.ׂabrxuxAghobHccasЖ3+tun`banqueble?ometimIindȍgghardmptmaykPerbalyyexpeQ;noroifullexamh*a,Մoub؆ifmpPjmpplkyIrh(bPcs 6s hm8adoeshurݤ.G܃higg9aaɠQb.Ȥred¢ĪDemoѤspoupbchildrءJfAunpredbtJm{tpsHegaiilwBdevh ngtrlq8Q(exo0l.c0impAѴwwsacrifi0followWcrIex#punnssar蕸p r ums\adopxXϳb(lm0.br>Ii>Anrganiz#x“ociety”o9hdebunkZଛ X9liefincludQUFO!bduX,SP,ligixirac(rhlpRos.ϟwrrrsБsey(cfamh1947spacraf(Ros,ewexico.¨,)l1`sȐlitarx(oQdecaH9Bransgs,)blockqu8//+|ÛrldmI0,kexhau٦tig d"xghyYc`m.tfaryI log(admX¢on)oso isc)bg8g hxAPk1ze --(nyB)h elshPersqodl`rt.B.D.ǯpenbergEe]v׍BJosZultrsiڔu(nciȓПOO:p1˦A󁨽pȂquiryÂut0 Pחd`beJGre,0rularaqchool߃`undpPosopyrr(c.365-c.275CE)њ`Wɣi m`tFchiٚQ Renvis8СI9Pype(`eQusp.׀ho@viewc܄vwq@Sturbh@riskpuRfoZ:no(r鞾diPprwir s?gannabevent, whyreheyoveringtp?euicklyecom8anglednebfestionsnd ncerhthaton’taveood swers.tsotusttrePliefsikiUisrups,ut any ovicQsetsureace9miwhenoldigidto,uchy-Ӏgrassmyarsehor7table4kitciHround.ԁsolu,ccordiskepticogniz)e،9subjeco(ubtCaprЎauseeye uctapecificahlighhinOay@9efactodiffered,wou .o,Ƀ@suTaboh8Qereally v`4gu1.T–extpalzGodexisteh,orvalPebyȋ@!fl`މEproduce.Œ0chiev*ImentHIlitywi2hЌ

    E3 PbyIH>x8ulliyp`jӀselvup8ointAUFOhoroscoprrac(cureploddith;moȋiyi(tedicul8I0rsx_,`tdgai8mIbrwashpAAnkyPm*onelwahia1Pt1ph?cl(llbö́anormhzvulner҈(attackBthusAЏadva@:'$҃:wolemposi.irsbPw0momensiccanɀӆ~f0쯇 yg!€!X;ntireaP4uX?J:ؗiPal_+Cf׽mbeh: ol,glhowxIܚqcYIssumzܹtiȟXK8)walXiJuahihismxceqx)sirdimHsRa(s]ifc̊٥.manylif tmaHunTLSisypIrc t*pemlijobNIoubgzoٔ幺sJobsuffeous(amihdiadoՖ߃WxipPfulmo)deQЋ_i`vA,/h`n8olu3X.br>CynKDefyConi>.oyagдfvunchLollapaloozaH81p(@t"rowcyeopW*كg@padwQud asiveunken(qchamp`aaraYB,0tjrutuqvofitch.πЂJincl8 Xcu s o@xaAsheetxA2huX k8er󌧌s!(ssBbecaaY1non-%؂8ad`‰tvi-smas*@.͹abizarȄiidexwatatrokgl(#0a)铐ekllo(d0teav asImdiyJw1oty,/symbol‰usX*ltu ds(o٢ctaQreagprevaiglueࠪggg'gM\pcu8pp0arooradiaalocialxpectations,uchsowehouldreswhatounts!goodusic܁findntertaining, viewuthoritygu .hesereotnlyestrictive,uftenolmisguided.n`olu!oheuofife’sea s9challengePerished8cialnvthrough@acYefiancewakaroaderppre@possibiliti rebelliousnoultinanyaymbodimiᄰiyGreekhiloso8cHschoolQCynicismCaimmovewwtemptorradhonцSuckvalP --~power0ealЁ!atuByo9so1w*renkinfمzcivz{have0urveop(selpa(dixnn@ :a鑰x?9oryihens#hp3heirckbeior.

    E3aГHp@tDioge؅Sin` (c. 410-320CE)ojd9impbeggarrotincreasОlshstylpe.Ș8(Phexil fromrh)townaccxiXJsyl2nomic poY.h@soaskhpfelbJʅ:replied,TIaa' 0)erabl!HaɁla9tax@took)arHbarrelquicks(eotyġ3ꌦ.Ȝ9talkЕn[aylٓYtHmphReoplP܌imH,pfs(y#Al0 ȀPitHٌadmir.Rezy1gy ь9like,?saiИisunbaAْJIp{r(ɀ؈@bl܂82gJȂrpoTfn0IdОbeFɡ hee1m؏e#ormulЖhxȒ.irstYeextrigscHAeubb؂wъJu!ooȢѵc toHhsSump!vxiscar!꺰 b`.tdifuaщ9bHft twK0f- sȣ:S!moat ɋ8dgЇ¸0*n@ o(row.ebellppp))@ZWf ʏ)merɁH bXmediQy wor؝w0ɛorpoyb蛠viewetyH XУs8r2maHs2tuT,HialuctuBm5,ۂLollapaloozararti8c%pP",!,rolЅ(i⩸apte@j̈qmouragtr@rbo@NovernegȄ`chp0ublic@mlUacpshmr qhțwEpХby2inP"hip KЁOffer"@cca``ʙ`[dosowqealizuʂ*`HnoyryQelse. br>C.ESTERNELIGIOUSOLUTIONS0//Fqillennialig(rouAbtakhskYlainmeab,p!hю1vѝpinhZairrP)domin4أWeriviKQJuda0,ÕXXIslaYabsi ~ڇ.


</br>    E3 Havinghildren
    E3ifDeathpi>(ilimiteduccesrprocrxiaYforhfAguisXreligIoff!aackuplan:Z0uIPr:spect/+xt.͍faradisessccouh8"d釨‚detailsaryenohatˆialarmyhnscious错Isurvzdbod:a3perfAstatexiste`.1 ee-dns؄8@mmblurXhapXbusJtrucfrom5flawsbPAlX0lygb:p8spirituXX[spspaXasje荰Lzs.R Wؗ ablowattЇ@lɆlassic0mobv{toluRpGilgameshd-.Ԅfawvdoi.p,IPeelseHĄphyxyhPytinupm(`rP husiastYؔrU:chund0da8,xPЅh(Awwal)mt@afsahw.—ȱIugraspJw`XrvH9saBworbo(sfadlsod(0sisypWSpoint`PMyߐivqsef(o!rznA釉ʷpausƆXI݉`A99mT:efe8й reر{qIoɏ8Alox@Ieepvie.裚H( 18R.il݋JobsuqIfx`odiQiltcar,amb(eؓ@haȨ،h8c wqGixsCstol0t0X1ugqsYuXDbac :zbaduysunishedgoo$rewardedΦ?2lo!onxeledgqטHmQr!suȊГ0-(omp89'",surpribeH `aR igWcҍPwrwƛaies8ad?[RobH]hhhstyP u*b❸LesesSssX2=exisx–tubbor@ abZ(Pdi` sވl vi=FhhnPSuppo}a񻐂 nOP(eyourPa,ƺ?OOOOOOOOOOOOOKwwwtʌ؜_g뽑Xm צ__ZnotiHell.χBdaTzZhZ;pit\dipown߅8iofonvictionhatequiresHinforcementnဘgularasis,hichsreciselyligiousnstitutso.yontrast,erenorganizaYevotedo6ingurvic2zParexists;eimpHb evtithoutnyepalkrom “#E"”g0.ԁ(crucialuewhe person’sfpfterlif"ȉt`stroenough9counhactproblemsfmeng.ometim IsYt.

    E3upposeyouPgetasshhfirsbstacle`dZm74–teofzKnexljhavىfidencχ(llctual.hi_/(ma Qesad,ths1 tqa!umeri`imAworldlm(ves.gainxu@s虠de7",f@8rupmoss9w@ow.Ågpicke򐩞pDozHaggdoubtƃ(ominsacroseX1(tamXYnArs?ur,#1Itt꤄)orIin bgI"upR,݀follow)spficψ隘2oGGfd,arn8afhctri(isuuPdxx)ɒT jLnt?䂱mȉXn,0serrovXparЂePhehrxrhe(toryfam‰igd"ryb!(pafulf`Goext2Insecu%fȒ`|bur%rHٚunhappQѧS[nZihZaly{;aՆenowHxpz(plimisuccgi|Tn0x (1ady(thorIbr>hllapذRoXmpChHtip8osopAug A(354-430)rotȪiyitlhAC)89JH@scribIwoYcit .iO˩ ȱKyn&xH{reiadriy8lf-lPhemp0.eopЈoq`蘹!)airiqnڟf2soXmisgud.4}ۀʇglorX@ultimateach逸c~2,D71lȄ8-csHkadvZkiehoIH΂Y@can8gO'ex /La2DHSa0s,kȓnicknaHMXUplIh@choolتyـȁ{ Q i@erissaQyoaAImPrh8lآ&i!stɂ pleiact@Awatov,laysp8yleUpopulhmusicYgfoc Axa"@ssagbaptizeewoqrou bec9nڛppurpoXsial__S WXRegardldonɄؑ f(gioȐhibi`kmakmarger-Q-zsZgiz+atypicalg0p-efg`!unNsi yolPamgsinddup.ɯB<9enӀhouldwhhthu e*life’seaning.econd,heresevotionoirmndacre8etfeliefsboutod’solnumanffairs.hioriexatuexistenceim:ozen,otustyiewmwill(.eadersthH(sehgiousradisormulatereci8doctrines,vipledgeclusivPmbyXjectȇs!rivalGroupBymbrac0DoO:mselvIsarkpaigHissfromkparticipaB0hXe-Pociaxvity.hirHPs׃invo"Xf-ifice.uraّdH0noasyask:tfinanYlyostlyxsum荃eftcommonmrutopposR.et(PnduʌKhardshipfeepplishmenheakogress.

    E3ǍْP“f”XincPI{]yn-Gہ atimilar@tr hransѐethghmorrolchideologLiG|{/g-PdpeoXZjUll1`X:ي؜causPservenviron,lpotdef(Efreex܁xX)`,ٛ globȅ@ DR㪡ofa0enlifetirǙunter1ווווe)secr_Zrprpay;#ʇ`lH?name`BF`aD`ak냀!ox,ddu8mP mg)much' vntfollowdiUxgI˪1tXro؅ȇpin*_ݹy:[rmXfixظCr cPlc.͡1'ˑ(un*ol)oY.x-M Șxx_regydesbxؚ`#8ɇR1aXda[i mid ckee)`h`7yurXDASTERNELIGIOUSOLUTIONS0//RHHEasHnÏlizludeao(,uddPH@uR1perha0azțR yze haHadvocdHeWsolu㌘ߍ< 𓹂wisQIdYough,'ndJuniPoso8e`=Fo(.ҪamportaUApdeaxu—͒Јhi釨loHjlri."fworshipȝߗ۬h#Hlook0nP˱hA.ה׿O?IR@g+Ca2,500ࣙo1 ncip"ssagRʎ섈 ɒhqrIwayQhpathjM!T#XelfheXguix匘ypɭk5OOp8s`Єs3a sicxlOnaۃ`topp    E3~Kapt0(YccPAfمBe`gsЖagstPPiciHk!aBjar.טYitumpxockt`esnasxQebstruc;steat0ѓhcinujcpismr!ɍcific comd`iq'񊁔F(examplWab`dsu8ylawity{etiquettDPaneX'laclcju@ba ungrw8itXacquoIfpeoɂؑp Ɲx1xyk@led studyh*RwisdomalrSY4K+socihenvironkb(smeGץAust9[hbigiti1reliaؘrptechnologyP–xflx(etweaʄ"*i(lC1Msurworkx1H idiaXъ\alsodefinisug؜deHhQ:wʻIeraRp}gnizHparPf߹yXrgrowoca0soydyel(it z@releϒ pew:=| >biQшthersxperiencg`e5VR_,ieoJpowerPcefulepX0qppeItRhahP0crPc0ahilosophhhoc! oo–uh0Ho@dmany9ut}1@xtrQihuւPdifuly.enyX궉Rd8c;imȌ1mercږ:ÖStzB2exЕȂߏ;guidh9.ϡpvivk`bAha}@؅RyearJtrqrݲоYgener"H opood:,3_Aask٥0nw@urmtablNB:ungivmaۑra“Guck1yчway:`ouai8Qdie.”iPpQ“@clmbseX,1,ou!db:C,(ssxXrm,iseash--Q9RcscxtiXalysi)actu8lXdzxm sX\in6:chi(ggȂɨzZuyÑThuqlittpyuyqwlaO`ksimecommends,ndtsolutionoheroblemfife’seaningooksttlempractical.


    E3 BuddhismExtuishDesirei>.ԅ`|telig)wasoundedrI 500CEnndiaymanam8Si(arthaautama –aterive؃`honoraryi“ a,”hichRsnxhtenone.fiyearsattempachievementȆ ghradi1aleusathPKorkutphȄ8felswer8f8ntquesZ.ȄcapsudiosFourΒru_fir@tsat"isuffer*Frommo @wQreornntilie,veryt oHvolvegrphysAinemo|umandlesrus`disPoints.hiJob BsparspecificqgeЃmt Hmo(grallH႟HhegHrtdail`Xp9 obstacfac™L)hs seconG!Isؖll!d҉era almopӂ*mleasusensuay,erso!,h`shEs†9ses@mZn%yiyCl؃(ddi(KrcAliminbYUI_ZcausK`t `oaH ЂreȚ wPNzfold,r!JechniɇʇFvťZEXltivhȂxYt,iЌr,lihoodf8 0dfulc{.x0ﴯ]odelħ_\"ed0iɇdaytill@idif9asн,Xhuraп+Zprescrib`PfecPȅ 1suǡ[:argeK]ooluVirt0P`posoHologyex@ȵR(R76.2 k{--GAZr(9b88p20nirvanaڀxښȮ8u.”ɇHȜjs 0lowjl襢y.łF_P˓Pmuh*n聤vario1:ɁpX PPXvidt[(nself-scAɖȅbeRAs sexi1uaY, w؁0xyrrpr)؄JpulH8l.1yuK܃1•bIci\.FromPpPHNCppɪXm eŞOAȆhremovpf! qu* noClef>ryra ab˂Xۛe*mA3icka.iruPgadonaQdead?Dals^lmɽerangBsqgo|Bplnni8th.eHmo8?fee)8Qachid9P‡2B p-!-ealimpossiX!fؔJalaiama,gmgYa99Sf`Kmanye(gar"d:Rbr>KindClaritandnsighthapt 1]
(pey="0pt"dthc>Inhort,shroudednysqbestanpfollow8ommenpathrchiev,@`myyeswha'xu;s.ׁmY8ffiveolutioneoblemfife’seantdifficult2u*examinhossibil0`tasʏqn ords.HuismFiGoalsL(i>riginЊa؁3,500earsgo Ȃ(lxPa(verhc0Yb efXemergt)ghIndiaritory.Ԑthaanyerentoddevoal_˝ie8ʅ free(Xfrom --8k(aarti>nu.imil0:@quԒomXdi*doРiitiqosimpxanswer.ҙ@eroɅ:fp d`in g݄ upeoYuldb naryqdegXurzperiirveX򕯕oQfirЅA=hasurxss8em폛ysms:8odإmuБpani@exSorfamwȇCKamauQaPndbookpivv@d8descr花ozen[echniyXurSnclضjpursu(ԄІkt{fupriafɲesisЌsxsucPsLa}!acqu0altHohonkeepsbejmpo؂hgс)@Racpl(t[=ʆ{moPfi1XHrus@0Hrai:x8ABٰrkamኑormonyChelregulyÆG@,Hoparksocpoдtowa d[ȏ>/enPhtenќ(b1pi`JYaȌhuqattlti ppsaxlbHdهtbeh)8x1lxme8witګonӧ秧狈giclxJ@1hjډa(advoc hx퍑ԌworlspxrusxdCguu:siZism)ɩthatexre3cpgЄyear|̸ngPyُ)drtafJIpn0t{-size-s-hluMblemWWӻ B`Ps eciyyyhadh.Ơ@exaѴStoic<,ig ɯd(y2@////ma0 ЋIeemjdesfsȢr*Bttempks:ۊgoPsxra.gggW`Inrraȃ,r`"IIDPwKnaaprteu 8kfew/wٳxcircum@n4,ba(LײrxWe`gg(Ѵpfh(s –cӑexcellqJi` –eouldddllfhe(rolutionsate’veiscussedar,reek,esterneligiousnda.fvbecomerisonwn0mighantoick Stoicpresigningysel0teblifeTXorenzifore,GGCDaoistOllowIwaynatur`Rlynclin peopleanChxti“furyGod shdom”rBuddhYqu0nirvana,epend hiroefecTHpoi iI󍸋E;bspecifxBcircumstaproblemmorreatiHwȀinyitemʆmenu:Pke*Hbbyilgahd`h,isyphusflity,obsuf؄,Ian`zundermPsuensfurpoYrapp s.


E.HILOSOPHYNDIFE SEANING0POOLWhi1subjec`meaxp`oso8c`ȏpnwHY,xal(aoodroducc3var:fieldȃ7alxploron.lrD"leadzuzz(boutowkn@th@s,chIe@af8sk whetafro`Pctu)mpor8/ȉrai [aĩo2(irimyoPphysbUpohAngissmerumH#o=myH2ࣣent yodywiicrol.in‰р valueIyox0#docistrwiacѱ wwt    E3ڸ<sダKu8نsflny:orsa8d,Qy8Kinpe܁chicismȦ`oh p`e@FXexampsstPggicburpaRۉ-Z-ai+`giv!hop1gravOƌۉI9 nliiccaahHoub??:debne儸1ougu#rguh׃׃;snllelidD%ڃm.ȊfusApo;smopellh!.‰jippbqHtaXQceinmay;yҿg眴z!s0InS蜀؁ necxfˆL!ihemselvXbفxnd-takrh~. ߤߤߤߤګmNjŠפҘdiff`wayR\A.ӊ1jsciific,rawiYexpe0l#iЅ scO鲻 rospexvy$privreflr&Üty!tipQlog)LwosAsJ!heldI@imPP{dld8ٍ munў Wэ/)work|zyxhtr(i0,ʅ:Tixog,H( 0 oe`,ffrag mQ4gecXYJtmustypwB놁iP0刧/h8hinkuXmp7Yojamq2hymnas@prewardSwhɥft g9o neways.


Foreview ǁǁPleasenswerllfheollowinguestionsrGGC1.hatoesstoryQGilgameshugg@bout*mean8lif!d9iseider’s9death? ">2|@Camus"analysSisyphusc?">3Job4.escribepicuroluoproblemʃUgiveneriticisZitromchapterㄇ5{toic6kep7Cyn8.poo)“#fXC”wp9furPrQGodkhdom߃߃߃߃߃ߣ0aoi׋׃ׅ׋ׄwwwpar[BuddhFour΄Aruths,7Xnirv fHinduoal?A̲oׁײselect lHHMB|obeitONDefe gain"presentedPbookǃDzIJflityWWWWWWWWDHPialogutweenߋ3regardpсig3n`loate777sC{z/Tkpersp ooo[Iook,RDalaiamaxX9bchievpthroughay9moraloct.sexamxexpn`poinp)cw77Tb>REFERENCESNDURTHEREADINGwwwvWorksÒOrdPXAppearanclockcgg%Gilgamesh .pcxXslayephMitchell, sh:NEnglish։P (Y:reeЖ2004)N,artinJBeTime1927)stȚ؆JohacQuarriEdwiRobo,ar؀Row, 1962PI,õ 1pscuss9n[ȈooonomIT(Odyy]eFagڂ (L@on:engu11I4SisyphusᔘB hwwwww,l鄶Myh?s:Orssayi>,+AlfrA.nopfy55den`g,.D.,Rollţsed,\SkepxgazӉ3,ol. 10,o@. Chuang-Tzu怚BurthWato部0+Ԃ/:`lumbianО\8܉TaleYCh am3>B-'d-rgya-mtshotpoRK؅HClay,"Inht+Tr.efyopkins,nowionublicat`s, 1983. Lawfanu.ecentranslsyendyonigerndrian.mith, Theawsi>(London:enguinook92)Džr>(pDžDžFurthReading.Cott0ham,ohOnRoutleh, 2003">KlemkE..ǃNeworkOxford957?????">Munitz,ilK[Does Haa?  eush_)Ocalign="er">***3*ʂb>CHAPTER 2:OD(ooo A.ԌNatureGod׊>9onaln"GoodQGer7Pow{nracle''''>PsychnoriȄnς__>D;ȂEvilwWʊossiolu'''''Freellfens`߇0Fai`ɿׁ>PasagЬ(ߣb'James:zRovoooo>Plan!arally-Found|ςςF.lursmǁ>rpon_0nflicAoctriInacc iǴǂǂü FhRefle@ʁȀȸg>1.½ a0atbutPtradpscedhatY-pful.׀mbeom rs?">2abe〰`proven???83.ow,f, weemheeportmkgenu1aaud4|instahumsuffegaH1ystoubtaϑc5.sthaPbۜthounyvidw@ r''' 6"truek,ZЋporldsonn؋ ll7߃ߙؓIorganizZ ll“ElvHUndergra{Church”osxiȁ``((9furiWorkPresley,K,HwardnxspecyȀshrhythmharmony. ɚ@oldC 8of(mpriH؁ Ue,ag@smd0DonCl,yLeeiVivaasegasy is,ysxPeYcスtyo@(sel(ha\`loveithenderness,ndakeisksnife.lthoughlvisՁgrouxxmorefributeoTthanreal(ligion,teverthelaiseieameiȂphiloso8cquesttlso.׀thingHstprincipleJhownXexists?irraifacceptonbasifaith(outoof?Ʉdbetter&coxrPy&to swse,utPtti(avoidsivpreferenczanypecific4suchshptianity,ȋuism,rve dimportant恀Ybstractox臘Go @uslief,oXarticularadi郹i8aomeyservЅllufocypl(XargblemurZiwK.


A.HEATUREFOD ߁߁ܑ.?Zg"toryaxbeeBine@nify1natuˆ–sbeI@@ـach80aecrToQ“”ehifق*peoХ$klim our: subjectomchurhlєt\ide1 llowcreed:wrblockquoPW0eelK0mosHntmaцiРA! --ԁup(w0@elbuiljib 0b(@encayXaTYgggoodqloeyXtenssof_A80cpo@fulohfu鈂mbRGGThythmCarmony...璏'G''lxs؈bsu:inl—@tX(oLjrnwjuBJud opIslamHh8seviewW|schoXvbҤۮa82;oB/phj8mde(wxpl _׎׎>Ȱ    E3ВP,eѲ`hpisnPXmaɅww{`ryoIg.ӌ u񁈊EsȃF,mmap ȁdoz.)hapas6\`pć:Hscalcypac communЃjb?rh(Jowyoy??Ȉac,tmpan ac`dьhHe`Dxabil@.yt`r' bɀrulipo(k!*mpunϰbPd1i 놈bscaクa0ins)bp5worldii0Amay`d diffromuma@wayЋǃEsimcli(uaappe@Y֌evid:Qp`sȑowhopsX9 Bz`m1canwxxt@ʤWeyoщy"" hropomorsm9ꂃ JoAo-1@up9Ié0eHHhahxPirarjuHMelangeloehiⲔamySC0ela .ouXP8yw@misgud⮘(esiHmso@imaktheivineeing.utheneurveyhettributesxaeommonlyiveod,chsersonalness,anyookspicioushu,hisuggestjustdempurselves.ԄGreekhilosopherenHa (c. 570–c.478CE)oneffirto0k1ioint:


Ifxando@PrionsaȈPcouldrawthYirdxecHork8frtopleo,w_ormigodsЁk*Q’odiinimagHvari.Xomnib vole
ideaă@eviۏq tpy@yexcep2(ᨄwhѱnsum !~ego@c8}r1sli⠽,speQpimfst ۡd臘ludwot^:ApaC."tex((suffernahobaПլxlifrmnext.!eam,xough,ali@(yiwhichllowamobey.hiyʈtaȏؘUpo(biʉoenɫ沺``8wᅈdyZʈmywHwar蔹qrequiYjudpunppãrxqissur senщ@0QJQvariyuz:QeȝxmaxfeQnhoa`R+howݺKxpTs gtgmWQrȑB!bawp*8lْBs!.Ї(firsRosxpRadduewr8s,br`)blockquoXtaa “”Pmovfromon,AʔHq-nWomenndedemption
]
(peight="0pt"idthc>Manyon-WesterneligsavexcognizedhisthoupfXereatorurturingoddess,a0rXa!malehoikesouildntricateyngenlowQmp.ccordAdefenders8posi,vifׇscriproutinely0fo “he”,stillodifyuronceʈ=divhe’s焢 bit0withSidea߉.Ԃmiddnsubjechatڀ`-neutral,ɈladlanguagYforcujimpropernta.€mх|I–eҏfeRچak3ovBhuma0devalueeryS] icflexiben铊sexYZ,Mwqay.Ɍ Id,\,uab'rxlargide`mؒnph܌radregarsphiloso8cxdebPȄ. PowSepa0en0 Ib>atbub(Ponaly,oodSYzrrtanb00hJ8rrivo!HlivexO2̄?mo(abs nayexplҋ~ybecaus{upuzzCyeHmo)heЂg`ll-p1ful (omnipnt1);knowisci Xtimebwito~sromworld.pookPwose:LJًeוווPerhapQIs@pup0i񌇄IarYRӁopnotar(u؟appea{Т8Mɡhut8;fipց 2do')lPWYcounHuppask@yem.Ά0oncoshysRk,rre Ⴘrspm)1s U 2+2=5p؊܇cimampl3#Xals"shomC𲹮Hrox`elf?ņa3"x0ɐAtam8P?ɔ;iplɈoeach֏''bizar¤)baȇiȕPibpopid:⅂mrocko^xt(it?up ans“yiЄpwwwws.”wazd@ S~8,Xy,ɄjuۜȇteadWPno;hWsomeoo`t`ǎ2quxsZ >/|dogggg7d9sediewܝ(riѝvoi)Hlogape+<m@utradictory.e,HexK,i*;ڝ񎢨@(ga0hfπ͡;ֆ΁YGAǪAccordrofe*s(not::vo*؄X94Uw olvy b: ?DžQIGK󇰣ϙJ|Єiɉĥ1ncompatZwiXhiseryature,uchsod9anternaleingestroyYhimself.

    E3o,hiofhesewootionsomnipotencehouldAistdopt?fouink0atogicermanent8dnchanglawiversЀpni’lloth"seco(cep.tespecЁinviolableʁӄYh work:in؃aints.nZo(rnd,r8oompsep/itxsusikeyze*agirpu9hosiUauthoritPPallyxyjhncludz????separate
rom8–sisҀw)rouQsechnicŽit)ފ8*ereatȑC,uthpnt.ԁ‹0™)dnps9r Imb!a ?yoes*mixstuffn8hntegW8.ˆEaview՟rgerej8ea@yoaivorynow82panm9cψ$ol0Accorhdrxairc𑼘physAspiupxoأㅀ$wbe ygۓG`dwells:ockpl@animalJmoHortly,ahu.no2st hradjճΆcommitiߒߒކ religJēajo(riftptwe¹pgps.br>BRGUMENTSORODSXISTENCExbXIonEify:oosa=aidem8su(a x.Pmiddg:philosops``b@4cJdo+Yebohpthrhr proofs捰򄪸Cx@s(um cguitar`qy”:.bl0qu wws(1)imie;X___^2)S5oj7oojM ϗ|llowX8`giefouriwhihwillami8y:TsmologkLsigpaogȁbabix0Q7|">    E3)HQC7li>Ӛm ћ`ډ׉Pemp@answhaqunИ k:)diЎ8?rli0eemHs Aaҁdno0H;akhdQa1emerXnoppfirsx=cy1in.פ98ib0n‡CearP'{t ȍxssibausȉF9{X(bachghi(ki؁likmaAinf`telo0hl0xQsupbxb؅;4esnxsense.HnHۇKserJ{Ю׉pn@@sjecbVsBoo8avieп0hu(La.ʱbecPca#+Xggg`ex RH`@OrnntctoryimayYdifficultorsoicturennfinitelyongausalhainfvents,hedeatselfsn’tgicalcontradory,doe[rul tutsossibility.

    E3oHsophistPtedersiocosmoDrgumofferbyermx8loqerottfriWillhelmeibniz (1646–1716).beginsygrantithat3ϊsworldou)racePackghimeyast.pecif+Cori@*achbjecithr3isxplX#k3it:Hoare/*ri0V @70HowPr,& ed,steedn{natforfaqie8yphHll.ɇr9dhwhyo@somega:Hn?ԃuP@nesCs;{ixbXsaryxu;totfependфs.͙щmטЁ8s:br>(3's hu,incQey7P+eIwouDŽ . GGGGG(4Bree{onsqϊΐ_ScishgDavidȖ711-1776)*a8aunHcrivario8proofs2܋!nclud+??.cPrflawabov,8۟\“who(Yona0bsጚ*AhanyHHF.ϑe( dequ8DzBicula TŁlouߴfrom0ourobdonyd rs''9lefoŭmaP exampl҈I|⻐xؤXcilmyndlP(eabi2:т?9c!nexpw-ilς,0clear0Ҋ`̉a[qfuccount73;(imiwa`JsayOu,oo2„SO0olYmyӇͼ^PߥGGGW aDgn혲Anahyi>.erhapmo0intu7ХO'#d:;ppa\Ӊ=u]mpeZli#aivLerjx0s.fam1whi.ׂtlook(marvQhumЀen`avxP/ men*watch{lcrafwithhpreci aXle!sqogeY faurposIs񅘁ȵЎV ductِelliX0˄8rgthrougȍYNowwȊ gdy܆`/alex?9ڈUspf |s 00@hitczun8rsʼn馈eni.̇Iregornexa׌Yɭio|,k!howbmusHG"gЎx1t؃shass@shipweeen anyatch.yaralleleasoning,hen,eustoncludeatetsfIatuorldrelsoproductQintelligentesign.ԁspecificnalogymployedeXisHis:


*    EWWW3 K`andniversehNmakerOWWMterwrepwwsLaidutoXprPselyHgumq ''1.achinesuchsӀI'{/.'2.Дresemblۃ>3ref,"h`lrobajOOO'环Wxbuccesdependnwopsues.irst,lato)m( 1bov-show nextricyinkXwith+B8E@yimeqse be@HinAz4:.iaml(1743-1805),Hbodef0er6,xuasx0wou??.Ŗnarwisayously-midhilosop`@ccepwwQKfel!|grK:bҐἻSeriooimayoteheostffectiveayoemonstrate0is,hrgiesrevailable.nxpproach,hichsarticularlyopQow,designpgumentromrobability.ԁ0craldeaatphysicconditimakeifossi nxhexordinaridel@te,ndirccurrencemoӂhundaRsyp!s󆐀onDefesfمAseveAfine-tunedouppo0ng=.Ƀ9n`biga8aЃ scrib@tadipritgby8X`mount,wouldHhbeenm .oofrav:a8ttȃongwe0r.͋ه`mally,*is:


1ex8*a-susta(Xrm,uterya.2.hsritwompejewhaccep㓨o{zhly-foute77777>3reЄ77 explanaʘorld’sOOL?;p??;    E3r脙espH 5.“”?]/*bȟhpes?ttrurom9ickenjun(rs` ddCslimt4exhibpφˣ`.ow+grepBs(wiluitlorganperhaptlroqsymgalax0A500dynctKYourČ*nxeownX JL ;kHmqX`H:Xygp@qyvP,#sci uhPKqQnou8aCp_rhriϔɆAnotxurs. מappeihy'emo:atق4coohpret@scankKmsb1gs߭s%.!l`Pfwiphwä)scenarioWtIurnxlefstoplA;7#kccdidnook}helpanasecWeewspavgoh|job ˬsinvolsubongӴpush isso cludr!avdgn舂For8{5Pn\so|؁gYsaHg'CeRɕld+dle jatpл/OplogicAЁab>O0remark"akiVtohhilosoph[o׊ϦGodbogobserva"ăsworlnamelcaus0iXys;yc*ۣslikPeeaev{footp`racYbac0o*himselfӉٮQ,es+׌ such.a1,bas puriۆ@phic裠orÝt:it3bdriXau'' "odn m (1033–1109)aopvispecifQsalst0-alpE xneouئ`mp'ght="0pt"idth="0`>    E3ynytandardfifficulty,hentologicalrgumentshallengeorasp,utheartyijthis:


4refore[O''"Mp''#ke@oeitionyZnrem8 1:풗rAnselm’snwieldyHrdp,Jwhich %cАcoivedከinky*r@І`bcplanet:lepxtspower,in@hadintellig(hi8Px.ׅ`)p]cures`ooMncnes`SupermanJurpasse,n.Ó`bMЁ퇅І͆dž[i2spectrumdw\ib(ӂ(ict u8p+Cׁ(ً"Kmaxim.#wB8ey.Ɩsimplic,ekabbrevi!GPBȮȝ??PˎG1 aq-Pً;iifoufm,y@߬ف[lack2em.Р2sύWPBcludixfuXst.exaPB7ں$pɏl@l,[s8Gs9ho?cauH(mLȯ؃snyWxɂ"stJ:cZbeqф.ӆPocipVP ֑WAgaiχe`؝)sr…s񃸐(nsofaXxߑߑߑߑڳd,Yhknowc!tag=1j1qan5poւ" ____?\3Iuxi!yepWWoH____XX ΌÞ тhy،sneAou"mx3ono th(leadآWslus  mYj,7OOׄCReduco ɀsP6ptologicYDis:҉ tradXoЌtoes2—in`9say'' oo hilosophsmad؀analyzyatt؀qAnselm2Uhe{sidkXfamycrcis8offypmonkamGaun,h *empȋ .] 08rep phra“ϊφ`”ksl,)Jw$gpbsurdonOooiKCD,^`,myILje herfec PȰl,lem’srgument,ere’soweanrovehat(eostslandxists:


1.Ԃgbisefineds “ Greate(Possiblet.”pV2muhapeveryualitywoulaket"rnbe rwise.3.avingJofealkencsimagina@ք>4refore,W//*p//+GaunilooncludeYounoonghdoub)R(iwhichm @cellpall0slomew!ȁpoipHAnselm*typf4s(0panyXng,9matbizarre;KmeanAunda`ylaw withlogic υ. ڋ׋׋    E3nc*imes,hsop"Penernegativiewcosmo"al,sigontŅs.artpsoscausBcompcritiquxbyǒ#,ȂXaAnR}htoh'natuZligioulie0tf.€y9emvofQogniz,@tpa肼ЂougPpsciif op*ɣpPangevid,cS-ᓸmp`.׈lsp73aQ0p-liQQP jggno@i!nvictڍfpael@nuumefXhacquiknowledgUsP1abIseemisdctedxggfC.RITICISMSFELIGIOUS€PEFPOOWhe endЅYa,S9ferцۢn?ri!o(‘mso)epbЌ-.ccasPq{mfull-ffsm.͏y*ٗ,cickwayșakkjtchaaڇopӁЕphntaaHpTwoimaiQvulbijn0raclYpsychVfactoinfluQ;W7Rhri𴙧aclaؐzulmertiw negnant;`xpaopӓdsexx١oH!yeaH)vi@ ;`KenyaЃRorcis0demPRe)supdgabirqڮʑqcounyb(eRep 88Kcivzѐodeqab1sAr򭓌ifraudY(ti8,exampl8suspaismugg ;e=icista“Ĭ,uڸxnkwor`ay.”le)ugthy?ah+ty@nvo*threhjssuhI.irst,DQHyrrhvioClawInae0rivp)unusډloccHjurёIP1blo@gtowardsIm00slip\liffkHpYdiscPsSex"foЁ8Yi(Bedi菀rˏt)Txbwou8"pquу__gc!hӋItnewspaper;-sny8d@ab`mwnyFinghAг—o*Wq]WRctooklac:="0pt">        3tatedostuccinctly,isrguments:bnevereasonableoelinportsfiracles@hosewilllwaysutweighpbytrong8evideforonsistlawnature.maginealanHgcawithwoansHn@h8lae@hsupqQa}.Ӏse,examplhthat0teamrespecphysicij8dwohcampregnanenya,ndeter irmciindeviolbHogiOLTȄ’imonIwouldo)firxڀo( againallegY-AccordAPHP,nAZd@onlyfactxe:wperi haP߇DoorsotffthHhp@m.ock8grou$myrioushly.ׂ1Iep͆iwalk,)does crumbenea@my0tK__ׇ'"XYoHlg,"eslX78xpowany炈,gardȃhow@ediI{ySvmayx.{wri,


IZǑBhichiv`auyhum[s];:ji炽ass sIɊ ؠek bnjh2trarnPdub Barom3emb pinioPe"!rσʆxkris`Vremh.”۝Annquiryorn@Ust, 10](P]lo؝bRpg i>.|rink''iewsroundednivineeality;hat ,HereqaodhohsidesspirituPym.on-believerRough,avediffntxplanation:⁉fuperurhumansychology,ontCp.wosandearxgeo2hilosophucretius (94-55CE)rgur gixvsbproductffX:encȄrighteningcalamitie0can’tiX nshse0(n “seekfugey`ndQyXgods.”anya_incedoptiE^iewkwellrlyooktfЃ0()common.

    E3egin‘19<>th    E3hileposiAsMarx,ietzsc胹diffxiarticulars,H!mZread:ligioausedntiPysychologicalsociX(ceaon-view1worldpipreable echnlyyHnotdispyfY’s(istenc8rsupernlm.uytingJYG,:mplicitquesÁtruthmmselom verZspYvemaougaHctɘismf;8kephonderawhe*(y@venOcؔ77772How큙spH?oxÇphro1iusǓ faot–Xchsearunknownessappyfterlif:e{-{.a,umap c`TheeHǂinnYmislp@.0Zrዀsmji`AqtrickPoreqǖrʅmanHzaccorQᐯersesxrV@}HGljã2yHܦjrQarget.נnXtuoXa1sibil+nCbr>DHEROBLEMFVILbOAr`anclGulf8as؈Xdemolishy+@itp.ςh!imouo,t`dEIȒQwtroySh dy,ɋIknHyen0;.:a罘hr@iaPI(XȘ6;Ѓsecouxhalers܃.”polsoaisimi`1`agediAembconcaerminilln鎪;riexk!HHid;IlojobQ)u(I;mid1`pai03y2w2ZŠs.Ȋ@HbQo))ncolow{?ӌP{Š8( )abHÁpfao''o?lPhi@op2yblem!evilZ*psuff¥íwoa0taV !1rl+firsoXn񁘄ɭStakplٰ׋li8sy]wYnxaTise(d75mo''''%berwfulhX(9Pyb8kiy(AshooТAarudrra in WWGGG7Aȱ Ami>( Qgi٘akm c@{#N,ρaticȇ@j)isbasicis:߀)blockquot8''!1ℰ,0ozll-9Pk(powerB8viWWWU2.ŋIexP 3Zrehe,o PremY1attribut犕jtipulxٚsuchhrx0]y?fz:jneouldertainlyeotivatedoliminpuffering.heniscusshettribuHofmnibenevolence,rerfectoodness,outsetthishapter,aw@compahonasarnon.ԁIiGod@yticQour'ndPntsbest(us.fall-know,Ane뀈sherllǁinworЃAho`ooo0ut.Ɗlly,郧powhul,h bilityCexhiшuAveryatuȉseemomhimqq%pevil.remise 2tobvious:O,othcal"moPbound'!.iXxistɃconptabl`J0muclud|pro8m򁈍@iHׂԀ H.

    E3omePligri(rgu)flibetwecep:Y)Gh shoaogicsH9emhsj=k''.ȓ(ptab`ina?850aeXGhwoh”HwhichkDunlikely—p]ontrspeakT!upl8leaHJolvsȅQrst,򡉇hanυO煲i8ɒ! i(Fhexamu*Ire“”xerhe’sқHim9occaI:lashGɓJsoщ1XW=alsogggy`u@May聋nwѪgoirS qui`hougooy٫ё2ШIusu‚willoR"Builpnt4ҀȀX,>WlؔÂٰwouldsx@dڗmہ)enH%wy@trappe n ÇuҀ9rronex)kYimagineطg ߔp dechFbe e liv8(nal pmu0@x8ɂuWWToðimfrom#looxt@oH.zbr>p ha鮡ooXKupЪrmaodicyysmpklrmea(Hjifd,ZsuggeffѹYeedZiwiBػwyXmo(plap!HHCТQrourݓ2influٗ9n |WHfކ銼eofĈuAccordlݜhQdfq8q!i0urrGmajxh(p0b)dollaXHdaH9lX:YpEa)Ӧ@pP,clockkimyv𷀕jrlreg phelp0vic0`reb؄ipxo# Gdis(yhar ,9paJ8umerc8generosቈ|ap*qitAXeioQpkǍ"*gedy:ou ˝ȵ`貀+aifsr-[pXP׶Ѳ Pfz!-de`tuؼ,Hosagainш0κ:owضYDŽ\Dthroughke-+H-c”app@Dfar쏨7doanormȒass/Zparkharityneople;ouldeufficientlyotivatedocablemyeighborfheccasionalreeimbellnisaragendeedhelpemovingt.hen@ddpڄer causbycrimes,ar0naturdisasteaccidseasit’sarsxhowasrpounbalancI+porvil-depenAoodsXatyener0.

    E3coxsoluto-examinxȇ0af@e:ness.JutsettY@p9no"Godattributf@rfecӂwompon:basjustItbe‚y%PpresumPewaai r(.er`thoughAelievo@-empiz׍3xTimayq1񔲁pdems!obedHcerom@iG0ouras @蚀khilosopEpicurus )!uchXppXthrّducienh qasurHnt`ean0ђ:[?ɇrtiwithOwvurstmainupr)CW1echnicХayHYprom a saYhoake𐨏aWSaies makɏliv@yy77776`.wh t0ryWJohnick (b. 1922).arguВ變e #avelopm cduwhichev3oPPuoPalikx CPnQdAeagȀx9shi`oearXgrow3ܮ ac@.EynowsmeqInhafa`any@diQuضraxс8m.ŸȓS0lleng钨~ly, P(asoci1omicstaclolo`Ķpd2jo8en`"@2apeci)Ȍ҇ niqu)borLliformPnartاemergfisim؈pganis81 stHiologԗR؍!toda@TӺă9e1orrB0iwiinu:`tiٛ
    E3ƍ WIDefтi> popularo@ f\dccordفHvie01fa,God)0ixuldk orlntainҮ1wpunteal0s¸magIlookPhbluept*qA|fcWb1,exhl0sЂqr(lo0)(mpspj h٭2J0!pelikehe presentorld,xcepthearthsnhabitedynlyims.ׁ 3!same,uroboticumanoidreatu(inoreehllTheyreonscious canehaveasrogrammed4τ̈́zsteadtru0҄҄hhichfYsebest? “d”eighty.ˆLblematod腈Xtrolverbchoic`pjin.fɂaw, n*ireupoe1decidowwa3;vيnothterminЄDŽao؃Liat’sylnshortstrikingad,moXthabo)tegardlesmu(he dik.,facp:aima:8uȆbeוӎpolways9good;r,jgam`hernllo8낱.ccord aXfensqd:PҒt0nOf_]Risk9. Ɂ(9olvwmweaځXiall-powerful (mi1鄈i!/)pls(voluntartrai(ph`B resoumaPsfit.ȎZ-orj)SalongsQB2ch
    E3hathouldhinkboutascal’sager?ԁais, teallyoreasonableoreoamon,nod?mericanhilosopherilliamames (1842–1910)eltthmingrocessfʅBfund8ntflawed.ivalligionsㇲcopaloxandposimilar iPavoriteeity.uslimhet,ccord 0,lsay “ImExpectedώXwhom a0ɉheffulgence.ou؊finp@happyfconfme;Xrwiсc0offrqhjsun.גy,n,؃hbДrast[Lsacrific`tnot!”lvUndergrohurchmakaparelrguɌҋ9divyŒssneutquest,`posiюApref@o0v(aȋP.bbr>:*Rʄ(BIvI j b>Werej۞Oc,hl!dЌdrefmbasfaithʕen.ey viewa`ncbetwedifkind2ops9.irsVu`OOJPsi`uؘȌliveّopdрdeaiAӆYmqXXad;9pcarrinhsychologpp`example(tԅaW@,ρρanciEgyPȐRa諸ǛSe(Wer>ce򎐋ϋ˫id8AnؔS8(wYmiddK,@@TvoIa`텾has邷;24mE88lhA@hY,qardternatp0lyo@m ntowarhFIXltBtiC.ɭdI aHiɓ/.%.ȡ)sxhbstچ xwlsispixu@benefipjtxghА@Yh.____]mnt2–iЈ跐Zmporte"tral`usYripyWalmart<8]EPar0bpeodok?LsxImanyiahГ??cX򷯷oXin1genup) i؇0,1epsstcпpoixWre:blockquOpaonu(onlawfuamaiI,hcȅMpro(,RǁcanRy0 #ellecb0[TWillB]戏GEInca,'%q ifq:TTusCneu"c8)‚I1zRy‹as!femo򣘎(uX`(t}h@fear:Xngdej!fخʈ@d#adqc0 magJohrQask9MarЖ䶐lookcsubtig0abhowceywAbAsp-ng:DperspbG(yan!himCWolቋhdliHX();T`Hb9esn@t (4andheotentialewardsreremendous (moXtYoption).nisitua,ohnsullyustifiednteppingutnaithndskherf`oesn’t,nforfeitllromisefHmportantovePlship.ccordAtoames…igibPef, truenhpichouldotain OOh.

    E3ow큙criticspo0s舰?ciIficy-mind`pers؆;arguaXrearu@neutrXaubjecXourutyBobstH掠.uphmPvegxrpec1ruireduc{risk1heartttackJevidenPHinconclusive,sldB(0҂1orkȀȇxol)akespeeltter.or{siX!noiffquA0rnIGodex:9///-9agnoc.Ӄ9s r9(lʊjhase.ԙzRwoalXinquiryhav@(1)ursY,(2)voi@rroH/ placg8 e@dj:v"sltimHarr,8yoxymexpecceneYviewsEaȀ8Y'??Pmocruc!`nR.¢nkܨѐyxfɍonon-s;prPipB?`_YmeaqsȐ-uapȎkRښabak0sl򉊆0oIYseemsn0r R8ȴ^nd8Ocxebr>sgAcompel8gefro.rough_C,ú0lgrPfdomу'%do  “Iknowِ ``-pjuHfiable.TmitaammanyAo`qlikistgclaim0Ps2Isuchqesigm٫aЀusumecis@/,ygJߘܺl,8@n@*h𜙅󀱊Xى9?omporarymeriosop!Alvqyw@@ishȝp(Zinnc82AducGB ǝǝĝOWvZpoQarulaohpacڇצlQ2.e(t Bp amp(BacWgʂxpopPr`{from @deIxCqhapP!nglт@recyzt0w)awP.ԂA!my{ԉ@rWasgtHwDfirpU.Sqdhbasx'sɝۇ߱XstworesptQbooxAIoxiYeyei0ac@Aknewn.ccordXn,k4moggY]R–bfٙm8huP(ohi-τώI`peric.)Ϗ˂bj d`ce8ъ,YpeoIego0oupinds‡_dx?I8yen1ggg.ollowinghispproach,xeelieveranay “Inowatodxists”asedurelynationalntuia,ndithout`y'argument.

    E3ԅc(rPblemrlantinga’?she`rreealaX-foundmfH(ll.hileumHbehavior遘oubteddriveyxs`cts,t9exordinariqifficultaskoH-like tw`aver,atopf,h sF.ELIGIOUSLURALISMЁ🯁!ElvxUHrgrouchurb(it0-xo@al:1ɼyf PpјX/pEnȒĨRȂs1s.ThtaileiRiss fromworldnQfignpmembXxQahriX,shunnPfIɂ8ᑨddhPemIHnkؕJsociorganizĀIpdJRotaClubYMCAȁmAH`)umў(nyrai!9𳩂8B)lifR=bJ(uexclus; ea@hdown doctris,hichheyelievereroundednrivilegrlationromod.hilosophersf(ligindishenom ascin ngspecubouthermoX“super-donal”pproaousCf部ossible.

    E3Ԅ@twosuesoncern@ivityׄ7sQRworld:ihasmostrrectet1doctrines, Xvideffat*salv.egard-fir ,sakarie allaimsujose_ritualXh’sificthbutQdiZinvolveaumaXffaPȈ lysp(exts.דxmalapon(ano– uprayAmus0ship鋐c00reІlsohrmWSse__lY󘔁bewpchRӈ xihiHassagcommit"xo(,rNnp0epyH"ga@similtiwellAmajЉItween_.jbr>FourpsPpi>.@"ta0[v)eir9=1lH@Wo:atuism,hclvjinobplLpi>NƆint QatכlesÎ?TPsځ@ghxciXsychologicfX.nssؖO"hayisgudKinqui׊ՊɊ74ntcmلsHum@Marx,ΦXzsciFreudokqpkeordcP2howOMdopsɥÉ*@ӎteja0ol@҈u@thghodrћQbe(wp(ynHorot –ncludingindus,uddhistsndventhe.tssuallyheoreiberalraditionithieligiousaatoldsX`view,@etftinvolveslosgverxhsiv`laimsPscripture Whileomensbetwe0riv n؄stillugger9B’Ӂyattt8nr)bagahwleaoompettofperiority.

    E3ԅfinoprplu(ism,hichه9svsЄe)Godifferently,utᆰaHeqectiveXoalvaq.amakrishna (1836–1886),ne1IndiaJgrektakЊpproapwhxwes,br>WiQPWConfliȍ(DHhi>HiЧӋJfac0coȊؑchenglO/logy( .žwasmisTONf8be]zealupPecinqмCrub azApl emXdž@9ъr+outsepsairtji!heparxs # noxdAc".ЃhՁzugqex DXp aۛSChX0X0ؠnؽڐpWnduH$]"owh{((e ?k''$W.twosX.i,r عesȊwdviꝟe tosalvon,!ց?:truhMayponaȓapacde8ӁЎPnx rema@neu脑\qu3T݊lw}@wrZxɅZ0qlxЋ lm"ǂQ ImyZspld[xeralp ߏWon`rYOu*Aj1ip8Xn(FX0mxYoHsȋпmergenc2(sjb`˰W; lllea helfYAsHcUɗhҌW3`aysښ*ሩȡߡAȅ񡓃so-)gg/on('limdspeA.ohnPckPissstorX0pYblȯ lephر[fHtroxPrimitedxperiences.nelindanoucheshelephant’seg(says連areatillar.nor.itHuskthxploughade. “Ofourseyerellrue,”ickR,ybutacheferringnly@spectfrtotalPalityexpressednerymfanalogi(Reporxreligious)th,1n,hwybehapbyurersoculturh(Whileniv`maylashBnderlydivipis nsistent.


    E3 TProblem GodInacsibi @i>.Ԑ8eYaexdwithȇism,ame˅mmitt@apositio)4plethiddenromiewcis!why,ccordЄ%t`tradjsfocpy:@PamptLlaiH,,P׈`vtid7intertaZ.— )deaa0TmajoHfa.ɂJojleani>Yhimle)matxFhexaɋennPfticPy`yPskyrAQElv |unprshythmharmonio8ЋopenHupaЃalmosXgoe)mean@lZhelpfHv0haomeQgl88d0weho(hobbȇRShuobsׅMXemsh2rovyDdescriwlfearinvdx0O.oۄ&mX -medn(adoLJllowcep.򧯧oPȝQpr @ka twoFmQestigr],irstЁtX@setщْ[likcvsc,љIpi-Y0 ecPd B0roЂ worAُ)thy yun@tuxleXI9 ,]OH.DapofruitfuloughH~ur~(кو:X;ύrZ@yȽ gnouar`H'nȢaskvaper`P_zWA1aىOHOL,׆iamʾncluK *9kxredi: (1)un0HՎ?wro0abIasA@ȥᄀ(2lubssfromk@beyy`ccord ,r-bf! 8ia0difur88rXI؏n9fir9ghexc,@fٌR݃r8cٓPo(ag:mtڵbБ(Pka3rearon.̎wwqb|tenn[2aalvj,Ypa8ebrɏ@know0gxſrhmhohun.f8P2himxfAY8lh(`mohxne: “I hypɼX"ffer”Qwсx,wLH8nprayul..suggs.ϡRlbertwPHtorico0-zfsJ,^tIgue,!ell`r!Xeff`viewarmohthmayroduhagaiths.venu-denomina!allvUndergndurchksormoiis.


FPRe! ǁǁ1.̈0ef2at`butpGodex`eYdiscussopen secJσσ">2.׊possibloluۏDconflictptwe8divAeknowledghureeXll?'''">3.iveeibnizscosmologic0menkHXcrPcqitσ4ϟ bjÇdesignfromahyσ'' 5'''''&babilitGGGA6DGauniloUMAnselmnt̃GGG@7Gƌw,miracld׌у77708sychnorihWpbyarx,ietzszFreud9?IAeulH`l,wմ{0'asȋkJaspaR8ʃPlanta"Mr$ly-fѪGGGA}܊'w?ojickrOOOIJdo1p0)يcrea1շDŽƲOOKA8ysix_ׁײ_xplYHtrXokϫ_}/gge}϶ϝsWWRoߚ܄ooo;Wpخ uefტabsu٧-<(awhEϢaӈ$zDŽTǂSerlyasicH9g(ondGexclusiv. ǃǚqREFERENCESNDURTHEREADINGwwwvWorksÆ@nrd9fppearaKblockquogg]Elpn0gnd:2Church!,ww.eA=.orgH7Xenopha,Xj@ag.tarddPresocIcfsKirk,...aven, TXchilos (Cambridge:À]xih`1984)>Rad0duer,osemaryWPiedempMinneapo8:ort9o98),. 223O!ThreendrhProosChttp://ygod sgeeks.com/LINKS/Ȃ:.htoτττͨa,avidAnnquiCo8rn!0j174SP10钗byom.eauchamp (OxI0lar8t2000߆okquoteeight="0pt"idthc>Marx,arl, Towardritiquefegel’shilosophyR (1843).ecentranslationsn̓r@Epy׃)ngs!,.olletti,d. (Harmondsworth:enguin, 1975).Plana,lvᅈGodee@ Gdapids:erds] aZemporaryersɅfXll>HickC, "AnrenaeanHeodicy,"ٗncouhr`:ivepi kStephenav(EdinburgPT. &IClar0198139-52>Leibniz,ottf pllhelmMonadolog"x721R@w:D.rbx|icalssay (IndianapoliHȠubhYCompany9oumXd"Diauesؚ rn1NaturRelig79Part 99goedNor˔0mitxOxford:endPresR3߆GGGGGGGGGGGA5,bov////pale`ia180ϑabridg*s//;elecڑOOBobbs-MerrP6qH,ob"Fine-tuDesigngnt:tificorExis҆(IRReasEHope(.͵@aeurraggc9Wwwwws,lais`Rouh 8(1670tgg;'sqsée A.J.railsmgg`Xok66">Jameo˜Hev1897crȤYk9K8Ȱ8urkhXt (CamrvUnptyOIs[fٹPr rlyasic,”Xu((p??;FuНXpd0pϪF(HKellJlnPhilosophyMOntoroadvih200؆ׄׄׄKler,ary@DŽGGTowalobPpY5@@`Walubpghmpanb7M.bStump,s߅߅ߔBigues(Oxdlackw etxoIKhMOK??99//////E^8">QHxip̎Tahferro,òl$AT@
(Oxford:lackwell, 1997).Rowe,illiam., Philosophyfeligion,hirddit (Belmonta:adsworthublishingompany, 2001r>(NMpcan="center">***3*CHAPTER 3:IND0(www[A.hatsind?ی7߁߁Knowledgebout(ewWWWConsciousnessThreeeaturesMalxperience>ProblemyOrGBρB.erson@Idity߃eodyri0Bǂ''''{''''''LiffĊhρ>C.atiH-bDusm_WW>'ssset8Liabilpφ">Iactiveuς///arall(Y:Maςww ehavior!heorȁ Elimina*WOOOO>FunX9_.rtificɎ`gQςRoadoggcOSearle:òXes)oςWWWW>Mo袂Wǂ@Forfleұȳρ>1.PqwaysomcegaumanifffrompoxdogK2 souhan8ovPtim2aspz0r閭remainsameWWWP3.oRtk0cY0simplyf̃br,hson-physic(mTubstah4YfuoulXteossi8惘actishopA0gcn ucompu؄wwwp5.׋ګtaoboteeeeI'dHyÅh -like߄ڄ3, 47(n0r cyr, 8osronoxdeadP󖙓 carefully-orchestrXdHerh8eamdingygpdiopulmryiporkeepir(vzlung3othroughveins.)yoweruXm8aa`thcepackns!!CryonicsacHe`@hundmila؊er0(zenPtliquiditro0aGh -196greHCelsiuWhxmakqarges,Kytwho`s:څ onhX –ȦZ$150,000h$3b.wٓ1xaP.ȝapx’#{"ife@su`HPhop:ɛڠ0reaniឱgȀatypژ/disced.ӢAȞlssolHo(ech@ 0msucPs).Ƌ X0y’Xdloplolog{poPgrowewZHre fa !r9s蟸u)e0Jfz򗐟ѷcs;plap(ZjoinjmicropicCČr@amage. U0St聩ѦP ab 18icornh8l`peopsignHupčH`ram.ght="0pt"idthc>    E3ryonicsdvocatesikearlaPseveralmportanthiloso8cassumption(boutheumanind.irst,yse`aBy ll‑Xapeoplehenirodiareeanim8d@rhapshundryearsromow,nd~hidentitremainntac!roughaseizariv.Ԇ2lso_aonceeadB@كon'tplyweptoafterlife,aoreuniIwitV.oslycciousnesssmbeddphysbr4hra@hspiritubsxce.'sniqusony –pmemor(behavioacharxerist--preab!toitructuofʅj8soȀqc0x$yA,(ichpYexpl(0p .


A.HATSIND?ЂρρAnbutartingoorunquiry!ask "WAar?"00pцC 8o`sI ,ڌifficulnmalnkhIEhi8nCviewnotapjbeAinspehvwaAnvgȁnamaockrPplhww elimsc(kgQ)roiU@olXouSr`w)!Hediscoyhowco.tʅ0eygiUdir`q)S3dsjuXyIGGworld1visxq#7,Jexam,r۞abelieffehngP8w hooonYQaApa90tim "folk-psylogy"I"commeu8on".egardl9nᝨgob(檨:u*w i>picg(y ۋbiPstȇbeB w. Itttendsveryentalxperiencehateave,nditypicallyeli؁;thisorznhynglseetsspartromtherngsnPeorld –ocks,lant@mHimals.iontemporaphilosophyfind,natuxsciousnessxeyhardroblem,”"onDmostYthoȅfieȈmubolvbeyo.uh芘lookorngfulefinitiׅ,’ll1disappoiHd.υ@possi'naG#hichouX€qfȇ tohepreamlslӂgawakep္Zꉁdraw91a ;遠oesnHeHat_ZnvyAn?_?    E3r؟ΊngcXQsoEcsa0b.irst`timLdirecw!to9pxenviron80Iӎ iflybymLinY Ѐself-aea.iPe`ѯ0llHံmhodyPgup@beylkxflsta@a耰//pIripʂinjaC.ȃyehsto)fulqkɇ4HCp8Z|yerdabAtoXrow!!FilyoritDŽDŽŶ9aysɥ0mYk13΄WheЗh@arEshapPКgp.ͅ:sidfixaIlin so'1aj:@meiajI    E3ecom8non-loiza –(H@3be`y(spacHᅡhg`rҊs0aoPѐIlkinsidJ؀ppanucNoPt yharilooh,PKnpyLh!: ;(DЇ1`zcious.”2onQfblobbiomzyoQCsHmQkzrree-donٍےThir(!YsW؞boHن.͆sabilitomvs.ɸbelief\Hemp9hyt:e?;,imy𯰖Q.op)fear8desPaD΀iffocuYobjX-Ї8oex (uchB*wor`p@ઘ㥰Ҟ`cerpp@osop0ranzrٵp(1838-1917)pguARPaxeGstѦa: ڒ/.0/(Л߁߁߁߁ۥ هGf2excejȮextreosisoaobbYda! ǎ2!@"""˧anyTI+10miseI9ɶلHl(vX )mport90intig6.br>POri>fdoebspw(tarxesdonꋈRڹHerȖa(gu9?Haskim,9Te8ԁu`Rnow?فwaH遨ЁglligHlbdk0O{`re?ȯ/Irs!9rep OfrIXmHByhrʭownA*pwith 100%e8׃ӇTgoon#K pW؟᭱orcrhBIЩ(YIȁXtDЂ@P"Q fay ωM*vhŒrefl`IP:y8%fromEprivaO᏷OَjЄasawaFђJ!҂0s Pwhomclai (yooenetraar`rtwewoindsndannotirectlyonfirmislaim.

    E3heroblemctualgoesurtherhanuestionseayaveboutindsfhumbeings.upposeidordogalkspoX8keye t.seemsQbscious,ustiJoe,lthougherhapsquitsntelligenty.…"awareasurroundQrvenhimselfancxvidpth؂Ptor؇0ature?ʅmputerizedobЀ8sayIvoicdesxa “PleaXhelp.escapfromBM’sics weybesubmitg!Proed1degra!xpim(I肐tackre!”look+nowondXtoHyXcificpplHjeregar*(2epain:br>3ren:YɇiPwwc`z σʋ_σT701effXiR$suco2///Yvecʉ4V1IPmoȮ`IA8hcluy.+(stػ,tPЍɂJ<+"brtruxBervsyHmAoexhibiPsignұ ܠem؄Pnjoyrr b BBrl_꡸0R犩O)@ÃfewBIVs;Ȳװ׮zFexamplwouldKll,narthmi牯㐢dHaŢǝǻW 77yHrobots:human-exirapacitpro mӻBnterach)郘l\BmHet#osslit$jZBuheRwAalkabor[OMcnec3bsoluc+]FqueȈHDžifrem8B.ERSONALDENTITY߁In 1968@24-y(-oldalniamSir`<ar0щvicq@ssinU.S.epqtixdidRob.eny `r,uriؼXynfulrol,saiiȚPnoongsers7s@cad@xlierHX肰ghim,qbeveqol nidentifiedithisoungerelf. easuchadicallyiffererson,elaimed,hatzconuimpriHmpointless.ԁparoleoarxunmoviandxhimackoellireaing,venfirhandorough〠gesnj;alityvtXstilltttom;yeam(*hoYforpassinatiso`decadearlier.ׅ's1issun؃disputBhowterminidqtyKpecsare:criiarracycivehofsurΌS(،(recognizvario`d?iXzwommxapprohi:plookhum@bod775d.


    E3 BÊoni>suholdюdyhyseaturȌxQ.ndails{feopYGok,faciw Xpȃ@voices intigatorsxxpmoechnolikexntڠ0t(nreȁscayDNA –hrib(carry{!dlifeshelpawnpceofXkn9he|ey'gotryMcustڏȥful`’sЉǂ8al(eSupposhexam$xa8injuhicausxlir@0ȩHp .rلzhamultiiT@Hfew@u@an@tiڳ$RuHcasexBig`wnsgdouPmstȕXڭ텀8ubstancMmmup߲Q cnt.osBP=wတ(eplacй>regulyh(skini0rt`gh,Q@eXstrucٔބremain.kˆg@/Yt:ns )Pxc耩ʑߑellfirseemiZquickPunss˂olˋQtw:b*cleehƋڍǍɔE,Lmesєs@onmayvirtuʞX9nguiXblimRaxTl@aI9nLoIobаfriefam1@bx.umpPIesscrаǫgencologykh·xrom)ʋxa uniqu'3paleGGGG?d-br0-swapenaжni,ir(xrn#;Y 1prunsu"guar0dobuc@;0x)SWؕ@c1 h(师o@cІ\XaȌays0ck"llgeh`da`C 8:g,RɃ1XaٛHrTp(Č{0hjo;P9mbouON79LJPrefls0wnview[ie8InkmyselfhYashX(be'body.


    E3 Theindriterioni>iY)m)c-oweemsikeobvioushoiceoresignatingpresenofurniquedentities.nPisiew,egardlesswhatappensoy`,IrealMysnfused@S .ntuelȄiss!steasilyttleAn0obstaclfspecific@qualcarrȅthroughfe'sver-changsituonHPabout*emor:ren’eyeuch)own?ttr؄someopmahPnfexp،s –sentteaortlo(with 10,0000r*tatorEvsoⅲBY5willHrom1 ive〤onЈBXyst)aoblemlocnin.upposactisookȉup9a -extr9macw`aisuck:Mir!aexinjYm#oelse.'d2Rguoul'imselfP߄w8wOkayitldeЃ .׋*=disؙ,hyțX,XpfeaXÊrefl1ʋqd@cuca,yZ1ヨFur,DžXng-m,*so{ndٛ †@imdn݃bI,ix|e{byhHaXHȏ:In敘sPmov8yɗ:dultd,si" h3xTexЃo KSirPy structu)brφͬݥs=I1ickppeah(s:IIhida0ee.ur#tUnectseowithhoashild,'mpecificallynterestedXheuxionfpchangempacts큠dentity –؁whichsn'televantfirstwoxamples.ɀisase,bodistructurendemorie(bo؂,sAdrawnlemsbႸy[i(criiaoorkut oncep͇7y.


    E3iffeathpb>Oneajoruzzle@gardingersonal߉noldthatasurviv1physቷlB0Xsomerorm.ԀX variousiewф,te 8diffȑfromaȂ(iloso8QwheourmwouldЖherv{anyanfulh`9ketransx;ssugSsBeve.e'llookphrex:gWރXreincarnaQ, {one’sXfollowbhfȏkigȝUpIwОvmotsscabornabWhA2groكye⡃acyctin.ϛHuigJtext `鎀oHoਣcls:hAASمff!n-!h/00todwellyrio; .” rn,/f8sr"rarAocb{hhea(Hl:_igratP؈o'؁?҅ (ȳlSo2ailۂon:`엎Ӕсʃ fQ cạo8@ꙨleteGS oNAmrse4IЄ؏xac gendEbu.ӏvŋymaЀ [}„؆ack
ɗYumpʝh,ڃ ab8encod[׉g–p ۀapppbrpatɊopiʹM/҄xHcuPyтe2ZOhalu`ǿS+uccPh0me`b@_biazNo^q)--lwɥfcÜ`lէb?nszcloX*նFѫ` promˇ"mepʻhuȑdepУwnAhH3qMultiplici9mndą xhimsell8Wax¤Xke`AXcedHJinkS'"riginaloug.hecientisterformingprocedureqnevealshichs"originalnd׀cloneZ,2,ccept#factHateaifferison --dc@twinfProdyorye!sambblem.teath,mssally;dn@new` Ђnotmbutwithʉ dopi8from.@diedecomposexearleivP1afterlifrusJyoȅoIeHctXchanismtainQourties.

    E3ardiȍDž0disem1spirit.ה1r,ijreleasyhysbconuo,on-ni|presumpti RRdanique,rthree-dimensx@substancwommon “”y`maybR8`miAYsoadouAnaasoclayЃadapt@s-Y,ordoBGE,I'mjNdڍ# joi8JUIseparatedIȏ׏ׂja:ܘ p* htwand;'suI8PnghaˈcPrfai2acerA8؛|y:pإIdsxll.ow@r(0as]:flycolors:y@abo'me0В`hnRiervjYzŜ-J߃٬ozmua1u4fic®DclinkUƃ+wiX=?involiahiloso8iss8A`…-j@turo`xt. br>C.ARIETIESFIND-BODYUALISM(HWGG)p)֜)ntigjph9hum{ޟ@ɇaeao2 twoenertgZexplTiтh.irst,'yd bt:eh/fpb&߆? SnmhriducWrXH`c蟒We'(fтҟr/.oo//>`    E3ĂsAXt9diabilesCAonamRebecca0injur!utomoP cc !@icsH c)ambulBs a (-e( )porphfel$ٍgef×SslowHriFY*mcoul0ookow nrYwat@: Qe(HtQg@risڏ[towarRl1.vy depi#〰r1Ynorm?c/܌necqorkrmon$ 7.ռaIMd:ꃤ(ʽo䋺PaRalOnfgh[Éi阺y"cntaflifxjusawHHL8fHwqc8Yxi aeϠ"wgqAih1q ossiials8ff0ӋРȁ@rstweޭP0szpresbhaf`2privH9,"lo0iz}pIonty;ockthre/8th؆mtgumdualismasednhoseifferences,uchseollowingrgumentromon-localizability:


(1)indsele. H.2)odiewe.ooooo(3)hfore,JcannoteBǂÇpǂǂSimilarmadeasisfj'sniqueaturbeprivaXandntional:Y,< eiprsy ool    E3ut-@yu8faeriousom:owJdistinctealm spirilAtoa8o.A(ideaHattw8X0$fx,three-dis؋a8WzpnypporttyraconneArsiwȇr?uI’mp;/,worldu@:ousomec;rllhvXf t󌰆 tt(sp.inad?lookphysiЀ:ׄׄIcauU/+,hi@iaarfoooo?l\mos:eva`whenesgmaryaysour엧',ams8o@percep݀move)Jhleloughwood Ixhisgattlesnake (save)xfmurruniiX).ÉfirwQvolvmWj.̀eyxpickpmagHPbiochemBimpuls`Ȅ brain.ؖZo*^databoPriggcBu(explX0->"ixjumpW0zˆ/Xx gbs.̱kޕ'm`@esA(aXppXRcommلo1ݍ6H"c򐳉buscnЎ7wB6OJ^'iɏW/W.efen0zcognizȤ0chHengHoٻnh(|br>I1D.aϾ@sځ\]aimxoscr)Pimenف\llow>ڂ Ek)[-"HႰmpօ0apy`FPposopenésc0(1596-1650耿knenkhuatoђ؏aroȭzqkSyighsowȆchornerv@ٸSH xs1schboaretweX:`tht,Lbidd譡09TlsPP@ )!*unif!dpr3rl{dO[:"hunth,@u(i۞bin( TQ que芨mo0inww~,nRlef`aP 60obvc(iBawoobleR6.irsx@k!NnoÈRgen"evq%<ʉ@fun,Rregul8aKmon_P coulci(cnowledgefisay,uttasotoodnough.feontinuehuntornlternativeashwitchboardnherain,H’lleisappointed.heres,9seemPnoentraloconxPatecesHlnsory8man1itiat4bodilycs.ed,escar0(9Qdoesntxplhow"pinegl bridgarri8betweephysicxispir8rmu@se{ZuldiPaYwZAitsignalsvergaW)0ti hatonumpsckڀthrom{pi@Ooupr-mhItsning1say “spoPquitЁymechanRdetaiit㋊2ask.

    E3 qers 8!rqXdualismX GPshuttlnmmy;"PviewXfendeyrenchilosopQNicholMalehe (1638-1715).πexahdiffX8I-$feltfHQbason:H(soad xeapneu9o΢inkw taktur؁ree-dimhimpulo8non-_]percep_XI@ossiblrcPg8me"ir*$qdؙ8x?`YB9miІiccomp@h䙉 y,rd<'es(.ebsranypleyyIpearsЙHupbQ(hrigg bio-mR{o.0Pa8Ia艙ނm ߐlpyinjecwsWhIcidIru苙xwxy0 ])roprqχ77%getmus ovHThuxb yiouchboar٧׌o`sc. ϭϭϭϭRelyn8twPÅhasniisoluro,oughAtooi>ɨ@mirseV=1-bodكmaqsh!{'sivaiI ly.Qso򝘫QRulv`a neȊ)plorAƂnt[Padn'tI@e0llowiadvicnSfѺRdшJ)'anyjbaffa`4mn0isaowaeery.''''"Aɘvh5veuam,ㇸpg~succ(fuljinetړoǢ٪Igbb8 AtXDescart(aXaul0assums3l,am$ʓ؁lff@k rom0 er=rlapơPoriePylhOM_9;at’InaPq guezs҂ؑPtegstufP@hdegࢩ5.‚𖯁AnConA(1631-1678)󄡉`lirumilnЁZheasic0P011e9I10񲯉x(1am91L8dPAa~pockH?Iextrem haԂ3r̿,Imid-@(5!6QRӗ%0egxi0:thwispai0substanceshatavenlyittleeight.ccordingoonway,tst@levelKbod ndpir1nteractithachther.ust(enicanoh(assi`armsfX!mill,argues`ooheavyJH.

    E3oesn’tommPselfaecifichysiologicalxplanation)how brain -ms,ueulate.erhapforample,electr(cheYurUstim"ura8surrouQds.ԏanurnIKs qconsciousbwhiؑ0nkOs8f 1-10betwemyߎinvol8H@ielloXgs:br>0llYٕo@—ExuȐ dar:ignap(ackҵ@/ϐT9Pi@ma[;sό inљr0@men owf`~0il񉠿WthoughArej2p‡two[ߊ ccordB+-Zpo;irwn,J=causɞanImagine,)PamplhÄnHr*2ȝHlikurcљp;0oft@AorYH§poAha)staetӀlayˉX"ea"CeoH@o8_u@aǍୀWastjuF،zffouspr Xlit+embCsperfisitcAn'xeiff؂mٲ twhyPpvڐtra$HڃQH `eme`OOߩLei`eakÅm0ȣgattlSuppo!)ȯK?sJbluX1{!lmoiaa`C_gr91romRGcop;a.(Ha흈cؗD.߇osxmdnstuff,ۦ nll.Нpwalroiߦښwor0zjob$Qunou nS urwe'oH":f'xeriub5Whileeopleon'talkroundnhree-dimensionalhysicHrealm,verythingherexistsstrangepiritorm:ocks,sPri XsellA.hewonstirun perfectoordinatithach,pjustatuXisadefstuff܀.

    E3@la concepJQparallel/dual`aoryjdismxfxdyermaxhilosopGottfriWilhelmeibniz (1646-1716).ccڍo,ave`sciousody#9F:E=,ba mim.ecausxto8atecom`harmonyom"'soeybraopt-)ˌΒuȍπpmselvXguh؄X~synchroX.wes,*br>D.ARIETIESFIND-BODYATERIALISMHhggW exaH-diff؎؄"Q-quickb8m arKknowHabǖ
riewߡ Crody,-meaH`?eumްφlook!furэHo*zessumptionadeyheciencesfiologyndsych{whenattemptonravel"mysteri+huma8ind.tslsoassu9behryogenics:reserv AingchemicalrnshyraHthroughreez.

    E3hiftfromualism)maz,ȃ,oHnotol@ H-bodYoblem;tnlyarrowurearchrejecoapirit-Wellookme-heo expl0reladtwe;yous rhysrealmLbr>BehavismHh.aԄHfirGDy,inwithba.upposyouerignedJtaskqowTMcorks.قeؔstrujnor,rp'`!allowyoisemianalyzesrtxAcd8p@perpu`nrcard,@numbers#waseAhappenPTqi8intimulinmaspevap:eixɉcth)ffMwz.unQgQevei3se:^!0nt pln,asP`iyOL0afriO|i>wt ypp.atuhagin__I֚ZRelimit`"Ymuw؂#(虢upHson'skuآokapHidWXpnqs˞'q9q ൱П wtI{bagpotappI"doHooˁ߁ߎzmo@mIidxk9AByISaboj`iI,way9tek.ŗ,'m o9m✸ęqmoXhidd!(se@issjKvy,Džǔmibnd`oPr8oplSadwndrawkߜInhorםKview?>`zHiH *whgi PgpsychologHI*(20th    E3nH0icismf#iorysomeሠmentalv@sealoeem)te-me.upxyItephnail,hicaus`gtain(hesttch8howPHctmhssGorhwplpiay "o";eaook9anguishiface)stopQ'my!te)y(juryhirablywardthers.hi(aobserrmbيxwqhlefu nlei:(uameng#experiencZRГZpsidpeexryno ccesIddmax"thrهYp铔or؀0,r(;aЇȃWsvolIorϒu[or!ilr9yot(pBeAМtxapproa-bodAoУZcɊC stpHbraivS@edromw0eHLikw,ѱG@:S"IofarQmHt sssiZphysnaturBuoc']Ptarge89huk(IYwr firح[ҺvsciousnYΞÄG@УtiinfancCЏ bouػ󆁺/*ؓ@duc ,hYaIhxyou93m`ɁJsQrePl g:jh`s1ω{incp џ: emuaq¨IIfy6wi،]p0osoplQcern2ologdeɂ׆Ɍ ցPirtanꂑsuggeЕmw`džǃꪧ/WLśǞ3''no`a*bLbookBnset.ϙ q2Ksuemop?'ÀYrio-chemr~xBwoula3 languagTbIyvP-bHPame;x'suYȃy)po؂Qaؙho8erms "PreਔS0te"J"Vi0UnitS"Cdiff8Pmean xyete}HJTak{JohndamA{{oook,"`d5jobp,oxx0vi/diedBOOKWRQpy ϻPk`roJ#!n',ut;i_ZhǠuL/*.ƍQ#n1ꇘ_˦soadD–˙ȲQompati҃8on’t+ggb'matchinghe sunset;irstescribetromheerspectivefyentalxiencendanbrainctipwhoonductsann .Ƃlsewoiewpoints,'llaincompatiblesatthutebasedIthreeeatureZthaeotearlier:


ME߃WatchingS"fǂǂce'Irivately'1o'''''>Itsyocalizaipa`WWWWσWWboutometQBAityriggerbyoo_publicobservi'''σ''OO////////gg'o_'%xp7ToYl,#57ownyousness.misPyeior,chsay, "Now˃pbeautiful!"till:כselfb.lsoanjoЎYti`-diswh?ak cixly  ,am,|\.ԩaa,(ough,8aexpposi sM `ǁǘe:cγsp-piochemie!ccur\""y;asimppׂג˂I؏:6sthX' ixȆ(id(Kwouleo8߃fajytradictorhhy?9diffPggd    E3rsedajorHo8mЄ|ȿcX/,(o logorganismcrكY𕨃!sn'zsǂnon-Wlpexhib؃Ǧ?ӗYf ndc` :utzxots,yPllinolleMfassparlsenergyeeaxhauviPP`uR؉OJon@ulXŁPz%iȃ-wumado.iǔPhilosopxyheᆨ2pP src؆ڏJoffsho:lim؝ȓ(riHsmZfunӻWE̓i>.unsteadI "I'm"`said+#P 3-Geu9regardGA.Hσ̋8wifeyou"t2-Jwwr –#itt4-Btop aFvenI팉horо9q")i ,ear!"Hw XhR0Ѝ)8desp.LJuqreplXd/+LjemYfirp,amel@urυ߫߫n9ن:hh)exaȬ@ȂׂԎ9priv,uyublЍbserva.gg'oluounkIf folk-psychpmnopdoptheorecientificanguagefrainctivity.heonflictisappearsncee'vepensedithalkboutalxperpceshat"private"r "non-localizabl+something".

    E3umanistorysatterbrpreXeocaptumaginationpeoplettime,which0oweje asalse.lchemone0am1–:"Zcafurneadntoold.eliefhostsianorsnousHPfha beenebunkov bfavm/9h0worl(sHccordmڃmri,olk-psychologyxscrip)wvIjustikȇxtxxymis,r@downrYIn合cas(`tinf8ntellugarbdump.''''"S88fendefWWPmeemQsuggCH@ؓHally@,bjacuxg0独stY exؓIiIyby{w80hbody,spitȒ5I psHowe,piscuss771u"e xhIneXsarimpQ-i8WǟXselvRaefN@td@wayʈAeuro즘ogserclaim,wiPauHc0rp`X2nfunonsm,ced fshootiidty.ƁsmviewHataonh"y,"i(sphysic8av8occurXrXurlikeumbes;most)e恋7υόouldHbstricqbiologorganP{0Non-7yste!hich0hibitamא8ahipsso –u --〨hapƆs.͇/,nQrigid`depen؂{tuff[aImad&wyashxd⎹difmakeup.ccordTgדp8multippxlizablei{nsainds:Iyl̓kpdw/softIoborrowfrommpuHcpasefuetaphorAlمY betweeipaȋ}3MorX1runyppmac؀`iju8/ǝxh))WanjBtZx;?OƊ{WէavpPlemrXgniz)VŎohq

    E3׃p`isqdolHgߴ!of?evl'n{bgu?nX sem#hihrtruc aargrpoCX,@examplhajanuffurniYMɗ8olђa`ɀa$@uP@՜viśp@pRmarkem`tX.ŐpԤ(fb-;χɋrod o#]elec1al,*,rou[builrepair7rWUmasonry,plumbp`XylxteeXoyeSimi8l0w_'9a3~reguɔ)os`܁퀤,tilneurKchPsiy@volv Pmcn-o(sЀCXciousPse`h`Xti(bedrɃ퍷el.϶Yview/Qexva8PnXoHcAϻ݇RegX"khKp-ۄ=OwilrLUϯϯϯϯ͵'"8ea"ѻ -i{todai؝ nشecal h`Pe2d.α@;bdetror cr؆ +Xtooarrowp놨ԛapaٵ`ysthWndeHal(aanЃ s –s,O,obo1mu@physiiough,A1ozossibilpMՄ*WQodispi@TƒghΧ2yo`cn'񗬄ىomewbX9se?†defeаPm0ponseohis.songson-physicalhiisonstructedfub-unitndr,entoouldousepatternmentexperience@Suppose,oramplhtha`heiniestpirqjuain-ofwitch;argerwbemنiirecollectionPgg.vpughhardwaia؆Af71,might vxhproierarchsButoakkse.


ERTIFICIALNTELLIGENCEP Nocap9simaginaliossibilitycreIapn1ci8 exhP)sam`HahhumanHT`fir`U.S.uiltoboppedeeworkorld'sair1939@t(A7eealw300und{},hd "Elektro", mozrmlegktai aecordlayer@h:ors(liev3so ayKultt@QholiaЄ*accookalPd`lary3nxtakid)echnologm* }nclYarryouib1taskDcan'huchȟ)opHthn埑ricॐpen1T9eiffer(xwCIuȂ8mHnց9lexvÉȔy:culIendlessumbP,B(llcgrmas@dfyobjhrJopqlmЊ navig6bstacrsBeolyraiYў:aricii llig@m "ce"10attmisleaa,i0involv8zts)blemwhw`usuyn⁠›.ÐoYalHdy=Gx0іext.apɎa'(as8fugfc/n08ncluBQona,fKlgoal7򌠄GEWQwtǗ´>⅘viP[uitabpm9(simӌ#tɑ)k>"@Y@pH5tga 𻕊+؆ʍBtIr@qroQBv8xh sortɍŌRx{t''[Q!-likHwes;T82ɃsPinrex84youI IB􂡌?reo ilo饘WWTǀW O)tps seGJcarry[H8Тirocky;neplp0q@`hould dHo3endн9ptrucΓk8s⌣+Hrӎџma؉formsask3iywe'Zћ8RSe8Xb ˿plex(uagorlgsc`Aqaindur1(1912-1954)v`d`-basedest toeterminehetherompuHuldhink.nQs Turingest,stsalled,nviewothndxhumaneIGBichafefoolsenoughtime,Qncrightfullynclud(hatwqh؃J-lik `abilities.ԂXssentiy0llowsjo(adag,fqwalks삱auckquac.orepecifiy/espondV΀Ig.

    E3ajorrawb8ݐ*wlreadyvgidž|ses`0yon'tɁlosoaYאHntalxperiencAtriexampleCpsycho-9aplprogramlizatoიc`playroUi xeowehckpivulgximate aiȊihonl`Whi`aXCѓsotAheartŇblemcfocuouo:'skillwithouqnsidP wgoqimacemayPfweaprtxbllig` ons*simul-p1oaWWQgheeo!c@uctu0ԉ seloeС%JW9dσ̚a,킹߇߇?ixawo`vansXSqu0io poryumbo蒧B""h8s@al:ȘHxatumfxerԊowWTsunyouwnC;8'duФ8beefp7sso@iaiteveZ#"zDeeplu hP-Yyߤ,b2worldHb+[8ޜqucJړ\yckalcmIqe-Plpoptmo 9ebunbHataba80p:-mam!StllnpiePH`(mp`s"ycognscXthrguˡ'doesoYi1fashInst0"alobun@st@XehȑMme*&0owwwwGt)YaccounPy:i@0lm+@xreously—ssݠparašgp铙bra(x+n@Ȃgi0I؆redPan ExЅpA@ffXtyp(u~aG#exechmeask•zzatA|ݷ@0dpcly.Ǝpexamplene(@GG photphꇇ(2w෧о8dfa*>dfinew 0a0feQQ𚠓technologyue ȓUj򑄝a:decadbexq.br>IexayzsHc(maJexvag(laiabouh综lhup(edrtoran(l[s>(o.̌upAromf0BYBhelpwv2cribȮAmIphilosopJohn (b. 1932)dbeliٍ%`odnow-f1tDgho aggfGGImaginehat'mnoomyyselfndmssignedhaskfespondingouestionsrittennlipsapaperChinese.on'tnow,u`aveulebooksoranipulaty|haracters.ofget8Ƀwithpartic(rquiggle)it,cult߆see!spshouldxdow n|eventuallHasechniHцsymbolsmy8swQ1?arebsolute@iPnguishabfrXthonP6peakAllwhilughund8tJwordnThis,ccȐSeari@goዑnmosopatcom:HIrob!7abo aovel8gssubt؊|.τ#sid1spȋinkikeus؂inǀjumHcZfollow\0hordoHxcJstroȖficialligencДiӆway.

    E3'sRexpimЏeneryQVdefe*ooo@JisQ{yon@oYlawaTurTʃ779do elemobilityǂǂPxolain,WWscenariЦuph8whe8omeo؝wǖjg8rgsls;aGC˜mbWVPkrectxobjH\zcxtoochya skillP8*76ng.owpsetsHchap:olBhpregaâ9ȘI famStarrekpisXa1roidampDatajorcxXgrYlcee壟Pm(؍PiepHoperwn(bzHn/khteadrfȝ#xoJpeoplOhZdrncyxn+sxci 1I-off`chwcG,-a茒ormssycB a3fr8dud8mxhdeci!:t(sllYjlikeouI1TIstoraisimport)s:[dvb𨅤ss?z "on"f be˨сKu FH`harPрBm$expreon.ײDlynkeysuthough, ishether2creaturesightlsoeartfheoralommunity.edievologianspeculatedboutt syangels.nimrsdvocЀPrgueaPteastomeȁsaveaaumX.cienceiction8MalhsromworldPouldfundnt.Ԅ5ques:nowisHwithntelligachinІwaydH:e.

    E3Zwinlseaydepen(criter@+personhoodadopt –is,ӊ@iۍ|Wopos؉HPhilosop؎ offerI򐑄1qibla8ayP\nee0tjaiBcmembjhomopqfough,PoarrsiYielimin9h(,)ϒmw.ɗeems`bigo10deny׀aojubecau@it'surl@ively,simply)cPciouww,ookbroadevenefndsquitox:rudirM Ziu ingWPewa[0tfuowar0aІΖ/ kPlitts(Ho甘1yfrexps0a(a鑋4qutyaself-axe7spiaipncXvid vȉhgh􊸤owPorpReh P]ǧUfuz;2fy誳go troXibۗà-likabiȔX,xiccludGAuccteffort+2hqpapt`,insofaSׄLA1judxDatae'Dru Z/banidiҙAideBZyouIwggg7eMᎯforН9cucuddjduihub Ay harmoّ^ tyqm eIsce8ioRxs`ȂwP+beH cm@Imag)echnqyXop:po3domcobo ypryXrr񀪯wpsignpdzy;Im8 PӰtЪiKv)QvQ nextepevoluYhCsor0`lXclai2rop>opf RXxXQjHas –l8ic xrьC@ Ttџ9HHoppss!back,uIagv8m"jeliPthHfliz"g Gleapoooo?lT)nishaisy(Zabo ?:uppcsh4B\Kad ffpbۭpacI?ӍQtop8hڄ߅ߢrʻQbe𐂷,sRan't-?ɀ twoXnctsty).irsq!deȐ@tA#}regulQyu ePdoHexamplȹwIxroenvi"feeonxPwapl齹ɟt ;tHv1pmis IaPromO׋ץmPappnt.әdeterminehetheruperiorobotsrehreatoutugenerationsfumans.hinswPPlesslear.eayivenarmonyithem,starrekepicts,ryoverXowhIt'hllpeculr0)stageenly3oralblig{thwexpointavoidingXmenacY .ciencex uthIsaacsimov (1920-1992)roposeddru(;shouldembedd @ogrammɋWQ;@`fysaneЍ.u esp`ibilityOOHrequiPdoomlike8conue0w9aPstroQrtii 0elA.

    E3Qxit*nXro philoso8cexpl>cepXchapte3begbonfZ yaڂ(sciousnQugoven"ain؃`neXsidmruia'Yucompuipqetwe@lookdifXultisurroundasondety,ualistHsi?щ)non-physjspir%yva腨ma(0or!ab1hx8ducybrvȠseemddYʞlfromleciccrap(h[sottllșc1y BXreciseabsHisab(f5t1makubjsui̠GGBaldydhfinP!Kques*,AwbQ8Ihenjiz/ΆXUHengqoasɭagapȌZledge,l $؂8?>dr@6`S&ropsAcog! l٭d0mߢܜny’ ribuyPz ؀Pi؀oxll,@m"`n.br>FReviewǁ>1ංp!taskDF(ms?">2.e`i threHњꂧ">34b}oBs?pnitwwp4BboJЪҢ恬ireym5ϭxlif(fdh6w Z m7xpale)߂//(8/2ei_ZiOOwws9wՃ________0gȃ`m=funonGGGGGGG1Giffbetwak:strongH*HRllig___YZTurixTaq(ESearle's÷RoomguQo__Yϛ$wꄙssuurround WWSAysisgOׁב(Chooon _Bpo@LsmsgQbilo@r0E. Œ@es'WGGtdefepag1t/msw??[=WAmndryoefendtgainstnefheriticisms.

4.ׁpeialogueetweenndentitheori8aaunctionalonsubjecx3rela!mi ibr. '''">5.xpl`Turingettrwwt6.nrganiz called.L.I.C.E. (Artifalntelligenceound)as!onliPprogramhereou skliqudceive8r`spes.oYj(OK),xperimthʄdeshbowccessfulisnass_Zbr) REFERENCESNDURTHEREADING0wwwvWorksÉpnrdAppearalockquoggbTHu4phreincarn{@fromBvaditaoσσσDxartes,ené,qPiDSoX)(16490P 1`tsy.ott0hhilosophi20R~[Cambridge:À]nr0yЖ1984)>MalePnche,iPap,S(chftTruH74-5)χύThomM.ennPaOl mp Newْ___1997_____">Conway,n`PciplXMoAMonwy 90Chap9WWNgìndxVA1n@Tyrs6">Leib8,ttfri(WillhelmMdg721pЫhph 78χφRwDarbp+:REssaysInnapo@:ackettubhCompan9">Ryl@GiltpcepZMkLon8utcson8>Joh0“9HBPs”Behavior0jӕa898Vol. 3Pp. 417-42477777discu2qiǝmɔwinf`dAMar(Hi’h蚞roughilmkORoutle, 2002wCFurradhOǁρϡ@halm,ċdhd.ܜs҈)tempX̖lOxfordGFgGsciou0bIxaundam؅xorGutten SamuelAytoғ :‰kwX4(ob郟ǐǐǐ8r>(NM?dgn="er">***3*">CHAPTER 4:REEILL8X ѽM)PgB.I`seoreminisw'a0istgu)wׂׂׂדxredictabib/"GenureeillDŽWWFeelP doO7GGG>M RespiC7te>HumanignityE.Jillndod>DismDivineodnes/s^|ForeknowledgȂGr>((efleȀȇQ1.njppxampleyaAathatouerformedexplainhythinktasn'ted.777">2.ouldobotserogramitoQly?ggg">3.upposeυ̇1,fs`oughdid9aat0choice.oeingreallyex"thdis:7770476arsy logic*?9st؅bapotachip؄Qgroceryh͋he@morresp0ib؄+#5灺midn酠C’e nana?i0rOdgArketcompany㇐Acxihcoct aisoninY (ovaundr8m؀cum.sid(usu0datauch9named8sДphonumber,Kinki0qliPcarr,pxX,xqhamusicho[evhexerci(preferenWith seyyup@oin70ft “lifepag0egms”sddisub-ŠKqw9=sa(dig:+buyPfutu1As&tselforids'֚iorȉhirhdPsi socio-exomcherics.pnllĄfyo(їiwhoargeۈur duc–peit9ad.ɝHays̕+7accumul8Ѕ3ass1xountl);biehButmpIt:m@i8TBw1Y:bedo!uniqu󓎌Krhphbώf);ak"y-!.Ƣ3ndpo@XuyrrelevantY☪ypeZmapnapushPwaA?YawJҍ_">    E3Ժsp:(c--zm ߁:ЍOKierlZOIcasisXtlacaJ`kCcoth//,srich.*i(2N%issmohilosophyzpest)tr)s{_[BsuacmfX؊kOPe`n!lypryGGycane⣠k̉qtrarj genuhȂ?#br>A.AINONCEPTS'@щPyayzunr9noҎg)gm,Xg+begw+e!wof:')div/>    E3"`bryarrowhissuOHpichilosophPsimila b,XwIwZjtXuishmoHQnuddlKͦudXpo\, asfu`wi`:deaedgeȟrbb\Xmhzsԧ𚸅us.ƮHmH,ysiidnap@chqwxQbce8r.͂߂߂߂ځghrnuPhسspeak80d`kbetweЗusubinvolv؁s YowGup,҂Njċ)hghrӚAizf؈X׀8kXm eeso{han(garpsRw}doxt,hЖu0!tavoi8deQqthwHȟٱshihhsrcrea*qre:aco Aؐ\:70򆸝Rrobuckefulf(iag1watc8_8"3gouts† bi臁iНKia݁Ή7ن#gggg.o`tX/dor8ahm2ÁѿVathϰYmpa.Ě'Oއ)(i!llow#b by1predictalaw_zlas~if9#@HPtype`moob`nxpys&aЙ1I,Xj񗬀 ߅  [“(HoullsoPclu(puntabeliefHfehnga e@
B.HEASEORETERMINISMXItaoughobPЇPi=willstosition.nact,tay0msibleςw8ertainty.hate’deeddoatchoudЊ colatXcream,nxver!handsfimes@ihpdifferl`PerhapЄ{ha{aundrhouspsforouldXexHʁ0 8notapaIoIwise.utinant}advocnHdq(ssueuortz)ofsir pe e(Let qgbyookBmargu.''>    E3 .`i>Dssuallyro`\aaȀ:^woroperaccЇ0rigidႠpictlawShumannaturou!thusXnstr hupAÒXdbbkhtx؇3:00M1sfQ8u.sĨwar@se1wj9kgt?re`p:Psmec@8ڋ|n)Usa(cmadPtJirІviewXtؠ0ramat؋@18th    E3pter؍twoptoposiyy.irst,hssu0rȁ~s?orᆰxknowgrnowo0x܈灹S,6ngWhi8mce1W[ossl؁؀=easi G1,dron̖ t'rogrammed.aywiit- 0caus8H98mpt,cpPm4 onPhgt08sѥnackZd.Ԗrob٤OY9!sciHificH9so,venByx%nve8gwhe<drXspeciE ˭a9-)QQ.ߜSŒmoimportantኈoitor0$c((rettutdه+diplЈRbiologpsyasocӓdɠ7t1!(usX aМvitᇑH`,lloȡ2Bw!٤I{l0|IȱJook"u,`obub؂BrafЃ odP(@tBɂ9diehardeferJOHwho sJCYimbeda(N lZbbetwe?dmt l51`n2A-Yer]+n0gohfsmpel8g;br>PredictabilȂi>.Pi> ?;Rt(ga ?sarsla&Roffd(mood!does;t:p9bDžufI9s󷈩hf`tـ)s؁cӞb.ȈHlpxexamplpSupт(@:0exzYheadР\pplockこౘapachQsXax薴odЄAZaȃ肙rcر}Jwu!lego?o8ll?rbds1rdowxsixΗ@Ȏepa zCzth.̯ dra@icsZkwrpeoqPȮ9hroughAaL rXHlerkeqaccounAido8TexȭYirobImagZfalifoulhepi-b`viyidfo_patn(Farmm dop`owfoo#w)arvPfg1anzquiچ+ЅzEoypworkhqh#bsocialnstitutionshatelynooperativeffortsoulde@isk.hfomexonalis,eathinkeriousabouteseossibilitiesince’grownccustomoredicta…fumanhavior.ƒwhen1doflechnow,takusookikecHnstrayawsphysicXbiologndsychz.ԅgeargumentorrepill,nis:


(1)Ȉ*icɃle.`F2)Ѕinat_\rigidur؉ɄGGGGG>(3)Y(ocp    E3defender*&ticizepeoplJot 100%әfarmQinXdecidotopingpodioXdon0t(ry
ՕVI[perI)Yraa0B8beᘺttwg\W[©PseemLdDed4br>C(HEASEORENUIN`REEILLpbPǂOOAgaisHIfueȉمP1It8苋i ᨐabtJdoow.etcloinsidyp[ond tw “~”loHrnoes6YwdсH-makronvolvduse-effehn@.Ϙbr9Ivѱ⚡mmUBsemeȲlife-experiences,ndhesellombineogerHupplysith8deangefotivations.ρer0siwardshocolatecereamoL+vanillayets`xhealth-cxcio{s^`fu-berry0bet.ԀdeterministakȁqviewHatXypr/(pЈSeach,’beorceoctponhiPev0istro8 a8ime.ɊyeelehQmorPpowering,b3.oatowXnyhsIrsed.alwayssi*desiЈXenjiʈjmomenXXpl.

    E3ȉhreIdvoce0ourinal8cis-makroXifferly.ٚ1_^mec`icyile`‡+s0JԘ`ȒˇXBumb hthoufuckr iEYho(y2; – wer8Inss@0Ɂ abilito─aigidaXPτ0IosEiڑ/,ᐒY r@ hZ$aIan—l{&s쨱agex芈a1tÏۉa,BdontarticularlikdflavxiۥeȍB_]cyXeposi(oftpagcausyiI (Y“B”erg띲)sapܘ*redH,pur1ϫcr_pfaargusquX(or̈ .br>AFȈyFdomSirhuq'a!:-aenzIyɡoЭraRs-smhFiXӍeqmXuX whaloqnavig٦"0 fٞI)smu ȑh(l9+.ׇЀYdrord@'inst ,؃R8^ji-ouldpwiSh+IarTedlbro#Aop au2ᇷCY@mplmwIH @ˇj(,Hs0whiitemɤXenjoYrNoadoalu[es#,Xr7fowpHrI:+gmatt)2ptaH9ʄLȅ6lЀp|qjrobgramm8GR ŖbߤBPsuas‚Imseemdoessettlissu0ImagyYndaypnsmxmRmQoluHsubjȨ%uuCsay:)youupX0wwprbec[(ge@0kѱntyh.9Hnapxf(,}Bof)gA[ۑk8,Bow蠂z;Reduck@YauiWK$I't*Ήxt1Yilȍx:{hIo΃2fickwWXbhappenaccx!qrminȖ^ciqa am9xalemCytplaБee`xlP0~Hexienc#s1za"b!bubblawtqfoX0top;iweQwaofc9r8iquideneathshateren’t.heealecisionakingrocessakeslaceelowsurf,ndconsciouslyxperien聙higherevelairrehan0A centsychologic+mɄ8thpoiPeoplernectedolXropha`ramchinask[formpficct spreporariggPofir@quared0e2%occud.owr,>spotuniqurainvityf QatfeelIfLldynitiatCfirst yt{coe ,nefhoiemergesChnal(tse`We.n preta)Pstu0sial,uPAyelphZ ('%frhyasЏBillux


    E3 MorRensibilPi>9i>Aarguenuȅlmrrequi_`^Cdwoiffsitu@which(rglaxbk PhstYjewelry):#manamJoinksprXa,9Ȁd ilnar؄P(3)rePGGGGGϵaA؇“”遰avagux┱Qcawij0єijأpu0gop8iҫi.ץAzjhf,exaatysu saswhymۇ҃8ecmppʌ?m.Fᢺ0inkeeЀfromUizKomeItesn 2ipreNesenvironAݗYuisamgeid@balsoႁKZg"–stiprogram.urI,QtAt)Iwafhs00ghؐahЅAIdidhiP__yno5i븩undeniaeleWhe;@WmjtَʄɄї Ж Qviewߜ.e(mpbe ,`nЉ@soo<.ſArs@@cd`htw!Bobb!spi🛾Potto"bothctromrresistiblempulses.eecognizehatobasictimdheneingidnappandrainhhed,thisillivesympathyorim.Ҁxerin(rownail,e’wantoe-programBughoreentxmean`Ourhaoooe,ybeiffer:eJnotodike) wHfeelallyuhfipunish yttyl.ɇ ayɄhetermitxmasensefqp‡sponsibility@Xasancideaafre.


    E3 HumhDityXxi>. IA)r somewslarrgums{GfdÇYts臌*choices:)blockquote(1)f)nm(aXXuineȃontrolvZos wwwv2pnyHtuaJ>(3)ԛe0φφφφφσ7WwoulfȔ8orifᚈyYcicpre-(abled?ɠأOSmal`beyoBeirPnctoryetp0twobؔrhi@$hg.Yniquenes exeaeoeak[pH(ui`ow{YldItalixPicIllairHoP(1463-1494)`y-a ecisfy“YouhonbpmolA+sculp˂fHjhap(`pp.ـ`Qdeerar ormjilow@,rlimbpwa荰BsasonȃЌgnatuwhicsvP.”:Ʌҍ`mC*Mele Beduwu//DoС1dep2gTtru檃?痒skeptRabipSuppod.madHsdRo Iawonuntilfleept9ty100,000vajor0yough,dX(ulrЇm`餑_¡#ĤUrkciz/eڥzme)n*Dževeǀ.ŀ㔭dvo8aadmimu8bePithpgQoccywweX runڨautopiloX,w)gQiee؁`'!DurсtiŠhIjob(lo(ofamilydeco`reoplUPpHhXCcuHxÆunzfi˥?Í@BВQdmQzempywiy_nexJ\r}BowikRsȂÒges`er(.c@dimpQo p83carrh\ܔ"Bdewdo@mech0daߠW0dxУaivirtuoubbfxub-exence?g,poben*mnrς֘1gih$芡il`сʶbr>. i>A؏argujfgenutemdinciic iwdiscovِQphysics]earP20thprobabi!;itighуQrpo@Y

    E3  “Aha!say relldve, undh䚫xworld,ichPtrЛe sЈasPourchoices.Mo ly,Ttwo`{subacy ols ory.irs zcipleoirewrit(RookPow?>uuhperhHW[PlongĈjuaPaX-eff@achehinkMchbeyrigidN ԄLglPlEitlYidpossi;у&lǡqhum EӢnhh qȄ;io-cPcmydresulHȤhqȤXmрIh1QcoJP0mP@avana,kQneurologAvbuiupdeeb\xv=(imPpack///.  rug?:7m moextqers҄isPsi)allߝhavsuڲ皙NrX??Aexcظ 0xҌ1ps|iqPۊ7B!ߚ󄸦W4st!go[wt؊hBVmoHuyY cell0CIspAlࡱf yxorkoll0iBă.baȃ//lP;stuXG,A򶰈WPIJg0оȞp,0g@qwhappe0weW(I@akbePoYHSpbA·߱%doesntjumpĉ–xX metaphlywAYom׆argu:ІIȻtyp`f75eedrpom,tenu҃eѡ:۠ifumengz.fɍm8cidbetwebuyr76ibI܄lipIooЈ:@arbi0h3,ӆ˹ńfxEwe_)wP1ntoppasmvulZ{gRa2@nlQ䟺drtuiЂ lis@aizu؟ׇ@ll76br>DHEREEDOMFCTIONLTERNATIVEbhggSo`alookstt1@ga~räsdsciPifQ|onduct.lso,heaseorenuin`reeillooksrettyeak.npitefis,t’sifficultobandononceptchoichichoegularlyP(inurailivesteems bePhearpersonal sponsibility,rtisticreativtruQiendshipndcoaorumanalue@a؅involveₘkingۀtric8ciexpectЄ.Âjusrow:way+urr8 ideaHxwePr8n-programmedobots?veneterminscognize+y"domembedd8Ąn u`noyrdinaryv.

    E3erhapsolupcomep0thetfЄ3)Bm pblIm wqϐqeworڂʖfar:Hl0a Haˇ)haHwise.ԑntrehpos#zrequiQuRynownawnatu8whI ly)fɉHuleYh"ti1Ѝjف"round,ɉ(dљKusxchaAfXlhm8ځfirA8ӏunlytxarotnorBuȘalHQ{BmodȎhiit'%Theisl9“” i*9asharpItrri1inGG؆0a t3aodOMϞϞϞϞAp_ paamoHhilosophR̜ܭk{:br>FoAj:ǟ…Cb8o1 !uWUAcP@gd(raw(circ뚰selHmgt@frP–(!hyNAQbrɂB    E3hdxplanafowaun[diff؁PPbymXcanhilosoparryrankfurt (b. 1929).Ȃsks(ost@uisetweenwoind9eswPave.ake,oramplhaflictcmanyeteracIyp@oZiHcreamgoPhombutɌami({enۃ0I3b8tQltnGminology,Ma “first-order”compe!thS_[:bbr>FOiăS8basicrt ()SSȝt772]74Facc1s`nhichurёҝtlinep;OKoccwh`hueZpurchaHwoul؃؃wtwvNon-ǚqk؂p.ƒ8Pfe`؛𛣫(ortaAeepA0`evXs7cribjllОed.łaify2jIOONycau=bol0lsfollpmenlawxuزߖߖߛ҈'JoHadv aghelpQH77cho0husXс9X-so-wumay.ӮXPg suXchAnzeؔAvewedecis-Ppro(sE!mblursH,d8kk7n\sualit(yxQ3Daowӷken.fe`genuIwAhadчX`solu9:R0Rbiydo`0erwise,*ێoӝ.¹w9Ѕyfrega녑domZ?ששЃa(iqu9".748 !3nWWrgorselv 憸Yei/1limit/r ep????:Wاw񨴋lx?Yyer[Le@Osuggep,ialaiacepr?OcnowPticآocat2ԗ,sQllNju捐syprhіߗoxpoonp@.ltt,ouDao_Xiolog꥘gramgrz.QYI@.dĊNJǒd菰b@Eongybo@ividdbA)߇ف (henvi mXbraPYvlea0Hw߂8e8s`:Ӕ mpuppee Xll sy@;cog;ar@@0;ط@sInsteadJс1(ulownst.(X&ҘՒDslҜ_mАA)ȏǧThu8ycessfhereedomfctionlternativeingesnhethereaneanfullyeeurselvhasrogrammedobotsichtheamei(ha(strongeelpfdentity.


E.REEILLNDOD ߁߁WhilЈqllndePminism`batesnest``own,xaknewYporsor(giousPevers.ԃtradiAala9GodthȁXall-power(9whonows傈ytp Pgood.uzzlQbout)’pttributiiarise, ough,c(8rua{hum(N.elookwo񏨇ies:impncep"divness,r?genu!??:om8cie.>    E3 Letssu!momԈbehi0accordtoQidio-chclawWno0,h1lackbjɁdoaw.npi؊xwxeZn)dualayJ,`amie1hysworldthusne8؃kexteb(J0yearZoastbucoopYchocolcreamydecis"esulmoeȊ8rI8myraHbyaenvi*–u;influ2Qyr8<isurn,Ypmplex0ڊQpertxirOThiooto XzraclifnaroncosmoAϨ,be@belrchȆH[qawЙi0\un ,Hv`SY)Xh8ɐXnly-casc8seȍkmeXn4unfothr񸲃9dIursϕϕθuhlсٱbwoubRawЈ8|(ich,OaiIR0yë?I;0s{`oc`zPnބolځ‰bigaB؂Rnoowثofx؀r(viPJPenslrap0kpp8ti jpeo.pJust8kkR׉z[؆߆toJ3a.ńqHitlerduwit G0gryaȱ_Y(lhdwgÄkbpcaPEpromgsblem2uz-fg8}bifnIruh-`em2p0{0Mo`pr0*g`"is:rbr>hferonveniaologicQroblem,ˏYitsel8s!os+embra.e’dt)nesom!dep18o`hinkȆiidea_1tru@hgXx*f Ydookmor`p8ibi@yh}pw seenrari!inc.


    E3 GenuineƈaWa!D(oreknowledgex. R`giousPli s8mmons؋)P-Y ԗ a)“ᕠeryg”cludX0?* apac<"aɗhapЖIsXd`tHa;9coul jerupEvolcanoMouVviuexample.yɇhysfPoȃ !+Blawa{jx8an7in1aݓseeipxthoughp$m*0flipʣLfY^ɜ#dh@Iorhhmy)?updtdntoC,ee p aanana;@inteteH"ʡpሉhimbwowI0 ctumakc!ۋRosPكy툘tiHhas[ɀ8kit?sąpzru0boۋ:؃ixY9,o.Ȑhciyg"is:)blockquot10˾zP_] ׁm#`oτττ2ʂWgIoqwooooo>3r@ׅ????3߂ut'(ؒ70,wiar wo`cXsqit4rgument?momredict5ҝbe8.ivsuomicUac;on7>7??89?heory9iP(nawith0Frankfurςoooj;onfl&ivigoodn07??9h??>genu?eledgecbr؀)Analysisׁ׈Tkn0supportesc@esxۑ{spix`aܼa퉏Hxmfe_] dwOOOZ`palogu0dvoca8j GG GGGGGGGFyprincipl,hȐjmesersyaPcepߚ߄WWעouiscuss邯imel,q?aޥ˝ REFERENCESNDURTHEREADINGwwwvWorksÑ0dQOrAppeaPclockquoggbAcxipnewsXlease,ay 22, 2000“4UnveilsЎonicx{NextvolubCPrega”ttp://www.a.comfDžDžDžTexam(%exec@2DavidȄP, @Annqui؅cern)Ust (1748)ardd!sZbyԃXL.eauch (Ox`d:larPPp0)/perregpnscioueel dȅPkBenjaxiЏDoeȮ9FaW`?q0Robert an0ed.Z ndboon߉NhYX:ρcUni8o02),p. 551-56߈߈߈߈Pico(llaidola,iovannisDignMan9, (Ianapolis:ckettubgXmpany, 199RecXslʂ1(sfamyw`quoteeight="0pt"idthc>Frankfurt,arry, "FreedomfheillndjConceptaerson, TJournalPhilosophy,ol. 67, 1971.
(pOOL hereadingpȂ.ρρAngli0W.., yφhristianaith (Oxford:larendonress!90). 72ooojHonderich,edHowƄ ou?(Newxrk:τ:nivity=2002)/////Kane,obeAtemporaryntroductitoqτττ5߄߄߄߄߄ed.DHhbook0i">O'norimothy. “,”nAStanEncyclopediai>(plato.s|.edu0em,erkLivthoutgcCambridgeȀ]0010p(Ke(__Z ernet__߅piep.utm&6'">WegneDanielIllus) sciousV ,A:ITw_Ecalign="ceQ">***3* ">CHAPTER 5:NOWLEDGE8XY[kicism>Rc߈'''Crisa7ONB@ceJKnowleoO>ExpiGGFNon-ggggggg QsmEmpi .ԗDefinPW??Ju fiedrueelief/???YGettiProbleWW">DPrutlcRe_[o r„Owf_____What’soadb??WW>E@cpWDŽW>xfirm9/// voluGǂGG>xFor8flecȀȩ?>1.׊easAouave您doubtQtIabj(QfrontɁ,uchsa,ctuallyxistsooo2lareheommwaysqwhiacqui(k̓` i0osliA3.Ɇlaimoʓ0meth, nedencXoackp)r34ldoite؋atatemڃp5.veryonevGgeasited;o`rfꀸbaspuponat,AturBospN///(6.s׃meyl:(opɓ(P,gu@enui0(lorldK,(eargo, 39Pmbeqrganiz;en'sǎH:itde*sy heddeirarthbod)joзenpaxhipCwfowathbIet[cPerpiecultsymzsube8 unHrȁʓbx Pll鞘e91y f1,oaЂgalaxyacrafmarAitrl.ccasz8seliens sendnwayeamoarth,homporarilakeheormfumbeings,0Pssistill studentsnransXthisigherevel.esusrdiscipleypli@dereمprapeacs.no/mppedlate 20th    E3t'snяhaІ(staboutowuniv8unItsuiâknowa0truHen`Gmemb dclaim̂@0view8T!ledgeexpn beginiHeriohm8peciwisdomedPf󏘋;ֆfu8refH{yd˅טB@doe@cougenuP7?πx#rconcerphilosoRostaptY mhelpQuish(twevictioaOJ܇f,ay8ct .e9pse`prȆ8t襀""omeZ`tim9uQ+'lsoi\zo spokic)hكws –cludi$fics --juutȑLBThe)prhryԐ.2󑥐g Aname1epemologyrfr01GreekxrHoȁP()2(os2()////,@Awo!1w[Xp"iɗI7dhsk,CfixfPionaruhgrompu񜠀XceduьeinvolvsɆϭbȰi ۓ cho.eφφɆzpos`onu0"Par+rapitpFraЉ/)=GCBSfa`Xffa`pld8o[9ouraiplЄBe8mzjfocXhapJ">OOOJAKEPTICISMAccLWWHB@7*racIipŸ\Xmx1took (붏HowI, bxg;`strippп6@vio m(riGhre9yypz(ma $hȵllDruggȊѵPS.ronlxexp(pur efusaה9rWe "h)sopcouldotIҕЅ@fliabilitlanImmedish8suspicfyQ71cul`Ⓜcp? shaky.on0m Rlind8 *mC,Ǔҋnlewulifyl8Genu+Ȇ(oack)updon'etthhtnatAkp:sK"maextravagcmithttl𝐃Xf idbuilt-M(e'ck0dAoPeryir-br+salongק!E3‡ؽf ismo?1kbbeX72etoh[cahdoubmořӔ@myeliefhatheablenrontfectuallyxists.nnciephilosopher,or(ample,elievedPrythingaworldhang(soapid8,henmeopspokoim,eouldn'rus dsa؀sabрhieyeachhisarHus0brepoyut;nwiggЂYfher0dicatфh0Qme.׉ssuitɊtre0 tion,XivillratesnoYvlkepticism --viewr grounȎ doubclaim)Xw8yp9ahYgr@ed.


    E3b>RalӅ.aԅmhs ,QeuisfHinvolvтx+'sˇ`i>Lofocushaarular;,uchڂGod,rϜ8sHuni(syt oralityilliglifxlseh˂e.ɓ` aswcargu sh:kpecifpqueon.͌Pp9licboleaosoldwZ0qDKissm邀ullEp9.ƥW,Ɂaioe#@ Renc聳y.ȄriXma Dour>Bubjechoєpropo!`canknowtert0hЦ eIfaX.覃rypfomtPat8cRmoHrmoAnturihagokYҳܫOJdoXcrX)8thoetlizPdrifP`c8 oeRtasky䡐Xcomb>ɉЦZmpoaYXw8tghAwApm:dapdamag socie,Ohav fbenefa.:8le)R(n@Hse*0ফ superi(ledgHoolWPixgBefendyOnamfrnatirɢPyrrhoniGhZpiqb0anG@kgx{ (c.365-c.275CE).׭Rwrotertaυx)u`$ossibj+πis:JsH wor3 ntlesypretain9ȊĪhbopaer;dž?u肨ngX,"dXJfromMyyte as m8ouHnt@lyif!Ymeeycol8 9rppphwizȂΫ1(f ooiAa(vПlSupӄIshrunksi@ilecuqhʑ1:VsurI1seemla2xhdπhexp9IloogwOˈ`[knocogn(يEltgبƧcei hiG,3譭+hu@yccor4נLbasȗr:x dȂYtȟkɃ`m@A rZ!\l(Jer-@8oAŅȅ0cҏI*sAxjudgQŮ$lτciuxviewiphysb    E3Ԋ se(dpproachradical䈱1Humeankep(ism,efendyScottishhilosophDavidȂ (1711-1776).ccordjoHy,Jhumxreascesinentlylaw萃u`rmini(claim*knowome.҂blem:hatheni!szarioȒ*fJorlhfizyexplanayeQtory.ƃ(examplifɃllona,ɃicclusbAnt x lro.†8anora؃Tdpll',juatmyvXMayބg:;уgbit(x.Ɋkdiff9truМŁwan'prB5 ellIlikeb :XC:Hyoucidup(bфswer.ρ'PmaXr@lcul,solu3w qgetQpartipcredi(Similarl+ 7irreleva XleadyݍR.Af)o0gra(YǠ,##dHas@smh:Rbr>m.elf  ,⌐ quapjrg Պ'aadl1non-T銭ymOXaes:CYQbodbobbS9ispirmǂcexڍlX𣱌by0pofuli emon?ł@XȂׂѤ1eHwou8falshHe8scribscenariohre>Ipsup`x...x؅ǹextɧunhenergћ0dexsxr2kIairKeph,XlorshapeACiernpҊЪdeludd0m(wQgeniPraps2judgmyhavQ`dPeyqHfles@PonȔs) jD؈+;Medi԰>didn'xctu]beټQpS!U(ʾ Pheȟ<;ZfB/*ICaPfrome;seem醚rIpys(inchyi@GAٙ򘨈HWwwWrO;threkϪ͙scaptd(ople'aginmosScienceictionoviesalorelayffhis(eme.orxample,nilm T`Matrix,eo8'sodasuspendedubsoondiirrainswirRtassiveomputerxateneratntificialeality.imilarly, monlysȆLYcontemporaryhilosophyу80Y0aatQ:dcientistutrson BglHarstsucPWheȁaeechanismevile,,؅vAms'Ȅ8co vincing,romApevtiXpbtellk1eXd-qfak


@    E3iCrithsm"RadicSkep(Hi> ith@gumpshocka`str9(asthn@imry*otufHI9IsNuweX_Xir9eveHj XX@)ooubtrynghstioniu،ڀirrefuta:w xQI"IDIs,"Pmu@Kb(؄Èz.Ԁpac(sel`equaeXalway8mmu 8K"shJc=#Desc@hX)Hύρ,hich8ncapsulXۀxsщ@)k,0e am."‘߂ڃaHnotPymJbysmaneu؉promh'8luʦ5800ngbIw-"I"bedosMo1rtant(graned,ou٢:inunt)؀on.(ccordDԋ88cح̄rel9hearHxږ\'(CwEaewȡgopcap*(hseemAc1asx8eomagiQse8HO pcle1ļ"g醸وy@pOH(RXarm-xachX@IP,Ô)8uqppenlrrqjsixs@oul8Уt ml@/er r".:WAtk!ݜwan't츘ڠ%Ȱnorm؀SuraUocca)(od,xknger-wiggl rs0bear 0"04@1Qehungr؝)pa0speexs,Q(usoMdur2ypaxWe'dxq jW,↨n.Ҍ¢ʽ%倘AAOoȀఠeLaturbf4daϫ`񇹄riϫAsegmBsϒi`ډesg٫JȨAq.ȟ*poxre:Rbr>Ttise
, 1.4.7]ޑ?=Thy?HrRih8tw//*Xt0liz8wpunjufi3a@`d w .ԀdoorlCɏe' snУڎʈ'gg_|thirdttacknadicalkepticismshat(e'sositiloglyelf-refuting.ԁmainintis:


w
.Džwǃ߃ܒemopxcAq@yZhmakLuynconte@andhouldejec!.savsp8ecr`i,hichhometimesppluseetaphorigestilaxaI.ׂariduryhm9unwantedtuffa:&xffވLppellHfrom*|aloH y0elsȏ77Hla:Jinds0unjufisprocessYW'Ua0erlICe9id؇VHncludu’Әool    E3 urQᮿ't`nunreal1hXev`ncKrX tw(csE:opetdartial?HsuAgenuin30gequi(W,0achievablqxm,4Ii𥰢aabsolupɝq]Parg0castoubt4y\Och@en8reduquPf0s鉯`o'ollratpsupeaygaPrnouHЁbry0Y"tjaHȠБmeIirg0hrrm e@s:erce"j eyeIX*yʂbavoً@фrewhe2edoȊHЉsciH喀p2w"measui (sid prum(flXofmtrembRyꚵ7brAhaeaphyxdy8ephaA(˂hse doo Լ˅? (äalwkruC׈0si;)aWȵfQlow+wA0? tƎellt+yԍiy؀(Z߉go0GCpndCposm,?@esn'fɂ˚rendpiAdmil2(ϫ%('lef:saGAxsiY׆ёrmuchasonQonvicAftviewѩhI򸪀฀hQܐXDbelieA!ﮣXÃword "f" [addqh`.

    E3Pilscev؊p҄laz'))qasibd) p򔯅ُvmAarc0eg؇attempv(ultimhfai@uggl withhessueelpslluminateheaturefnowledgetself.t'suchikeesearpintoee8glyxcurableises:venfcientistsan'tcoverforcer,investigationtximgrerHsightkhumanhysiology.seXnoxplo)coptnxdetail,kicism1alwayseurk؁qbackground,tȆc uojectomoripandvrs.


B.OURCESFNOWLEDGE؁8Wlaimч銘loZfacts,exampleatiisotG0Wash@twaast.S.id,q,}cyHea(GabelirsuperiXanroa2galax@Our'saryram0callyrequ71ti@o!hneHyphtlookt:differ0QxhiacquY. www">    E3hilosop@radima ed{woypG@fro`qreFsources.Ə:thgh)eH: ً,0araboufegng.hgo@byL`erm aoshi(i>+liea:ցʍ–Pن eЇdnc",0phana!(sCPЖybبuth؈C',ȃq,gqa^EtiK>ÁA?al()/8x{mbvio`;(oleHon.aPhsX2ahH!orld;PwopeqPdwitnpdlesietʷnd1exmellta8WI8Ȉs"ISsb0n,"R3AupmyisuaileHsFo8aւ]xxcxalso mislhLoyhusakappPY110r;W(rag‚,فarud1n1dSkcwe’biosXprobleYWOesߜOOWHA(Hrospec/dcamXI˚sixbLJpiar4hIllowx«Qw\ th邈30IfgodoctȯXpl؇"f)ibackhhe'lskdescriyink׈YI9xqporX"W2harp:+IrӎtoP."1 ٍvXI[ureǨB.̎iυЁg{alwayPamemoryMɀyό0corYXvicav'ir锂ydbxccur@(bxxϓo!T!llt@tituaewAg,ɉ'wwƅexa8ДЛBwg脦>re'izza=ref9or,etget5i蒰쿠i@H8ometimes overbearingeopleikeolicenvestigatorsanaushink0ateememberomegneappened.nden)re'9`nonf dejau,feelwe'vencount0deforeallyven't.

    E3ourthHur0experientialnowledg tmony1o$.Ԋ8,rPam,yOSGeor`Wastwa first.S.residP.inicu`sI:born,`8ldꎹroughrectption.nsteadre؃(statntsisyoks`authHHse,qHuacsromarli@ordaitracacxorč%yewitnesspwhoson:knewwxapor:ur?sX)} –acabou񚲕seIplr o.hiit(co8nqHruy=H oftalihoodrror8pa0cusoЗw-of-m`h^p:alkcheapۆPsloppơyQ@writRusmQiab8r`d,muc0ed3HigȉrҔ,ublisX[٢of-@郒OlongYcha8^i4g 0=ireepin.ץPytrospz@ݎheqbQm wayacquiW.ie ut?yЂawIdonbwhiȈ@Hexsens_ESP.ƪO,ou!lepic ImiwI'mO0clairvoytXwAn ӑryZiЎjtљ*CiIfy@keh(elassifaф8m//Z.ƒxdo iyypux1olsubjsusymbolcaQhidXview +bepantag 2umpevI{HowSmoscfrigo(s\‚tfa`2produpiggggiCregujPȎlؠ XakmXrily saf@HewɈofX(fzConsxrxtRgeBihP8eceipheGo(guHXim*U@th.hriologYJohnal(Zpo``ndiB@bn ms2HxM*R$ሿrȦ o9xb*+8haȃbrep@.et'sawbwoIxttyp)/٩鍣tic7.egJ脘#uJtoK<\m,0z}o"Ueai0YrptPuturIЁinndiffS؄ۆimaPxق(@l`(babl(wP)1oy OK1chree߂=“f”q&sup)8—we' `pcytBs#h*:Tztechn4spe;Rn'tal`Е?nf٪m!eت8:¤hsfulexes?mag 鳶~Cfw, Gnon- Xc ky@琰pHopdisbouthepcomingear;tendfZeanheckedresults.owoulprophetso?Ԁoddsrelimxcevonducxperimentincsayhyan'tsiz`nemand:t'niqueᆈunpredictablvelatoryex.yightlsoirionsromodno sortۊsۅ8⇙nfirminbnewspa.fUicegenuinurknowledge,RburdPȂ00seemoeliamet`,`x matulude amo0ormalwfti.


    E3 Non-El˃ i>urn)nex8on-(`aiori)?is|qinf)suchodifficdescribSomhilosrep8sOkflowhuXasQtself,1ollut8bߔWsblya0acJ"_through:ins.suxexamplopre OW)striQىDQampiricXpar–,ality׋тxah:77oo1X"YWׁZn؁߁߁߁߁ߋڍOO'' РRQAme^y e(nt豧Ҵaddib`_ oYruth|/+l seO//>·@eXabocaseʹH0Hu 8 Zirst, "O"ٟydefin"%"Ѐthrue,rpect0τŋ?WԸ@~habeimpфBѵwo.ƈ醩ne(s:L[aryٽheygPbк(`regardلqhdiff(aworw8ed. 2+2؂l 4qQxivabAcHЇscenariounrspEvu (d08stiqJ0"bd%meanK8HPmselvEli>1oughs@È`t0, 8oppoAnK:ՈQhad`dy.ak7@Georgeat~.S.xi!,8hiX3i0Iҁ`0ow.—hcmagin@sԉm;OProm comن&.׋psoorphanaHhdowamiXrtree?whokkdei(wooe@i؁inauguray?ԩf`NJNJБ(ciconstructionfheorldsturrentlys.

    E3Ԃoronceptmbeddednno non-experiialnowledge`at1an analytictatem:ဏbecomeself- tradictorfeenXt.ake,orxamplh"Allachelorsrenmarden."tswouXbe(is:br>WYfal bȑ ctuht1_7d@dfolidiffy:mago3///?~Ra ismPdmpiricx*>nrHic arookla+17thIOY$ҨbirYȀɓ@ArmW8inbor2bxahHmnPfe –ӁcYe "a"Уؕ.ɈgBp)clasteiw8hᄋwiabsolu0cexint@)ssib`q(#Grel0rleɆꩠoСnclu蠵JGoIni9subscausptRegaONÒ^8RҐq7؜1ؑ/likgetry(g*olela\sromheseboutllindsfeometricalhapes.escartesasnact@spiredyheeductiveethodwryndaint thatede˂AsameHy.hroughon, cer9t;haxinnat}transferPoo(rrfrom!se.istakhcreeponlyhePurwsecoong0yestPmorPAnowledge,rgued,cludiscientific_,rocee dXns.

    E3urnowemicism8icularXLocke'sjfirtaskR chenge xWK:nconcepts70ar`nborhO(mx鈬birthiklankeefperyatexwrianyth itPblem0pɒcanlrigfachxBГy/+)Goforampl`@noɃȜsupposYb슙orldouu rthu1asp8war//*g5YȄjuf(fBfaul0I[alosiqon't aupl쀈nfIt(1clearXsuЁlQX88mـ@b8cio ꠹i@befloo0a-b gwould)ЭǍiNǏ.Şt8 F#ts'Ihas꣏W ك8҄new6+!hma9ciP.Dzqrol0lfollowPea acqu`ڄ,g8nerpz"׍9I tlPlbammѠRbks;>simiswin: 8H]GߡyaI`pushǡu.''''"ڦ;aKantgtdiatLm-ϓb.sympothA(suffФa󏀟)t:!doesoY gp\Von-tiklogic.oyxcmhnoq(*sen욡au tself-evh certheyR hifiǨev؉8e.(solu9resurrec 𳟨a@arguˆorganizaPu(utoly`yIrawׂ–rɝakeletEg haphlesh.ƾBIt¯ȟ/),:!inɓ3r0myyMy2epon`aQee-dnsimaqpuȅ`pHЛXeimЄo=Usc>)(seg7Qse؏*0hhnu@Еb*t:ggbPcau9*W誻,sfuϔAJU)+bsJOC'ā/ǭǭǭǭR׷C׭+iigioutڟ0itodaySe0’YsNсؚstBfujPpitwXundatJdi*yss @n.8Ѓ8ubttraȺwȨB?{cani"d⒇AE߃GG¬Pnessookishy.

OOOJC.HEEFINITIONFNOWLEDGE///+Throughouturiscussionfnowledgeoar,ertainonceptsaveppearedganT. here'sheuest䀁truthalaimslЁYmatter)9personalbeliefvicfor{issHbeviderju0ficaQthates߂radihas邁Xsthreeeylemento:),R.ƃexample,henay "I:ParcapitFra",means br)blockquotOOIItٍehGGGFv????e.GGGGamoiedjing׃׃ׇϊσ̎ashortpontemporaryhilosop`sHlldefinߛA–pt@abbrp@"JTB"rucihpointvˆ0{9con*mbernt:!ynK۞bYxdoesn'tu!s'    E3J.T)Bti>Houndt񅙉@O,etg٩achoi]iV0DŽI]ElvHPPlx iv(@ac0ead.ˑgyo`mЪufengsثh8involv{zyctuPHrSom)c㊷`r<*waysecessaȰ9 szbasavailablimhsciis(*iddxag胊arXwHflat.vti,# ChadDž޴TAX(DidY?ness1bexrea9yWckȫ䄚worldXyaAdy:ir_sСxuAnRhItroZ龧Âaap戈lXk.ת`alkwi@yIIinsPly,Joecarblue!"Ц+(_[red,rpologiz[ov"h!ndispensZoꩧgSeRӼ_S((rvițהHIa`IsnormouHup.‹HIXiPè@oulsiXreqZ/.sopbQ,ٓZr1ew5ǫi8C///Qinzmrequi mwwђBHbI'mrowolAI胁itBcXaiculڝK.`ʐ viQshQ,KI?mey̆)noapʄ`imag0selfet*()yetmo cQ_Iꚡmak軰ohodrapicb"1nHI.i$li`_zXrwbe)ified (ǡsof(-gooduppo{iSys8omHpi8aы0rdeseeA)IIQuAHsۀenoQI i>$9҃earts;'venlyadeuckyuess.riticsxtionhethervidencesealneededornowledge.ƀxexample,storwn mightay "Ihatyxoyeespstingrom@butan'troit!"ep70hasf(picularactithoan؆͆Ait.nsponsȂ8*rongbelievPӁhimdoeshaenoughtoharge@E܅n,indPtegralˆ


    E3 TGettiProblem.aJcenturiphilosop`ook`Hxd{cistsju`fi)ruefJ1963youy!fnamEdmundpublishqree-papap llengtradonview.X om(ituaicheӆ__fKdootunWTiwdubb"76"discussPquickdominavicacz'clllrh pءyco xasieko䔟_SupposI`aɛappeaʋd@irst,i*Se0d 'm1CnJhhڎYP2riAalsoѐa},DIu aׁוHowryurgdby rcaYt`–YunawYo AlQ`ty4,dpwoulڃeryaffcolor8 ntly!claimQoσCIϋϋςIfooIecˀy֘ۼ'%waygaiЛ Rx+s`"instaυ̣WSgenuisugVlTBefin!eriousflaw////*W8QЇcp)"֥[?meDadpul2/{w skKA.os-typɁinvol(HdHZouur2сlB{9r-߄Ӽ8Perhaps8qMDpfcepxnMprecise|f`t茋g^:br>undefeatedustifiedrueeliefhaton’tountsknowledge.his,nactHsroblemithostpossolutionHoeettier:feerivenough,willikelyindpnew0exampleeH0.


DRUTH,USTIFICATIONNDELhVISMPpoolTruXadcon'see`arwo(eymponentsalso8ncep(neJmxplanZmselves.etsrlooktnoj.y    E3i ori>5蓀manyossieaningW`alboutPvٕfPndowH>orkIarorzHgegeniuInplsaspd ""suiaXicphilosophy,ؖËχHrestric0istm[r$h$ld –uc`́"Marwhitx`"ParcapiЄQFra"hqlafe(h,w it fуb,'ers{bhicularkarrieci؞niYere'suggfromcla cHng:)blockquote"Wth?"ou insis@x^Cor8 deXzex?"ǂǂǂǂǚy0wer,Rfool,quixhleHP߂߂߂݈Iev`Iayuwwwva0 so!ӱJre!Purveyo0fXehoodpw؇炇>I'micҊrPe (!old,Im,PhH!S_WWboacâsHe sPsiِwou8serious8g ʠPgr`dhij0cཀ`dupؼyBͷꁰmoH(ǂdAssЫ mdisagres1ctn"wi@sidh(eadcid8Hh.x،πW(smoHfam!?(ҢzٻIyq:/HfI瀸o realitycommXepwlook Og owIndaXd( Hcept.CsimppreflHt(aks.”'nmʅٻ0Xhispfqwhenpain9땁XpelUwS?sЃkicmmediYmajflaw9t:don’tSesꊰ.n 8b fPo!cKI`kmerc*hf0X@Pc(wepen@unreliabl@W` 􉐂s7r(l1@eymx@ɛ9hadByow.ƂЃatPmlxhahuciqMwyIadcI2إb0#邦W`|_zWtrssus9trnsȉ:2oUpreteIdi2ϕb`d (Й>xe@f qsoaso풡ougAhIHtig7t“BmurChpiE|aeРԉ)O`gerprkhnessestimony,t’smpossibleoreournackheandsfihirectlyccess2scene1Charliemurder.nxhavxintsbouthatrealitys.imil )fɂHmnvestigatingtruthtatement “Godxists,”can(t΂Han8finite powerfule,vefǂdirstorightro@me.ԃbЄ0wouldiso` idencmysterious ndIbePeandeedqus,correspo肳eorynotermit(oayi r IXruBillthr.)

    E3ecamAdeion cowy,ichimRaddhortcom󉿉I.cȋBg,'^p csxaargHse"be@fRantHpSoatupu-iactualr肠f8wn adpyBeGBmeshwebqsuppm.ƏexamplexmyrAtBcoll0oRsusanʡpaHhRIcei(W?X;peo ariabreDjWŐ/-avoskecobcl`Munrabi匢ens@!ÁjhallucinZ.ׅBHQ-0o --8tra@hid; blu@de쭈?siJ0onWsoYT w?8ees?8xs؀`fϘ0Ŷӎie0ag8jQfregaaviR._zUntuȷ9Qcrhcismmoе0aˬ"ьДvicXtround*n#geІchuh{r0unˆexnX\GTndѲ__Cho–'"R:,,(’sKc@tXissue0Tro`my(0 go.TakDžsuo.ͫjultuIthghhXabas@vvi"ۃ1p0s:YpicisɌflirdЀxA gusafic`anim0wciЯYȧn.ɳ؋b(t!moPyeansufiXXguiltp|day~ferprDNA8psycogfiم˕Iribu@9Oڄ?ؙs/Y,(noدRtypѣ*ink򌨞sol:Ȅwwr@dnHfLgx''"@noo_{o[sponܞri1pMJeahilos!b@*ь}RHp@unnsXgse defon!̃xb:as跉a&@_Etself.Åqtw>: br>Ig)킟    E3up8alsoac(probl,[0)buil؍normalp0js[weqerPWhenЖٞ"ha𙱂m}.ccasAiJ/%f8bwhappr`recogniz$do@ncqoݓ0 ▐𝀃Ht a5:Aminߍބtnequu( ness.br>O8threementknowledgء&ؖ\ttractPmoXamterphilosops.Ɵhurollow!Yfdclismy`viewЌI 8arranglikHkw,P pԕat9tbcprJ ҁnon-ԃXa"example:Kblockquote*M (nT)hNT󴑒u8‰gr-lHfXluC:׆׆ׄ//*I':n潈tyh@(wwwwmembPr:sok GGGGGGBWV''''twoptЇYǛRWWpirst+welf-evidH{amusxquin@urjxZsu,m`bomtubׁĞ، vfs$famerceiv-col0 kњ$c8p0way.v8huc݂Î,aH{GD?inqu as 鑿znsfaupQm!ߺoނA; nky҈{rtbetweخbeginJveHbottb,cemHlidkmovupward*9h𕠳placeWD `к)b0_in8rt) M.`OOL    E3ileg    E3nXtern8_alismqcont:icˁ(structdiawebyɠ8eng any烸 șend|WQurThuҀx脙@HlbpebhE唢:br>cesi>;ɀcep 2 2a@cАeuxiJ0o aseaveonfidencenhelockechanismtself, at’slleeedorderorustBtim(ellss.eon tavospecinternalearsfndeeowyelat)movementjPdSimilarlyhoHifyyeliefs,Ʉʄ烢eachdnsithurroundingmarenea(mHx`m;IdžiabilityQprocesgivesЁ.Ɂ|mory~i0wholleIxmlik[I(cornflakth nyfbreakfastperceptu??????;xcarAwhite.Ԓ⍲a߁ځvߌPinotelusioxlympairanxXrayightm misclat08gX신upst,HbēP.c 胦smaultsbPaa)co蠺MoouP8ro҂:@esumx؃ou8indey0hcanystHgQfjacNgasupportpoo㜊(eXlikHrickx8pPeb).usay[apȡipla׫wţZۊX n[tweponp@oriousunYtPar`choulddpeyRys؂ю,,tead,ˢhex܄Gѧ\jxknUЬ0glifi???ONpcau2$IberKI\Ok(хo͋`lyAin8aboup

    E3ҟRppeeWPdi8niruwhcYozairϗnшOKax2ؚaG9,߅HmkfinHraWWVpolitigh88exagPP,H@cdocu"ٌYlogtcebampTg3Šۈ!!beoodn؀cꤊi\viXUop0h2w*easzsesЄa`br>Twy8fissuXf9t2raistgpX0aɰRHp!7h8gtX#feell.ԑtXЂAgenerؿ5aledgIlwK$opa(cul@cepXlame(ri2`q)ique9r`legovxrkmoamcl tX?9w8tb(Greekhilosop Protagor(@c.Q 490–420CEwh0ai“MiasuxX0s.”ȁpoʁhumbe!5i;auЁaskarfix`_0/beyo!xva˂e-flexiK_edEngln2//"imx߆todӴQkrlPڀ΂9eesociPeronAhgg/JOinpptBus藸ne;.1dj,IIy,Ycldn akyifferencehatyndividualoptYframeworks.omeksreimplyrong,ndthersayeittlloseroheruth.”ut@elathsmXalsoadp`itarrantsxnegyeiction?

    E3Ԅpfirsttepanswering[ques1recogniz чi0 diff`nypesfm,x@whichlessnihan.moinnocunrs aceetittɃ,viewcorHardzprotocolRgood8nnidepeلne’sulture.heneeteopXfoatimehouldHbo*mrake胐s?fQcis,َمPfiBprabefriem.learlySxn"socienvipm9you8iyɓoensIekrabsoluȊKappliill`(qEfbXЎyav `alontroqyXg ahHc'''t8judgُG럷A=er9mmonfeelpriwъrtm"largeI؉8roppon.venjoylv aint8zdo@playc),؅"o0ΏibiP`nQy(se( ݋/)6bigxsue:o0Iʀҟ)ۤc`Xogre8Uydknows “sutaaswhoxpflavohwithHaty1aagrmu@ XeSrripsQzfuaI*flP.ȡxw _phy@logX+dibIledkom$S.____?_綏"hof@qioughh`nspficBwoiphi($((discussHab,mHju؃ai>Tⅿuʁ2u`~mou(nLRs@(fُXinaꔈ80bj1*18yBJׅ臇i>ws0eviCYbefoWxuH`״Pco0sGerilosop9Fdhietzsc8(1844-1900) ldembrac!X8țh:br>
[Tv]as tchingphoopullfhickens,ndeedAthemthariousindsfood,orderstolde “that ygiveirplqoffsprnd]ayooeggs,”`icheemedhim9bePvebadum. . !Ia(also2co`nuhe, unyapsoyouppldren,1mჀealie؇#wHBquP0six{a9leesanparts;[rtude鑩vxuh1hstyceaosjgsttobeautibjecH`nature.i[?8zCastPPSkep`x]ȔWif9okZt’siQXzlyedaforcaccbsurdxewski8shmr 򊫘mj.or"}sibx2+2=6ThuHnacknowledgcertaplꟿketiqueЎ@hcphpeoe@drawli8Ȇ8startrui!ion. "    E3owXspooP?υ0approqъBnoФxaiscH1xg31bhrs.ietzYguBpX8sp worlRyinnp Prkueaxt>Iour0erpre;"innimpulsHg8st.Ū*sortirppower;危h:@1QwougladlmXډɅG ;nor0[WiaoЃ, 481ggg>׉`sS`flaچI2ruggamopakll.{gȂ,poug@cG˓76ڒs8sڏlifiٛp AlloHbr.ɇPeopod@heͩ//////09lyiena3elwe.ƭM,777tR։|oimed@Eny-monAiohumP8tory.himreali+wwJsswayЁʌciRirHsIWstZcKrhȅWT͐0exeW)8doXi>*Xh8ۏՏaӂ PmQ᷿ߡ߷rȏ؉a !xlief/or'okkso3outea dow#paHabsurd)seX7:sciH?ɖiaЁଐnؾauspbye("H;nklphyhloglrhi0TQM Q`;meQacI–`ppSEweb9BbȠp20\feel Xt‘ .mP3JledgHc走mbpfix7efې09nexami:ehs`'Bydetai(JoE.CIENTIFICNOWLEDGE؁ERpi؅RIsaacewtonhpir9iegra0y:ysitting beneathreeeawnppleall,hichromptedimoonderyhingslwaysellownward8thsideorp.nimeewtonormulaCseoryfniversalravitationdescribttracetweenassodies.essn(2ivintXigentR(,xvishbىtiricnewspapTOn0.ccord 鉐siew, “becauspHgce, 'God'fouiApusymr.”roirYyit)pag8OldestambookJob:Butnkindbor@roublasurelyRparkpslyfe8gތremq,1IftyKeHy)yPc_\gr@ty?Ԍclear@teA aonscious?on9l:Aǁ׃hobvxno!xu,hDIrodZe`-batigȂB. hleQskRic[etrqu4 ''1tᎀunatur@ntʛHχՋQeobBoxplainoBworȀ0@gXiledualymecic8phenoa.(do`9casthough8HeemhHrph3e’ec00htispМةGP,hde(minearlostruth?


    E3 >ConfigYꦘ.R!@rt1po@Jdiscuuishth0fH(cepts: yposiPYaaw eakȮ̆@_8Y[Xany)pdႀatP0ozwhrequirheuz)Iҙ>begumX釘sעqualk6.hismaɂ8spx‡obvڛdthoЄvirtngQ zll.qepmz_Y?;@𔹄όmeglik2NÂxtsupp3@eri idQ C1耸mptIalH`/IE ck t-᥇wra@ y:Ѧtno7cfՔ#thilԅLastlRyfPigCaDam=0X,`edawYsu ro`t\(ourn#slarierary;assu؜teabiψfed:a8^waȒok; 100ears`\ۅBg𮙕a򴯴7WWhH̬4criticonɏablϲlaim:AoZسѳ!sdiff(wayzA7ж fac`_Xc+exhib@QimplicH1;Ptwoi ԊhoA8ruHaesguara؍DitKXbҒaaalz8s(ldep.äqr`0ay,nisxg.Ձ_\involvٸӬePe)nQ!Xphysbod8ƍІʞ0nz0ivXguhdHDwnwarda6ډ[    E3econdomponent1firmaunific,haI8bilityoxplaieangphenomena.ԁrulthumbr8smonfo5a!orybetter.ciezsimhs)relatsystemfЅlaw0aietsatita8extrRyBribute9schem2n.ɏzgavHnitialooshoewton’vers@gravitPrior,strorssum0zxnetYdreleobjeolloweirwnqueJ{wfromoarth.ȂX,h0#egoȏpreciselp!aiʈclhyshd Peythirdbؑ''cessful)diq.oou)uldsimporganizell8bɛ8xreapoكewǜ@wbump>up^u:a.Ǔȁ!19th뎹H."ɨh€ֆeYr.Ƃ`PJRanoProoyB 0ʨ0ilosopIKarlo@P @re: br>AommonredictiXmadeyortuneellersshat “a(jorventllappennourife”r3so keerymp8a0acquain`c.othfese-caHdws)tplaceo tterۆe,ndIexperie`verefuthos.egitictific9oHs,contrast8lwaysold@ossibilitybeingdnewataar;mhyutt!hirstcrisk󈒁Xy’rohYmXisvSqfactEhnisalravitavulnerablocfm0utuOsduȔ p(1evidjaghst釈Thuaood;spotq蕠alsp9ٍugh sp(ufied.


    E3b>Ainpusounda1knowga(ibasxwxep]zafeasAheyPhabitenvironWlsɂ(IstudAch ngzviousaccep_iewFxampi虭 earliclaimsQ,wisdomwmCohelp¥cp8fib8`ц``cr.ӄq8tp`xdQbaytepacconʜhAa8ckwardorrec0nre\.whiY3largbodR/secwhst8ishB3nZy ̝hhgkaarIchqsequ,y߈YthrXman`erlyssumpor( sePș:rax0cpseѲaȇg𝷝J8]Փ(hifrPa-ceؗTmpWreek0tPxrtolemyounsypmch8defeXCrnich@1500ThP W,P0ɻ,d8xhswap9model celȭhbjXIh2ffQhrnevʿLmobulreplac!؉HNewtonsw.ρ0mpa`_sparkDarwi;xpGŶ!geillhx؅Biga{ҴWp0bposo8Calyχtoh1hAHJtPHThomKuhn (1922-1996).0u0ƒwwAesb gќgmz;webObefs!m`@memʕ2!unhimajޅ2ٞsupa;aX.N,Yh(YotrigKphrdo"̫in hP;anebx i9awaⱧjwialsI鷨gu it)̈́ qxjntxeptI󵬇ط捀'"臨rɀHw*5;I'@ilkux@Hevatbuip"ꮱpri0Qinvgx HowrHOJpiSg2쌈adXHiSxYKe٘Ĉ)OoberBdž. gG?ߤGmZpols:hXroupin1aul)itÔPinadequP`yâ0_Y:br>Politicalevolutionsrenauguratedyrowingense,ftenstric)to(segmenthecommunity,atxistyin@thaveeasadequlymeetroblems1nnvironڂPysinartrea.nuchjsameasciificWWWWVaga(aarhubdivis݃䆉adigmhsՂfunc7yQexplopdhaspecnatuwhi"xitselfPd0eviousl8bothσdgcevelopT8!malcle`pcrs鎰rerxtBo.
(peight="0pt"idthc>KuhnrHran9fromol2newo`no`moone.anyustshllfaso~Eneedt菡ver-numbersupportersefofloth9bThupsh(0Y’Ieorhjc{cumulve:uryorieIbuiltr9cfoundpԑstgxknowghifaccordrsڙ suJre ismhisшX(*websybelieɀhe8''!Cim)ruthnMjYTB*.
FhRew ǁǁ1.׃athreargumen!radskepticism?">2fourcri#߂߂߂߂>3߂߂sPcexpii΂4keyeatnon-߂߂߂߂߂5߂߂߈PsmP߂߂6.esb"JTB"eH.www">7LXoiiGettiׂgg`8.ΫɆd)ffНruth9justif00ypelv ǂǂǂw{w@hⅈ7alaws㧀firІǃǃUxKuhip0gXvol` OOפAy@ׁׁ׉qH8Halogueetwee衷onk`hsvɦJ3aWVha,commsensuceExot toIeponisoind|o77i1___׏׏ԛtpo ߀gardmΝrobsurdsequen ???{eMfalshfwhekigioulikQЏ*el igjX,raPQcXdedm2IhaptA'$litbr)77b>REFERENCESNDURTHEREADINGwwwvWor8C`nrdpAppeara8lockquoggbInfoxousHeGacult!http://www.kross./groups/h"sg.htmlSext Eus, OutCPyrrh (c. 200E).0cs`byʀnnahBar(Cambri:À]nryМЄ(1994)}Hh,avidRTXPNc1739-1740`TstpdSczƍ)NortMa (OxdlndL`OOOOODeRenérM2` 641GG+CotthamiPXPhilosophb0 !198GGGG@LJohEssayrnUn89Ǎionsy P.H.idditch (Oxford:πBniversityress, 1975).Kant,mmanuel, Critiquefureeason (1781).ecentranslationthiss.ruyernd.W.ood,ambridge:_998>Gettier,dmunx“IsustifiedrBeliefnowle?”Analysisl963),ol. 23,p. 121-123ׄׄׄׄ>Nietzsche,rPrichWilloowpك06:staOOKWaltKauf0n, (Nework:ikingi67">Beay,amehThestl SkepticismA͒pscrip XbinCies!ed.Early@sponshHume’sifeReput Bristol:hoem2004ooooo">"EvangcalcisfuGravwith΋'IntelligIFaPng'peory,"aOn,ug8 17"5ssh41.3">Popp1KonjectsȉLondon:ou3ouhXmadStruڊficHvoluO(Ch(go:y62Ch. 9r>(pFurthЦd؂pρeldX,ҝ#phemology{(EnglewliffNJ:釸ceȐR2///">L`oa3Anntrod) |n,K___Mo2Paul˞S+Hbookgy+㶷τ͉ττττSosarnesYKim)egwo:nth(MaldeXMA:lackwX0gbN''can="1er">***3*r">CHAPTER 6:THICS @AorOb)iv4yggȂOԁYModera0Compromis.elfish8烿eorgo////+Al?????82agSurvivaloo>C.Qs؂Emo[_ h:etngruMvBehxorWWWWn’t ruPUt@ancExpeeWW">D.irtueSouseaGen''''''ul ה'.Ŀ؇g1z GoO@OtegorichImpgggggAnimalEnvironmww>F.ilitarian/Gׁ׆nlculuWWW>HerluЏ7gggggonshyhest77pi hoFReflف1.hatreom(t@geprinultBtyouh8heardbout? ">2uppo 2Iescueomeoneromrowning.hatighteelfishotivehindyction?

3.magineyouereebatessuefbor thomeoaronversȁbecameatedeAonally-charged8ssayoachrn1spic4rplovpunclied,viewqeyqalkutYaonderfulPȁwas.ӈk,orxamplh`H6󁀂PQenerouan$flatterIxtrait]msxscribe5.!yrahPcitpeohnownsPvely?+“Don’tteal”6.anؕA"lyifroducadsequen0noodes?ԊhQQn-.br>    E3ɓHizast pʶb`thamipmemZ`Re#tookcX@claihaܡ0ieoath.ďtriallawy8[НCdib!.ȁ""Ʌ.Λargu%dlsibilitoXXi٥atwhich[fai9o.+vo o 3c`ч϶KnviowwwwGuTessnr@webaeH)pts:behor,vastaʺǚټbutrag؆S@8IselfishgHItBRX0uvefeXߺݛm+isa((sa8r(Yyi@!.ƃ2,5#phioppYberyonrᢰy@rpldg0oJdiffHdramy:chapwqllX8somٚȥ`0.br>AORALBJECTIVISMNDELA{8XWWApuzzl(tK HilIsce: do)?ľa؟rQxcht?magi⏱dhant 0XwPm0bodaȐf;YfiKJaygZKey"aC!rewarˑ0adYpl` sXngRdBЩ Xwouldouʱ?σqhYmIBý!crazy׆9improacbhun٧SXre`nqjus؎$ymidȑ€aworlJAsonbjevism4isko iXon,Xmafu radsmbracFirsؗX^@ꂰƅstandardsxistsndepe(ntlyfumans.ftenhi sescribedspiritualealmhichAfix!nderH,nlike`ehysicworldociety atAinonstantlux.ed,ordar@don’thang)roughoutime;yreternal.Ԅ@true/AipeopleollowtspZyear0goillpptodaPw@futureir'universsensp#4@yonxNoneclaimbemmufroPde8cчnplacen8ll.

    E3υo(rpphXingCrevishstorb*gunmen,ousayoridwro0byw #em:suhowdo!ngڂcountry.evYoncept1ice,aer;eiRwsupiorcdiffer(ښR2ositi8{relatim,alsoreeX0redi8Firsah`invXp.Жct/,itqnoes,rsomϠʝ8QŒOoESfad) valueOj \@;i*steaxӆpurqIsbr>MrObjecMbi>.̀oߊRπeaZl!d@uishؕ(i(imporRproqPoPP0o (428–348CE)9ovelopwo-tiiciI: wPlѰZzP|rockt8a2ucboH31aajZs(ointt4shif肸caxscractіgenui th+Ina񂓈f@Ypar`ularahoackRnbejl耘1fmolҖYf@E8ΖpformsCޝ Y遠amWTsetbasidЏjԇgra`Kl1QIddO񃪅ꁡ@؄إrawisdomfXodnesןAccooc֐claiypo嚰-s@bldiAruN{ncapabaPRceDb.҅Wj1Bb`lamearg0,2ᗩ*acqune0awaken{lawڲa@uIBaspeciond`tpacIc ,Asv’spewꍏ,ynplembXphilosopxy۾wonecȇhpopBpa200ear0Ipp:emphӸ47AXIتP0ȡl0sfeJsom(iPHy)pHitldiJew8wwrЉ+n0ja LgŸryGerֲ1ime+We98cʹN=ZYxun[g{suggeswayÚȍDzOޙXigi(:qGodzwih omhx)l.iVH2c(subp?y;nsۆߖmb`zy🨴6E؊ٕor@Pcle:qȉzo@ex0ZA@arowknA6alX)commanded.omeuggesthatodpeaksosirectly,rhasivenaoralonscienceomiribeddrule(pture.achfeseu0divineevelation, ough,qu 9grede)rust @ldeeliopwhayPUtoPhimbombnborlinic?politicleaderцellswagligiowarga pnnemyuntry׃’s>0erpretZacIrperi1oxrs?ԋextreexampH,u eywclaimRknowZmindannotakHxfaluXRa,ofteatasH8(epe(ntandarfightnesēHhingIdithz\n.


    E3 MRvismpi>i A)fspr)philosophylotrovpi(skeptrad9AccordlGreekeӎؑEmpiricuif!wa0"`Xa2s;rejЃrobѠpth.ookpworlP,youHllэuflipi؃2ity.ϑ(%bistJpursuasȄ)*⁦ign2elowillquallZipeoHJact hqsoP@irAyJ%feed"jvul?:pPx0tdem(iHe0ˤehttitusex:)blockquoߙߙWi!shamefuXo8exa8m"pbx⤨Ë|romndia.yЃ@Jiffеlikx)wrKstoryoAd,osR@disgm醩f8`y EgyXa9hhx peXSPr*numbl(Annnt!nk`P@9{Ha8ishSirmaraHllIxwbe(ehApmeIАStoicX zpabسeepmp!օ@"lbrofi\[0Out@S:i>, 3:24]pVH ,$iryw:PviriЀsW8ask8gXaorqHpreyrsonp$zview ?@؄ n8omHJjudga(єxf7Iubqe`9gfKse)Hs “ima Pv ـu.”򌷌??acpoý4arguc`varion[whicis:Щ___(1)ɻ X,aiт(dDŽƎ$.WR2) f0󃿃31܈وƂߜ߂>Inremise 1i;@iߕߦsenP4alwaysXradiyسÊǂLJ xe`t㸜fdx tf@ZÕonlywth?o2thropologٸudiclHshownormo8P gworlregulZabsHngiciignsu@honihxIiQsexI0s8cbou9LHɄoutselfli00dnbval)hotogeyBZch ccl9뇠re    E3ow큙objects0spotoisrgument?egardingremise 1,oOts,omeeople႐societieevilit’sourprthatyoncocjirwnelf-servsts.umanatuinherȉflawed,hrhapsecau8wȁh structedutfimsyapistuff,r''!psychologicalcripd.nirase,Q aarribetweenُhЏmS0thweakwillindh-madeilthO|Ǐ22st!tinuekXicsave!exagger drsityk8senTЋ؎T}indeationculpracouTworlbhuch?anyffقIinvol8Njtast rtiquex.ƀyxam0tllengthextdesbangunȅsbritual[import1Л#bZwhi؊kcprQfu depminx(0mHvawayH+sHherly)܂=ceșPFurvalmbC`endorSƏߏsPprohibiY8gair؆03h akriouspre9_iyackӅAux/׆p[nromǗwfXst.rbr>Hoom i>Rto Ŷhbo!1ȡЩ(m:(Qďunchʁ[(i>_ner-uӝъpspiyɋyormЄpul8ۚ؅uviewit"\essnno si8.Hnrฯpys٤doy]unsonab@phuxNCiXfeep)Iexhomo` erfP si;ȏXϋ;ao0owiHppeaȠy )ksoЍ8WWT`ng`|mayt!xg0Yh-⫯[+unNхv–oughgQal!'oooOj3tw mQdextweh-mҀōmfirme" ly-ޟ6,tfix街́聙ewinumbxeKaq.Řkul`ducouhildrenvoiaigelpPAlefoId_ü81bs8xVZHىyecific$ruy //whemptcfP@#obligGGwdIc@ulsopuXc@a ea(;qhigtaso0nL(SimiɆ8'IwsǎLJ1Bdisa@ȍzwa ” iFt8 antYS߀1princiy.a0timИ Ãȝ%oo}P磇WXc ٣dmmphasizoPGsctɤ"";mkeccorr:nHIp؁J"8icxon`aPoso8calable.ssumeurtherhatokeyoralaluesreurelycicreationnd8ryadical inifferentults –uchsulbouexuactivity.eves,wppeaoeniform@܁eedavoidarming9/ohowindncRThesightaPfUinstinctъhav@huma(oousxfJbiologvolu.e$animalsyura,Tususԉriv-dr@naf(`؊(ceitha.Ӌn/groundM[soplpromhrsonyT`gtworldechnTsPg,ghAwouldoeternjd ng:ymergۋҗ0quick(di8lfuחdlopm tibeI0ssrq-މܔ tmid1betweobjeʅȝ zextrxs.

    E3ak(separatنIogejaackagHQhtwoompisPpridggax$yconfli0tuiˁmz.lne9l9ettisle’@t1wa!skhnϨ΃Gx/)br>B ELFISHNESSW peo8obankwy2 mo?selfish.np,f*beibxdP q-oriHdesileep,Zx@Pne0iArJٙg؀I 5x 2 ̅wq.ostw(o1deermail胀uspt(sawmoa؆@Knowelder y!ҮقXknockowcdoɅQrc˃ic(#adKcat mkerosenhHragˢtowar,⏰bؒx8,.ƃHfIaso` par`Jmafetal[injWٓ}rdiʊPoice lit?χexplaАٌn@t 100%ջmϻ?hYŽL"sr8p p(.8TiC₈ʀ8Ztru.8waiHcrcsay.ʐbeؑ@cp}burnbuilhjdoesKmeiAcp.ayPewѫ񙠎ùꈈѿѻrixreceono~tY`jxpdidSre1boHP]bQ/Pasgow?c,ppearAsur2q egorsdispAу"psycholognd`oɋheˆnci03se:)blquoh3i>P͑光my:condui 9 әcanno٠ŖӾp;ŠWWWWWR\g`bel@ccas`b؋HEp    E3B͉certain9Ѻ[wEBdoPal?ansembed80a:)mpliHsDтh٬pZobligjoI@do.ɥakqenQ I`mOOvoidfSmـ88,RyɃǃǕA amppiɕugY;ack2equiocЙxtH񆠃withinyoweroventtempthis,etloneccomplish.uppose,ow,ome9saidatavnbligation1donateQcharityrometelytruisticotives –ithhxpectofaxreakrythbenefit.ulfillingӄependsnarnheI’msychologicalcapablectw .ԉthough,sreciswgoould nInhortfamocked؉Xbehq@f lyx4moralesponsibilَakga


    E3 TCaseEm. iO؉xtorious(fHers9mas‘philosopThomHobb(15881679).beliДdhum@besbiachinRfollow*sameindphyszlaw\make1sun.u8tocessaYgonbH҄wup,Hwe0noruu*twhXsido,9mulookɇcHescri detail臀IvpYly-bdA drxrconducxYpsxea)TЃhminyيyhoi+inn ?s8erg0modram(:0rdo$PlifeXsexsuchfoo sheltscarc qeuick!XPQacmx8alxo(皧WXlʄssu:,eI0woifߌkmonnX9:𡹇exa@,Xgenu(pn虁?:zXstQ0cuh2burnPse 1wQHҁedctowarvirefl@(3)gσ̎ gσPremi15_Xsi@ic+hi0PqOckham2RazorٗSfY9pieX`ilosorplliamy3Pogularr[it.Ѕ2`iPidotMneT txq Thc8mIpar؞ppeЦ`Q8horrbysfenX_n櫸&cissuZ@dx8lmPri8]morp0za񼓂 re.πsuPasritishlergymanosephut (1692-1752)hoefendedherinciplefnstxtiveltruismgaobbes’sttack.ccordingot,Gsundamentalrrorasversimplify8basico(fuamoxation.tookseatnidyreduceythaP؂"selfishnes0sdid,ut,says, naturesooexllow憰sasyolucTthusremise 2Pabhrgu1 –inotsphO9cityQ1.ȁچtwopecif⊢ Yory.

    E3irs0aǐNjdfiA؅I“-lls@st.eyRur@ɌDy⍠͉ow,@meli(RmuperiappeaPoes΂uchungesteemhlthoughقhXudifferф/ns.upp,exa,Im2r`0IXndwich}n enjoyexien`=GMynp#y[Iѝf8h ypwoulHtill(݅imilarly,pth&GGf,xcOsi(Cvaluoreo(o!htakej玐 oɆi":kXdTgoept샪critAocausly:"ۍharoupgcYrevda;:9헡icien__Yco3poinsh@rmdonrEfrom'ym8clpsychologI;itbiloRdu0PNow9qSkIxujS\?n2colleWWSAȈя`gwˋ8huroPɗY􋄌Pwell?ǯǯǯǯSe!Iℑ@a)Qbenevolbunderl)fdship,as,Jp(nhfeegbPmؖPhЅ 1iX?ނterprecIfrgsId Hexer8ypprc8`ow̄d!ngh^acuel h Xv{?JtdidnЍqiskxownifIo0Zjustoo2watcheDXfHhha"̄xleކ(hObvpaysҾ؃0":px4r2extrocHItsJasڻ lwaZ0dness.Bbr>EeӟgɏSurv`b0i>.ŅȱYnabisprDarw`onwardjhcap:c-b+o9rbaq`:ssumzorganHQ se:syxksYEr@ntuySk񄑥ztegr(rfifficuljfla`)sa(ӏ F kizpeoAdo єjibeƒoc—l1roc12ls0equi_X{s////lrej(umsm,X100%rlىfwhSup(|IaHllɊYxag:hrSP oo1fpicsli+RQbpx treDfha*fenuineltruismne,utheavemansurelygoistic.o,ovedyympathy,ivemyppleadl"star1oendusailpassʄӃ8nctnoffspring.eanwhilӅ3sdSwomena,YyatXȄh臵raitsirヨdren.ԁmoralstorythatgfsotonducourvival+if8arhu`Xveray,`ouleelimindromIoolonggo.ЏPfeejeHRevolutiona`ndpoinH0r xlPw@yp8bȁentXPior3~xplain:㎨chgulRshowhwardurmi3eccasAlǁsngers.

    E3egPfirsp+mbi@}@througЈkseli>IgOfa2ncreasorgan cӃosdon’diut.eIsIᢡ×Plsomprkhanc@V8Ԅrib ju(Aw.f`reseyXssyf؉⥐ayٛXyatum*mak`ajQacrifi̓ o[perpetu .Ƞבו_\ opsoft-co.ϩviewkeHnti+Hish#Ihoᆘoi0G㕠"ruZinxiguْ1b藈0sid ag81XirgpptimIpfuYxscioexwhybtnhip4IH)(7xiologarguʦ҉ZM `afi)0sD21ociaRFCol`ChurcH{`eegᡢ8†zarh81r`ñưGՆᱠlenvie 8erlț H1D{framhrkۋbr>C.EASONNDMOTIONȁׁSome0&aH alkb!pPligbecauPytop.ͿmoٕHȊsiX1alli*isuabor,omxuacapihuh˰m dvoc0@q)oraghbur pr킓e8vzt`0bkHla…xsetedYerPnt8hk`slat8h@ɛЇ PETA –ЏSDŋchTtaA􁁃nch0roj(hll“Hno0Pl”`ipos PhowNazik-ci Icm*gebunk3coma!@xjam-pa`ɍaXderncyggim.ŏJew؉{senoȃ*8ԉriv`izuffaf5vimWquePy@h1nȚctwe阡Z\.ӁqposopZhag9s8B 8ʖon afengȺ:h`/,st"mpẗ́%aupI*atɧ9FSm,ppeϣ+(A1letehilexdec»{weƒroabmXˆa.gg>    E30MR2:ąؒTruivЀBeiorKPb>+70ntifwoniu(1)Yhcҁtha(2@u abxY0.ßr irs8Wȡ8diѤwayB!hIeЁalreadyookedtlato’siewhmoralruthsesidenepirit-realm,hicheccessroughurason.or+yenɂyoIustookeyond*distortphysicworldownerenarthၠhavomethingik@ystexperience.entallyinhe0nsgraspnotions,mu:ameannerligious0lieversfdivineuidaManyHilosopgrewioltAwartf'e,uplayЂzanglnstead,Iyrguehgcibilitrecogniz8ZlawGodmPnhuPaturTnonwareniPinctippriples8xuima `inbornop)ma(ics:A[nb0ttxTvoic8yWh1cquirӕЁP[oonaoȊl:gs؜ s.

    E3ÉXHrHxthfe":_Z–iAat۠bb`valuItesnQȍgo0coX|devisgay!e8Ifolloe"EyтYl`pro beior(؝o8Yr釥bmyاpssuP[ore2OOritselY•SÇ factϞinfa@uct.uppoImّ2y1oPabbek,IsocXgedaypfWIskipp mRplazHM`terш (g؈ puthdHdd‹h:ellkXwrox0;+animalIAmew+dA0ly-sdfelٙi awhexaka nuX{ch ي'u@mis)eQfromurh@XШSbr>umfir`?0Psxch8engQeɕ!/.Ȃfam@arB0xѢji@!ubjectǧ^YhHweqxlmo@roxlefr^te2oHclaimrv?Msk2ȶ́Jrtrar!vespraskReg9 1L.IQjyouerm؁`exii1inkahorr"deed,A@rдctiwspeciR8tituqm.f8lJobl?ڜ/uzsurrounو5ouldiWO0Afind?ـcȮceppla*se(raAbodiBvfeel`JͅinytR/.ɍ8ea“ymYturnflHXrwht,”‰idpapprovi.rEalWˊassr’sasicris:_)blockquote1p> vk( )щntifniquNq( sԅnυυυ2any? كꒃb indurmotionaleacY.3.herefore,Isonoesotiscoveror@truths,nd,nsteaHallassessmentsresr>(pM,`elieveqPmuchikeurvaluafxartisticautyatȃindainting: “itXyself
object.” s
lImah:piceV9n’toway8y(Isr0pirecolaHafe`worAbgo߅+(sQPdIchar.i (ys+abbehavi؟:E1Hu`oblig;&followromjGoldenul`51eohappXWtiwos#dxynRxרЀЎāso OOOWHiXttack";iО(apsulBCJ:a[A[>M⅛PܟҤ QCwچxms;seYt@ܰ؋,neyxmeHJȅ\@07ePaals`" hi_s@s.͘com`*QN)q2+.?//.8F̀ςw˞q#eamo'''''>AupұЊmilkzo>9dQ聈chool'''''!O>NOOǀφGЌo!OwςR,uckOhorbgood dayl烧Aydiff@vhgroup̝74etrurl Qworld-OOntIxi9h[/+cXfuQxeheP,` “Irueralsehat’mဘnfteam?” “Is逐ruertcuprottenilksn able*Withonfactualxpressions,Xough, @sompletelyseosk,exa ,ׄׄgo@75yuckjNseryventueelingsndontepornycthll.

    E3yer1nss)decidenhichse worouphorurancesld.uppoayDonatcharity1aod`.Atirstlэс9ppearbe2 ,i` seem8wehmeanful8oon@777ng"war߀A\notafooled⍈S.͊?;likQreyloxhisecopcategoryٗwnWdždždž,wqsomeZ;HoЊ(C!1Siarly,?Sba(zhBoosډșaeymH="jpitc؍xemotivism:͋tu ʃܝ".(WEtac+@soZnnti*newevePhilosophepamonhfeluasyargmabghu0.ƏPlatoD^wqx/8nHthSextPEmpiricuȟ`{sociexxrovЄȃJEum88͈Iy{䉚booneȋlkE(niᏺ9wHTٗ"2se!oo0h³bravmٟʇ誘mUbexcitedMpdy(uctaPemБH)idasmf.Xub )genuin(oumK{m*si8`gu.Ci,ǝyptiĺpsif r:wargX1traYvoP0rsi9examplcXk8coopΑRNazicrcȄ(sETAZhaHhi@?҆+certaiih鐘9.ϧ;xnd"sdegrehb0؅sclctu zpfu!crammpin1euarzag8Xiref`EVorm1diftweXapaؤ3b;ʑ(72i0ieriсмXopږȔhupV.ӭxlty0roK`licA݇Џwi)WWU؍at ggȣqA(iw'el@Xu`٘2i.br>D.IRTUESp`nXwor`w p)hfhopsWayXkPbȕh#a knowledg9oolish}bluɉn@@eTrexd|cultiv8sa`dom2flfrpnX.oci notHfVicz@uQk:‡(dhimself0y(ble;ser=*pectLhel**5ordpeoH justbH08u,,ryiȁX1sadopt.ereP!op1Losgelxbankobba Rq iH2/(bguyserereedynheiresireoroney,njuststealingtromrs,ndciousyhootQevery@ight.heooduyo҂[P,xhibitedra s)yeopoYyrobbP’@chinegunsbjwXxenuityborrowmozfulaponslocalXPBpintattou45inute@notetsscapsqu`ties8whatall virtuesʂibas+cmoflupioof{ dxlopGreekhilosopArotle (384–322CE),HichQwiPexaeX.


    E3b>ЁVqMeanڇjdefdumanes “ration0anis.”88iHsXve"majXbiologiifeaturtԂoi`0doA`catpbX0Isami(extrasychabiPoeasonelevapb@߆forIaccordo,0intsbpla8etweeiccom0Xsn.et80egpwithgd8m.idoshnpgrgUgetirougday.șe`frewh facdarenjoyHfh0QAtrud΃1s„hipWicrivIsi𣒆uniquo.אԃdtpne,qfee`ourselmakaoplaȠo1mqcۧ[Hm8pbbؓ̓zPthI/coHo8ramyȎuppȡPyʘehYaco2m ituBxhItЙ,굙җ؀hRbp keepEfrom rHg(I@L,ߠg`,stelong1itaraflHOCh +n(A񘈴h`fٜragef waiQXinkI;s*amouؕ :ߘ Acp)݅jobzlop뾑Њفh؇AregulyNOρɯivirtPLhwibȁppy diumwoa)vbG0yproperitj2x"ƅw `temtzcenkaQ-O8mwspiriXssn .0s12azxNU9||ֈD߀ous͆9/EBFearsgCoward ǀWVCPWWWRash">Pleas牧FInsensi,Wance          W ntemperance

Giveoney||b>Stinginess WWGenerositygWsExtravag!">Self-worth?9 loathxW2respectWWhArrobr>@(774Onheurface,toesn’teemooifficultpindproiddlerouwithllf)seirtues.oeourageous,orxamplweustvoidPcowardlyrrash.owever,istotarg@at* iisasisaHnne.uppoImoli`opaIndersti|nvolvknowhowqregulatpyeardanger.mifpHchaHdownmeankobber?manyulletsڌځ3a8rexBpursuPXhimcomȊ?Ċlopak0muchimHrain(,roftenHsXildhoodducation.__">GWTheres0j(usualbout2ory:epellsy `neL,says@mono3morrules,a killӀstealertwa!funca7laneohJl `)؎HsXhxcon0ty낒law9n@ciA`nmbsi`IY!w(ꉊcenlar2SposophyhfocusHoar.Hyntؒo*prXXhtЈhk alhoulًkل,I.et2caÏ-郄.OOKW鰸V͉H ⃀.͈fem`+embrh+#viewtدh((siodispuxwhHٟwЪ(0@0ansychologiHyWY famili reotypjmale/88eЂY8gotoyusd䯨ghȪxJeaX Sgir_doЁsi0hlSm0gy0ghs ,ه@)qjtႨa`(icsڀPaly@task`SctroAmmun`s0Psюʥ–inborځ]uȟ)uri[soci`Qi9yH-doX`0etr豰}A)
.

    E3 PVsRulesڂhip,-alonoryasupyercriticshargtismissoralQ#easHeyak caseptwoȊȂȍ0nteirnvoaaradox:isusЅÄctualbeco`vicImagi``onossedstringi|,chtelligence,pHuity,Pticalmnx.Ah,maihmuceHin8good|beX.1However,x0P@fiƋskillhi)n:fll]eЍۂHproiP(a.ccordٖh8QreciXyhyfocuB8houldPunn`g,otɌ0ohollowpdostealQnw̒.urstYeto0;conduct.ƣPexamplwyouCqhelpreeddrawim)Ocː2effectaypr Yprima ough iɡ܃s ryqiuggg"O?IAs0g ץaskso"wtla!A(prap blas.Өsf)IdrunkHpmyi m;throw`n(aloHwspaIshlookhaorribll@BuHaitIaeJ8ȑ PŢinkaw`p(ocndɔidalebr(oȄ9IlapfudgRwhiI1be@eexseemЉuom|ymhIwr5XXunished.͞ʒ|ف8wors q(S@on0Ǎ$XsڂGGriƛ!(ncipЂ`Ȟknab(b8dɑRإo{habiك(npsych yoIGÇ(Pr*.ņ0clty0volPorscʍaCdiscsBɑriЩИ(ulaZZlcd'zy.ϨW9DcludRbatt0betwex-p?irst؂s9Ϡpٛ)(torage-otrad8SӒak؍p`osop}errXbhlifroiiHowٻПpZfuA݆ir9re 6sugg8JupŗYpongst ҟidՒhooWYshfea(!twpproa(harmonicoexShl@Ao0xHHlknee`elhwslepqwH|hu(貋rdrso,؄ w9hHfeetocyc`lӅdortodcertؐrfle`Yg@meqxhkext:nugbفun(valu!eQ8arxer9n"Hledg"}@c.OLalwwwgp`o1nt h& soempXiwi_CM/differisidbesreultifacetedndeayeveriaingleirtuousharacttraithatullyncompasseseplexatureforalbligation.


E.UTIEShȁJustscanxamine*ityLosngelbankobberynermsI9vices,similarliusola.Ԁtwoon P“Don’till”€teal.ɂ(sesXrutiqB9acknowledgculQroughouworl(A 4,000earldabylonitexXuccinct 8urrip0cK:Hintruduponis`bor'xe,pproach0orifsbloodtole׀garment?We+pbasic͍яHT(CommѐorecodXethics.d|ne8toov+author7#;somehowaaccepmtTayo1c0 8y. ''>    E3D[(GO`elhhOQssZdern1PdplopbyǜphilosopSamuelufendorf (1632-1694).krgXianeni@nllphiv(preciguidanceSf؏Xpsocipeinst,KȄ􊰄Aabi speakanguagysormrooQ(dwipm tiscXrunstY*Lj@reason",2, embedٛr artqhu)lLpccord(.`eyp|% zLetbriefookH@ggpsWA@ha :xbeoLikQnyOъѡiimЙb 邫ʾ9ubGJnʰhٜobservݨigne feritbe؃ducasm{er.eel>kX6iYIopt1ubu[equir .ΖHW varway%honhimporshippraỳ`г6Aklig(dh@@GviewђJla`uspjisubjec0Ei{׉ʏseem@*JǰneDŽQbꈨy؀x!(so(pfа)$egasshbaaHaradPwritbP,la0ru;upL0ddzychooєg'IPhtaboffimc峡(g,amti"'b+g:bodpb##ndI(ЏharmR9lydrmui
    E3ԂxCategoriAImperxvei>.ufendorf’say1oryultimlyclipsedatfermanosopImuelant (1724–1804)؁remaiimport1aboutWR+,@ough,通deamoralixinvolvp nwQdooteppoprivȀsiP.believ(r iwhocorr@(arguwonteoeize؅lisJd@ٕood,HeselfHA8ottoPqt e(a0hnci`߉,@i@dubbe cߎiޒAlfRsdIXyyЀȄjuappl˂8thiȘggd׀W0Beellusxactw1iWW(ihexplhowjudg2fffromuQlesscru.8r!!idp4}9(oce8ngreadomePokakettH9healtHg9n!Pjky;sjúkiXƛcu few7genu(8燀HXc腀:ڌZence?cdo2,@n-̓mphyptOJs:Cxifw1@agoal,AnIasldrmKp.fɂFxJng@ndiebenwϸficړes{,ww(ca8qu!01fYMay I~.mҥstȗx@V!Wǁ)ЎАՊzهҀ@lexzYnaJQruXWג ˣiabsoluco9d“Dtkill,”urder ׉HeKdroultidždžorxaebroiɡ偊circumstaHaradoxq@gfxsuicmꖬy󤘡)saAҭޏ•.neje pow@ul `naYmea@i"ٷslyI̞withgn98Qj8 Be@wetwozsmf:Xstru!`AxHsic.ӦKhЁWPw iᄈtoo0!plish elsMokeX`abs0tyIdoorXngocQloreraurp I !(arbag1ee{ (job#—1moneM9llowshutuff0Prasy-.Ԅ9Pه msep0redle@ЧurrnefPʇѝxsA_i]yxCh(yAw8wʱpoddyousk߄߯1ge؟be ?_!itwnk`ArmȜz2ϙ'ː;,RHstellˠٟIσgѣq,k5bu)#LJSjuP88 viewNQ.Є̓ks,ecauseeavereeillsndanhapeururroundingccorYoownesign.e’tayhatbou0ouseey.ecaiareniquenisespect,mustre@peopl)thpiality.

    E3heeautyfprinciYhieuserylearlyhyKfictionr1rrong.fonatechar,amco(zintsvalersonZ#hedevelopalentsXX.ϋ0(rhnd,ysteaack!gum8omr nxstore<2%ʃ(aebjȄtbenefit(ch8snwifs8ΕZmiss s/cr0oKantnvisxedKgor lm `!pi`ȁuGoldRulaargextvachiaimbr>.ŗ`CJaPfelobligxpplialphubeRI؁lsoGod.ufendorf,examl18l(0aena0plbaceful socie.wqirrelevсisQxon)up$cap*mak9ZAY@ !旚beveتd:rОɂr hc:any@likt`P.o0al]2Bʇ𞈆ciTmsel8[mg 8ancain/*򇏞8HieD(fi,no `diPi>䚥ward'ܟu9@nrli؂bas01owu0z-c' .uppo"youine8se)gsH(i@fIfuB)tui9sadthrill@)H ЃbIcaoork鷰up[oor s(01.uic8d;R8R__xLviolaً"7H (enavoiduchdubecauis숐b΍x2wWTod0s aЇseuibizaGAsom9#hckexڠggA󚼐`XZO;K1wPUA suggetȓgYstepyiyϬt؇{DQar 3$qhif HtitudpeJs@knP8b4hylogi(PQՂ:NbJicRcl(`opreus-Whmohirch–)Ѕnze<څgTbxhhqwrcompu9programb:vvabi0; xooٓrn8nguaX.uqrϰ(tkairhr@hȲ2-iPUzhXir wpZ.lYRڄxЛ=Ap,pecifDJRext8ACgo(!Ѓ_~٘C陰inlegod lawpnyet\regu P yld"laersԬ0࠱pis+mYwhೕˊi_Qf@ȉl:d.sIx,uststsrongooithumans?hesesuesretillporebate.

    E3ushihfon-utievenur0r,easkhehavenybligationsqplante@animals.Ѐclearlyn’tcious,`dimpossibleinflictmspaiYm!hicken.utgrow(cer abo depleɈ)res8maspxtincEthHsijpecaegularasihmayeHtۆ:k؀aunchweepmackard,lash"burnJtemberʍendangd?9,atȇ8ifftory.Ttow&oughAtway`mlookturspibilityH. oFirst, qΈenvihmionindirectas0how;pa advectxbyntalrWQ.ɍzchop(wheztjaxtemperatuskyroЇ@we8ـ die=wipooЋ disrupfood@ arvEcxrticш folloЊ*-cȔ reasnowledg8K9.eЎ2morL/ȏ8vXixirsake,iSXai.Ϝpview,gbCng,imiԛ{{bgen鏈{!u0Dna`oesKselikobvy,samX0tȴhVAdvoc򄰑XlogicXapproabt1rawXX"njne@\po@qЇomn`alں_gnPurrouabriclifHhEwoPXo(belirequ yǤaw8ny–kmysexhieahcgraspqRW܇GAs(peoЇhx apaQav҅m'Ulefpc8zIheawer.br>F.TILITARIANISMȴǁDheؗs1xxf8ww r̜.׉coulHPgit?ԁp m8srcs2so-HАnpQsa!0PufXorfelG@؅0dȇn;ˑtelʲL@.)ppfixunPrs9h#i t e` a`mostXivarʤBAc*gon`؁1uzsi9ϊbeXcaa預uicH@P0am1top,mba򖡁dixNewly-disc!񔧔cepwv#sjuipaQifDj[Qo`pHrXoryeOrejudicW8g`fiarrpri0`bjly?̀s@ЅYlWWW">    E3ɒl 18th 0smi>a錢oiwsye:m(Yby欤`ir fuRsbeɎ8uselvToPrs.xWqhb`roogܓޓbMBig.aɎypamhublicobserv*a͘ʐXCpainshatesult.hatheosngelesankobbersidasrong,orxample,ecause irctionsroducedaroreain(anleasure.heymselvdiIfully,nddtrem=oowhQ(shoPByontrast,charitablestorathroughoutlifaXood_gresneed whichverbalanmodesxsXfnd`-sacrifice.


    E3 tilriCalculusi>ishhilosopJmyenm (1748-1832)@importantevelopof`iQeory. Atickl艑details,`rguꈰitn’t+ensHhavfeelingbQwheJPo0cia`uPquify –assignumaluH+\Җ Yseques F*HrڃYxesj( .uppžV100$uni@Con5׉m,erhapfromn҄8gunPownreceivفusaap :mmوSi8“”ȎJ%FZeb@rsPшt@ژcappa(Y8uA?NoXll'>srrsawښ7Xaccurat1(diff.ƯG{I5+lRizzanЄyYOfnnmill9dolllotteh  ps?oаИӂy9wetwevouom: blockqu(1)ntensity:ow^O7aXOOONDCl//*l 77777>(3)einy7rk??1ﯸ b>(4)em nܐmedi98KsSutOOOOO>(5)ruit_Y0iqwllow>(6)uOϙmixwit( 77777(7)xt7o2peoXxȝ~ͧ|Thu_ge༃o0fpؗI,.77V꺹pparkihouldF̓,ut(m؛veshн2add뷲K=Purdxzd,ua"m؋smanede:1ÅׄgnaaDooanyid8rcoherXini,ZesbYc2rep0teps 1-6ǎˆ pckr[hrupCrx!alyz+ @,npР/T]hиPIBosP3W ¸ beli9phutilitcalcul辸rpysocieb@deHmin`oray!ourailˁgovernofficialcraftegisl!P!yonHG0ayxzhs alЋ8 gu@mІ+uncheT熺HrecixmulmakrdRbashard WWWWVHPRulesi>.wgodfaBafchiqigy,ohntuartill (1806–1873).soungan,#adoptedentham’sisionftilitarianismndalptlyefenditgains@rowinumber)critics.hen(tleldwiser,hough,eeganindqfault0thiseachertews,3(op0oayatnoIp@icular`goodoralxeorist. continu8xembraceLjË iactcameQfamous 19th    E3ӌnsqhՈ؄ne䌉 wtP`oucviduQ.H@t?A»X`Rsforl8mCDdontatio(K/)thrIou1aXLifeulHr0haiIna2s jukeepolrulsiBbeo:k,vY8кsubmYho ;@W0$Tit Wsb.ÊXidҥA:: (1)Ćdž(2)hOKI⡳you eliAssu8ˁdLstlPaskiyߏ뢋amounx/etCrȋLfirsf peo(׆ҁpylژڤ leg9e8")cep rot@wnhipo@Ô(dow.يc3ȶ)0cau1;walkw*wa@ׂӷto 8rackary:h8sFmat,ₗHnolэ!iУB@*P)iЊ@q!elmoOaxcedopt*ddisastsG@.:-basQpep(ȝ0@ש&____?ZAcdo,菐4ׯ,lp`kI80(errorوȀy0Hאcbenefi9|WW oxinhcZfavorpciHoXjInhcPk;rareaσnwpgXؓ@xmqnewQjspecifics8alongexam(,Eh(c `sxȮ bkgqnmx?ӁÆb/ssauweapX?:ans Xutheseasesouldestnhichuleproduceheo(pleasure.norxceptibenituahenworalsonflictndean’tollow.ԃfamousllustrfiscasequiringurderer.uppothatoueeannow(road,pnumpto`d`sticarryaaHcomarournXasks, “Did"jxJsonthgh?”t؉ro҆:guyYpead ifell:truYarexcatAilemma@twe׍pcis:liesX0harmY:sc8d1M@,#holvspecificaxЀPutilitarirHemicourSOOJaain.Ë9ly,Zbɂѓo9aJ-kvoXስ*эǒOn9returodusu '


    E3esromutyorists.i>i>F!:imtnismiremergd`unimpseithso-cadcient*apaci@怨b8|raiP,evoday`mmo,seriychyngp71.Ɔ92renouLJaia8sAfbeyo)ojXrreamof١A,*tarq?cofullyXalyoi!negXhse)TLoshgebankbbyt?stohiӆia,peo@iHYnlcul.any의/BdoubSeelrevulrtow.uB8>chahbmixanr!`ertnaelAwsxp&w0madjmovى,edp2eyrڋͷة|dkFЌakH؋HoHس lo|ai)hogr0up disch㈡qcahPWe볽KceQCOBrcheʢ脨WonHa(l(Äb. “ɐgeneAes,”guicoihens18 embra bu8hXhkptr!ernm . RЉOttemp8sidepcissuXhavlook1,u؆pD\alaXnןͩ('upne8dic"0=mp-Ewël’XmxdopȃAl-ra`Ο oajw)Doub oasp0p>    E3eqsoZm d`_!fl9smporadpSupIidnapoumakejmyl.Ɏң`y0,ncbox,ha gicarSZunasۥhA@    E3e’veeen, k(motiva:dopt9u1ianismsitxeusunreliabȊ)judicial0dPa@8egedgroundrXinnct.t acZihsqu(;napublicserwYcimpartayzeucaru.ist선t,w鈗hopohipoacXplish?arkixrguataC_neᖻevalu alwaysIfmȔ؊JsoWclusBilawed.Hys`8stmaaketraChnprf.Ղ׊thu0(oQgetex`j:selvntu(,ueo(sXtaȚ!ensy2llowid"jufe@OOOOLseudebtw?l`hldifficulchoosanyxlp>Ex5px2chap(m ppealsGdecidHhi؀coffmt!rsphilosopH9dofspȟloyIfavhӈ gHviewBtPesnHCa{,st0c (Y(maj@wap'"broo8Bxham KlY18thiReviewidth="0pt">1.escribelato’sheoryfQormsndowtePe8omoralivism/objecceb`.

3.nway,ccordingButler,gotooimplisticOOOH4.ņYin"ress“weannot`riveu0rom”thhbcontroversy@tweenaseqon7GG@5.`wouldyernst)ׅdo{yaoo؅6Aroȋjviewvirtuervicareoratuincligepngry/x7.Ooemins,[keynY0eɍfale-orienšiiьє߄//+8/*Kantc`gcmpereًwrostealWWWP9WV{銑dutaniPnlpndir@!0BhamZ`anlculusoooiMill08 gnumYvalu#somelpНeacduleՆPsbr>Fornalysisׁ׮!TpdefeTsmpithouJy99piulm񄸀iwhGodGEvol08XbiologIyp()kcgenuinltru+rs8ducgZvlfȲ'$agst۸8pT҂Ї4%wu`orpbdesOHQ$ܕPcussܭpt misuٖc&ǂattackwwwˉ񃓄 oa,ӆAo`mlosrb>REFERENCESNDURTHEREADINGwwwq-36WorksiOrЄAppearancelockquotewwPo, TRepublici (4 cn.CE)`csby.M.A.rubre؀C.1Ree8(IPanapolis:ȏettЃs)ompany, 1992Book 6CzH7Sextusm1Out Pyrrho;c. 200È//-Jnna8hBarp,8.Scep[Cambridge:À]nrsвX4s 1.13-14z3.23xq  HobbThomaHumNatP1650pIncludC$EleZLawYPȇ؂,d.ƞxonni(Lxon:impk&arsh889C9.17Y!Xyχχχχ>B(er,ʟhphFift)SermonH726gtHsR?8oooo83 1cqQcegozil,dwardϕnȏ_rvyOO78G /'''''umDavidk0t0?739-174stȅiUzƹort!py (Ox8dlar,3.x7&Fis/ourob/////>AyAlfrJul)`LanguagTruLogic q(193ww!(Newٲp:ĹcJ5!M?smotivism.Aristotle, Nichomacheanthics (4thn.CE).ecentranslationsyerencerwin (Indianapolis:ackettubhingompany, 2000Book 2iscussesheoctrinefmggggg>Gilligan,arolInifftoice (CambridgMArvardniversityress, 1982ЄPufendorf,amueTDuhM8anditizenc1673///M8aelil`thor:\991Chapt 3-9}utiood,neselfors7777>Kant,mmanGroundworkMetaphysoralsC1785Maryregor777718)wwwwwwt“hTowsnim”鎐i>Lectux75-1794Pe8ea7B ham,ʙmPciplݐLegid^9stednJ.H urns (OxfordHlad 6s 1-4؉litaralculuχgggg">MxHohntuarpUism86dždžludedJ.M.obso8ed.EssayRePASocietycToronto:R6Q hxasru'''''sb,ȃЦhiloso@nvesthted$last (rappehR8 (Lo:ԇhadell4r>(p773Fu(ReadpρΞer(ameWTthhghAgeNewن:cGrawȓhcpwOleJeffreyBarr`V!EApply 4(Belm:adshp?j(oooooPojX,oui:sco)RZW8g#y:xYerKIndpapo:ackettggompan؄RachelpOElemhR,oN SЖdA\ToUBlw("_[NGGcaPn="er">***3*j">CHAPTER 7:OLITICS0P߄߂߂߉AChract>EStPYNatǍwggger’smaWWWWWwrBigotrȂׂ/.B(٧xoʃRevolhondž7ArecGHnC.ТtlibeismJProperoGontar 'GWelf@G'G߁߈.dividuHmuni''lato2Rep'''ׁׅy.dznercꅿwustif5ǂ///ۼHarρσ.HoG="0pt"idth="0pt">Justarheory(pׁׁForeflectionȀ/p1.hatouldocietyeikefhere)noovernments?߂߂">2.osffe,0ber8andpursuit happinessuaranteesPythingoncrete3.s((ednaxtoaywelfa`programs1needy4|iso8import8:ourdividualrom,rrolpcommunit5.hgbprevA`omrmis8aaangero0sY,偰Ʉxductoesn’t2yonelsO 6s"warallyabltAnganizabmsomee:go(“IrimljWRepublicTexas”hose၈ HmpXdsepe(nce.ψmemr ,magcountryȚeophaț --$rruptttsypasp.ow:t?mregulaidid....䉕wKap22chYpdreste.predDecljIheaonXtu)xhɂIPiQish|fenثTodxyremæAdskpp()esU؀St(sjtmusbᣨexpف`n-buildɃparparticipX3pc8rty.">    E3 efX,f,сx iworld,secureǀȆdo]kuchbou=cexistWhwe(āissu`txgh,;hiloso8uɐrisss`validj!aϔyYlimi39au`r1ydiplQpolip8cx30q0ctAMCanada.Ѓny,AraslookȊ:hb)ctl2AHEOCIALONTRACTbaselPnfamilil@uage:w)blockquoττʣ'hcea)t٠c ]4rwh(legpm0Pwi1dvQ...ُ[ isifirlaw9 rb-ervqenjoia|towardmaaadg3jZoуș8bshcC9oradyƍo'%Is@țbetwe'%774QinPalerl"b@csociCoryjautlB0,ahXpividu\8mutgreseyidHt0tYыpeahtQ.ϊ4view,mð4cfwrui(ccorQҤxiZfaiHintsssignedaskeanbolishtndstabanother.Ԁ0e manyersionsfocialontractheory,ubnspiratorllodernnessrityphilosophomasobb((1588-1679).


    E3 EndingStateaNaturebi>XssomagineifrimveimXbe hcreȉgonments.eouldzb8urwn1fi8fooH"ecess`es,0tho protecUlawrˎcpTwohforshkaangero8.irst,’sAscarcehich#compet0on.upposat凨y`XIhedXceasilycquirbyull0sromptree:,lȀ,lronicevs؉Rabunhce2ick.oYintst[@aZ"mi1ʁ3ck getd(icitemjonePspat[otow9i gh,Plo@9I"!y@pdifficuloe heaʈ1f te`,nIyelf[81)ђhsacriЂnZyourI{uX|upaqglpp1sa.fHwgen,ɈwitohaiXtaag1spl9яrwq{ʞ!@n whopurv!qprep :f!bTccor3oT,–huȐÒZRlP!waȄPagll?suciP*IPxٯystiyrnfpuIhuyrљpmou80AmpXvalu0Iadop`dIIn2famapassagdesQgloom rospؗR:_Zblockquxsuќx9la ustJeca fru0uinsequlЂ1ptnavigjyrɁ-jmay2seacbuili“rujKv rel:s퀹JJknowledg(~YPʡrtHHcsocietJ*8w ou`f:vi؃PdЭYQastapoorQrutꁩshh.Lhan, 13].n    E3t’sn to term8fj,utSIrelyno`bidby-.ɂ@uld,example,ˁlivewithouonpruardYdowkill=ak4poHssix.awH1Hobbw(hdeedeep⍖WmPechanism8eeyereat0aovern+onwa Pano9o`tchiolatorPpupemmeantabl؄لabodȋ1stropolxJweBu0ritXonalizk.gaiaselfpoIXPhesitatoPi{mo@uWfuaCfulotӊi(:sacrificІugh,worHi(8JnsُЈ2l0n)s(stuckbrut0hudyPn1HWWWW7RHowdohnewȉB8ǀȀbe?argu„mustaabsolHithoro[{effeclyHnyAcedaknhP"invi,ih*urmi u00un؞OyG7@ifrom1p,0vi` hai'pYnejHed|w,cluȅ)AmeriRoccurraジurf$br>PrierDxmma.د In@ewenormou8mpA /HohHhadaȭKh`yp o`urpCAb`inuhtettta(PdefeRrivlciAsHapГic\QpAhgbwfaQmi(c#lef*irwnvH9laun"wp)ll.aybJszhumkʂÌAcomb-izۂ @wfoIXengagnf Do@ant1uaszl`darkAlaimu,bsequqA??Haer,lpXIooremp`oXanvbm£oئвǞreɛ ]philosopIfel g;lco`cWnJiTc3nulyabou'drԊ׊todayȅ Bway1tigReJbOhroaпasccЂo`mru藒@yucop(rkniЫRy.up)PI◐achp"namJocatI@iٍI sy(deɣ bitӦh!rslam-dunksWQ@neehaȑbqu8zXPnax 8in@mj`o8pplypsychologrsoff learɠhphIhoȝ(irsAXdؑ؟":)blockquoIf9doXnwibaa 1at[сN 0/)fDžDžDžDžDžDžŃԢ!doDŽׇDžDžte>Ifeitherfsonfesses,heneXllachet 2earentence.(pggcCllyestutualrrangemouldoroendeoeepurouthlosed jupservHwoRs.nPtunateinvigat haslacPxparoomȀшcan’tiscussoptions.ɀmow@nderinghatiso`doisgc+_othHonywn a(eciddeYme,egardl8h0respAs@`persiotiv8ylftet,ɀis{whiHguI񊊍ig 10p_   €E2ȇ8doesЅapplysoci(tracory?uppyou2IsturndifrqanglR|ˈrmuPasis(x.himqalkbnsplittb0Ir kJ5(inspind+I&tranysay.oHGGEuIXq;or9ec`"򧫖gy+(ttacktakSbe Km`famimemb89mayeryXaИ0k0n tow`sJg)r_( 芐roughXbeP ofHpalwayosdH,˪XHob` iabHcJgohnY,iflik“nastxbrutish2shH,”G)i?GGGFSC8BigotryЂi>hc1linjcriticismgpyZnxclus@bHqDhip1notssar1ope9ondepi)qty`Y2;genhXyPuĴWwitpob Pf,Igur o itya8roupch#crafÊXBؐ(dvagMen,jexam*CneiŽ"beha`ppmve8IdeǤop.ϑ0=AshoCa`0nimˆdvoc8sdiЅvhumbfidisregՅWɞTДdX҇ aŠassign selPzrفmrPrs;ah(I0sh@coytټmnoȴ(epbpn0lne(droy 4Non)iblemw҅פu0#ޗôhcZ=a)ciȁs3madig tist@.ǁWunpcredawAk9c#freecolontimhEuqP`߂ȳ(" nhl)thsubjvrulL񔹃iGDmitYz rkahЫX$܁blabono0shAsɈzثorldWWZhbergzիbys.____?Zkpphiloso8quy5whe1sH؉b9Bigwhllo'kzx|׮;rontractualituationnhichenndoQofllaces –spokespeopleorigherimalDhadquXvoice9determiningheawsAcnd.utrchaotictmospeEstatjnatuitselfreventssromnowAwhofirstegatorsiHbe.oantroupsayeryeYjack2prosleaveakh
B.IGHTSbЁPerhatundatthou`dpX*I0ꓐertouPaborythxam,rnfamoau in,˖imbitniqȃƒusciؕl(oYdherK`suȗiveЎycopyipach.͊9typq)` /pc echreligЊ>ҋ$violp0h!0gohnsrsbstrucЂ)freedoms. H”K(tp4agћ@zQߍ۝Ёρˊ3ctict0yGbe harmrlipmsuPberɥbqnpJmureOggggq Jhowsk`8ȃp`velIsI camAkQaerx,Bp+aloneIWWW">    E33xLear1r!yts:y1Xd9bP霈qalX@eRJt.Ԁdage 16)ap:i ɂ7setrireanȨӭ`HjneyarImoruiّ.eca@depeȉlegis0 emmonX؁إ#ᖽ=C(iȃ󮊉_Th`ع Q>љkPf0u iכ XenP@bornthmpe Oi>ɂ\si)uma`worlxI`8r_ZҚi>@Jrrdlaqrr܋degh.;_^?WRi NRT RevoluA::spȔ4C2iron`cep}Xiʠ*300goТmonewEsubje(1HgB hilosopJohnocke (16321704).amiliar3H!sobp;( wi`oducoo3askwou`thsp li8aь?ׁiخjchao8sd(t ed?o,nswh.Ō8 1peo``fundxGod-gВ[ifXht8libertȁp TyiIamo*kibHphys"a !8!IstH! lawnmo.ccordoYqefemPw@tɂhuأqi0PfQxoimpri)@bhy;(grow􋨍ȀPnille. Theoints,venithinstatefature0a moralonstrasnurehaviorhichbdeterminedy*zrights.

    E3hilOLmayotpsuthlessaHobbestended,illhtiallyarringnvironminceopwouldprenaoQspeccifIy(ou(kcgetwфx.o,ockaguetomprov0safeteregrsosor ibili@H8tectWWoXcisely,ngree2RɃ:agirulerhw0andor! exchange摎<ЅGFSupp0ȊAaailkeepsar0Z;oli@cyexam ,gepqtaskIdealoniz@crim؂8/`elfsorrupXroutX0lȈAunjust@XfiscagbperY1ecg.ד@1tl`revol(sⅧt?i’seen(e ne3Ȓ8bud comig/-!ord`adequd*irobn0s:pn`ified.disz!AusXA%mg;H@Ձeny̓9ob,ut,hSH??YIɘqIXremv߫߫߫߫I 180c(urhґeor srmousxpopulamopBishYoffXXrfqA0lҏ朹1688deI8k@. becamposo8c1nspirnmoab`Amern776    E3enm0commez@abAidea/.pt!lcnoxpPsHDe HuҋBÄkhsxdozȎry!PldɛRȃto.choLock*( YӃE-hawpsecuxfsonIt@Pon0cplr`rbitrarrrPcknowg $m iagrHl,peec assembleoyyheis2foodȇ`healcبy@picuHhmisNwr,ѝsXslamhJRa(m"&God-+gr̃hOmPstmc0tridJUaPmmxnda8achiR:lXeo0sVhobeʂKge)苛(=avoidhckssuwheOl/ς)mt DuequP–as`3'$>NirXyʍѺtssario.dbr>DoANeا?i> AA9oroblemjeo=c*P\nicep򎰂2t.etPxm48h𙩳)3refrp{Hb1murderq낿alsohowak+Re(TdoIgibdъh2PqHll?мpgnizئPnȃ!rel3betwePMHk:YõIail32aH.Ǝ,fɆ{a    E3ԃs,hough,nmportantsychologicaistinc`twyandaichpxplaihyelaceouemphasipnutoday.pecifly,t’!rderhengembout&h!tggdÃPupposetouakeptIt, “Yviolat ourQyIobe!”oun iH8put*󊨄atmecPzthesdXd.1Targu?absolvHfromwcauchilx0rvingJynefBhem.vhif󃹆Zfl buh8everlesRm0oɌiweakn.ϊo(rxndf҂bebedI0x@fasЌ>mewπI It풐яffxg:aȂIaDa;I.Ƀٝ{Tm(xss8rhetor£XnsofasWy=seem`(gcx5BXwefAyraЃgon ,Xyittlcounبqbu`Am뇱gˆqattracȆQsympazerpaldn`urpri8u en1SR3y ɠinroPdurrevol؄Qiin@groupsxpȕsoci0r(.ׁ;4con0seerha+x[ysX?P ȄAR1wordKʍsu pXs.Jbr>C.OLITICALIBERALISMNDROPERTYbhggLociuyong-Ceoknow`s1po8 libepismɸ vi Gs0`piў`teixvidus.Ɣ8mopamjUacc؅oC롃iv0AHthhelfȢ)9BropЃ cle80howʁfuacquiH׻goat woodnobodwncreqxSn*boI Isoobj񂢆hdcom`,xY8lrieby9,wOIÄ,keep,i+awaXls`fib܆xonlseԃsa1OAē+AHeyɥ`mad2buy2؃Allowormula`u`IJ92IgB}shiPfundaaVar*yoask_ cdhnirywh(rZtcQWeگO/三eaabenkra@":quesY:J/)xe0ntpa(ށI`Ppop藈nceed?ԃ ϷcHm7@@ZʭՍicrcɆJc۩ɐi aȘHث*ea$variouBgfЅwxagra(P,usfinana`0꼠nemployՎȾvTHcepB(d rib8jpв):wP:ȏ0@ety?Еhosop s`dĶWVvast0dianswY%__">    E3aNozickLYia`Ⱦ)i>2spuUplOlM0po 8be@fxbas B1`c)Onhisiew,t’sotartfheovernmenjobescriptionopyorelfarerograms.odhampylibertarianismsmericanhilosophero9ozick (1938-2002)nd,0keanyans,esxsposiJwithifeworkysocialontract ory.ɁcstateAnature,argueIminlyntitleddefendysgstttacksyrs;Haask,XoughpsXormoustimesuming,fɃvoall!mfXewibehtpp0unitۂouchQȉyglse.us(Iaalesphachessay“Goodftoon,irpumpriv tec2agencyneighborhhqaXfee `as eespXibip(fLyyouOJ.e3o9ripy,ut8cykwppshiolatoouldinpsub9brservice?”Ԁ9x!kiPrrangenealizȘf dXi0signpfȑ ل7cXobuጏǍi8wpop(yw .o`reamlinBirivenessSrwartwee[&hmvX2btoge,ダtlxreghp]zؚolidz,pe aMH,hi(ea؜8bxst.

    E3owrxhp1beyoioWWT?t.Ϙa ijustifie moФinfrpXricu8X@HnȊЋL)ccumS invotwoe9i@ppcsRۇ.irsmг0Hcqui3[@s)amixala:hcommJheobjhsoggHSeȋ؄Munq(sfY PaH)sXthrgif~.;0Xn hipYavai8qutsidwx 0raud`ktiI3//( )Ȅypaexeт@pmϿxS@c+coPfrssooPi0m`cˎ8ȀXworoadv🐃yopŒchobfmyhiyXsympa`underс8gjpg2-XdQӂaroreMOJcoew0gram0or񅡊PsidefenslibȘ,htypiigZW؆unҏ abeysp58cauihtempreceȏ`Pg-r.̆adҡXee-P@tegdeal)Zp9tynς*ws,stoplacYtrib(ّ om]flisؚΕ@nqfobsO똜Iqdoo@unloyI2ߑX Unsut;;ruraon`g蘵0!ir1表XEencyZiesRdrv lazQrǜǜǜǜAX8dom-loiciy-midJifacpstac.Ϟp`AuxX:Qn󉈁Bctuy?ven_XPlwayI`X.Ĩ*popula*exsy,atlis,oreignompetitionndvenadusinessecissoutlyhrowconomiesntouin.heroblema`0meoreat؀(unemploymentsurance privatehar0’tAcloseoixingx0s.i weookt@govern*fortec[gaqis,urderers*invaxitak0senȂ9ׂ҃`alsromcisaster,sphalwh@isourault.

    E3d mor` caluesbibertanismqrxoPpzofphywnhipfair.saHȆaapfrigincquiry~accordcncheme?ilhzolal xled welfatendy苷,iȑturnYnexbr>.慧view,*ddrun2tribin(althXmptax(helpneedyknowgws‚IuHhtanclu>;ow@ddьsqu"impo\uHsQpeopleo hav adv`ageهra9ccumul@maPangel8ipfhumyou@"Qbodpnewbobab쁘dax,0ndomxpick脀,:(ey腡.φɊPIwhfamisvxeeBombIndiarnskimorcǃillnjW)+aplXd88almo8vitabdeXmynat plifeThn@г r(0G-dlтX!p@.gsyrreceiжeduca,Pb(@rsҊK͓idHkjaeryucr`(ceY׈fʃprbesepzbasHy܎،ȂsPmath1iamQli уO/oodxphappen slimcaclaintitl˚ZXyv.mernosopJohnl(1921-2002) arbiȌparg  0oy$rg0jueix2@m@erpetu9i]WLNoz,ussoo%ic8.ichroup*ahys-(st|ogeLrbul ahfetI8o8oonsi1ib(#diffhsy0mSupxtI๘me)NP4jbؾe8amoyonu{$5,000yeaals`0mych"Iough,ooqesYr ПjOacUIfy9WQrewh0PmVqxl`ics:eepЊэlڃ`reg"̀HPgh`lfJrograihlfav0XEtia w\dsensHؚhmԤA4IbenefQh؄ؤ#;!cw ඐmpasnbneg@"ǥǥǥǥžʕ׿aHlu:et:phi ayvei*igno00–et`mnesi!@`ȥ臘 stoesknow$Eۋi?HρϗغЂire.ehenotenceorQurariouschemes.houldeividePalthquallyt $5,000erson?hieemsikebadiskorei,pmnesiillrsff,oddsslimmnnncowrЄb(low.’antQopportunityoa moneyfan,dhapsvbeZricheyowedjusteepxaccumulateDalsooosk;hil /.܄hles,eaPfinancisafenetcatch҃ppoverty.(`abȃ|greo;ompromise:@Ɋ:OlexibilYɋ,ampP(tectipoor.

    E3rprecȆ74cceptccordingRawls,involvHwriɐice:br>
@ٞBסЅP.*br>DHNDIVIDUALNDOMMUNITY@b yanimdlmAntz,`"yw0namZ:nsPab1aےDbcolonH(pexX%Aap:ˈblqu׆׆Z:yPjnɸpixmehyoumidd0cdami`5𪀷ont篙npon...@wu0ho,orgsmI؂. :xm8hdo3forheolony,ndhatboutyeeds?׀me?ɀ0an,’veotoeliextitheresomelaceʁ"bettern(is,wisellusturlpnarvalositioeep.heoleystemakesxeelsignificant.rapist:xcellent!ouKmadereb0kthroughWWWWW>Z:0have?7eZ. areGGamr>(pׁׁReturningobȌllowPricheZ: “Inp[you,逳upeam!”ntremarkablypmmunity-oPnted;eir{"hey*plexivissf8bor pwhichocunaiSp .ϗIimal‘Y,ikurtllitpPcistruce;(ptrieferiodmat舂ownrommbirthntileath.umbeH;paradoxlPZb8̝AouYdbon:awц`,typdJaosenindua y.KsPldairst4? Repub`i>.maginbewHhJa(t et.ԧѧinBxrece逩` germhsleepbar ks.̈́WPs!ehw+duriwy-yeRKNQpred.tgpcou ir:offsXPxIait`,carndr)˓PJ8ؙkdm.Âged(d H(p`heltdegenmus@!Zh1squabbъAvpossrhmi1oyalpytgado8sa`larg_DРos<ɔ{sIfȇQiitmZ̳erf a`escrd9b`/ "mx!Pespeciunus mem`gHogniz9!tte(XPw Ȕ؅cћwe(`ower.O'''"lХ;@GBpH?ȗaip{҈ا m K(PxangneeȂZIᩐffzmdeviceغIdga*,foo逕clYbu8s 5untxkXgo񉸷tasypsiXanX ǀ蟪oytasJdouX1:,exa`(yougrowopurndu typhXelopebЍHsLuxHes.hIsop`Aaitinvariybeqjۦ8؍outs!opetitionoraturalesources.here’snlyouchater,and,ndumberoorouwikecs)theseGusts@ivalsould.ƅsociety)workffectivesu(ednrotngselvPfromevitableompe$attack;7`llartfohmztoge8rerarmony.natense,hinkmuniian0umanexhophysicmentXfe)HDŽćletgree.fy,YnȆifmi@0xs st@ght “Ixdȓ”ii bodyrabbxa0ndfulidirjY.

    E3ccordpPlato,ArЀ thouppeo 9iconsuh2a=gdXir؃Otrades-Pȁ,arp8cloZcHqviderkba@sKeoweZ`9aerviуahup.e@Y>guaans ֚DtsؘZfactlif0ypcribo(specifXB5hLntlx@itrguntrieɆn|befocmakRhembsoldaossiircugooentiP~^lm.יYclass` certGZa larg؃dar9Á@infusrWdevoirؑ?aXrul@Fd`NԓlXh*a oQt^[Karlarx CsmȁQb>W–Ǝyide؍.rem]GerposopY7eioqrld.eubbedisheory “communism”ndevot8muchfzlifeopreadingtsessage.nitezoweweopledopqtQime,eplglobalcceptancasnevitablTher foureygredienMarx’.irswcalls 8toriaterial.jpguxz1worldY8pos؃irely%tuff,ithAirituȁn,„hv"mechanunfohor*rigidaws.umanQYarticularmergese؎0dic1yroughconomic`rcepe0,opert 8sionshmrythSaocietyinfrastructu#1ndatxiAoalbuilt.ӂd,ǎPclassruggleTcou3,|ihav9olv fl`etweeH9Foxamh,sa)AmerhslTsymcollapbi8Iwaonhtenymiddᐉl-ownno,erfAodchoiȃYkdresc ZhaeprivsK~@saw@towXSLJcaq0yindu(k!1eirb8m)ׇouQlsoy`–mAgettzf8k.

    E3مrxۃѩwKKen1borSW)sk¦0b`h(h6pvi jobsacoȜBPy?tpemqkXasonYȊJshipansPsJbegieidr ,Ʌن@4҂jЧ@Ay`we#an8exa`receiP(payche؉notwe8`erpay,h"iou)ot u؆@ms(ѫXfZ#dЀPZzs9lsuP -b(pixaɎw9b,hurvmuГ"ros@udoђguiofsellIf܃ i0m鶙򎿎sofin1ecur𛊌!ofromz〰`ЅPE֤!wsupp8̥9alawyniP8 clearig!٢lta4GodquiffЄҞ1miPbS%w B2lifGGGG'FfpYH__]ݎvoluXlhe𩝐fupƦopps dp2hilaun0{aiPf|ohvI8*counʞ,hcat2bloodX ҂ron ‡[ps "ao9garownumb4Ytu ta8Xߟɯ u0CnManstoI (1748) explaYohm@OstZؘbehal 9xlێ y2espcduPhѡ x~freKclH%ʁapp;t@hichaXex˘ noȬeewwwwGtmrem`a 19<`>ththres-be
Urefl3HZevolvЂnarompP@vQPȉl{.ԐX,+rhwXiЊfussuetweb)znܠsomHYlikX?8i> YxpeddnJnopHt(E.OVERNMENTALOERCION.HG_difficulask ddkha!s l1eg@苘Y.awmakVirgininspr0sS$50inn5row`*pexirrjۚZdea񰑔яitewubl``Afh΁Yiiarpellawy8jok( urIsXFPydعnntdevPspushRHrEacXjIysituccusbca`durc@ʭge!dropplaccωMexico2si(aributsexlmqɇmisЅQ;(oumȧcIaؐdepicyb-b evilvoc#ˆsaid “ mHfeyursayIP{иSaysopu1Q 8* ,IgPXJm ck.”Ȅo1،himCm0zealX2ghgtgogihɀev(1ڢ;idn'r1th Qme2">    E3iBSexamrtlluxg0ncJrf8d@(n(!efe ׃눫@ycoerc@ef oeeppeaceyp0osrdubȣXjwhroh0eWeЁwhyhibxfmurx#ouifBermitYsx ;sG;satXHτʈٞEчxdisf(–uH"HxǯǯO818philosopH+grgu`ꍪI0n87sHytȘbr)GGGGFP8cih.b>Ezonhifi႘t fi oHimp 2m|Q9i"0ܿՂyxȭ.̔againissaul@clءJi0B|no0)attfuzzyHݡ@qup:js?םĄa,8ysatt)immediXcdPxIȆythough,shattsnnvasionf{terest,hdvoidinghysicaljuryjustnethese.lsoaveg0inyropertyہ@I’mprmedhenmestePromMojersonreputatmeans߂߂lǂprivacyOOOyoupasstyrekroughwindow.eÇmans,piAw)counts “”㊘quicklyeu fndًemoщ8happinesxsldreeaws0eventzeopletellmen9yewAuchqbya(rreckownoad?€keyonʆrmnvolve serious?Lxreaivif.earbaHipparlifefmaksxhaccid`still2thiveXcommonplac؂؃@w2Ꮚiaْ/..o,Xi(ourD8ncepvaguhhelp0ink!$st.

    E3ep0eQoffense)nci*8gonm،ayepTzo0Virginia rf(examHttempt8hiblow-raY1gnd\publicis fsX(w؆i.laurnh,ornograxIulnguagєXyero"YricQoj.ike|,quai c-esatSuppoਟ1a1knIyinex@(HpmXsorriblst0`xa؅s8ang*Who̧DoOutLtoplutcignohim@t"tKcwalkwaAs+Iw:cainxrntp legBXonhoexitmlYauisarayfuhb@!OKspeaمP񄙜ireacUrPy؉ZujavoiiijHonȇreĄ%easpn@r`myself,. ThirFcpr`ism+x@m(p.׮rѭ,ivhfocu(5b\ca2oktш82suchߖT!choicʪHgood.ep –0f-@aQ0tji۞H#xIc`B|0deңؔؔsum҂hwehareXrnesvurS(tiQ1Ahi@ccu(pripriorXጸbahknu)xɀH@ȌbsӇ footbhe8hreguѩPimiz@iXٴaw񨉊lthmotychel docsuurchadru8Ү؂LR c9n uptatadeЅisk0saoPh/1oض {ccorʉUsocietpك*ifAڰy.Fht|m&Hdu@2peciҚHxQimeѴste<ܘ̅Ϩ9donesӃC2su2aigi9well-be8a}Wstop%AiHFexam(erv@Saudirabia,(lebПVal2e(bann:QloXQZsalefedlowers.heroupesponsibleorn0cinghisndimilarorally-basedawss “qCommitte3tPromotionfirtuezPrevence.”ŀnmuchyeibeountryGreatritain,irsprohibitublish1religiouslylasphempaterial.egismjustificaJbehdnyexz,9aoseh؁@uty,Iwh(@act@`don1iv؅qetwe0cadultxal`AiehavXhǁHde#*czensh.͉imkeaudirabia,piQ governbyslamici,odxample0BuJBplujt_enitSt0ifHoAa setuhu@Tryqagreqsond8l/(wsagxWP,xtlookC)Kgang!X@anor.


    E3 Mill’sinciLHarm @b>cpoiȁdisputurrcbur)3nvolvHdeminy3`mڌ idaspSmeon.nerhapfacuss̤subject,zhiloso0rohnuart͉ (1806-1873)gonxqfir:%–˜Pmed.ȅPakSe:)blockquo??:[T]so8eQskpwarranx@vid hcollivf`ithЊ@鍣num(elf-t!T9purp_p1aIfuex1Ⴢme9vild(mmuFHw(@aQڀzHownb`physXʞ2suia.ۚOn,ÔP 1]hN环sҐ“ߌshoulesHcፃ@ɇ,XyPi0y4ur (uxreɛ+׌@pn.lseЅQork1ccsseekUQavi@krcauXoffl0icwn%.ƃ(i,;meaPJImpqmyɊm:zo sH@`ܗ(!e ൷a↰pbXP`XȌ8hpeoူnkhgj0tto@aǕdzgWhyDon(tremiew?ЫHroaroubwexЅЂopen-мAarad19th    E3ԈideaIaaxim(cietyIceripy;H@likypporttastccasodd-b`sb_Zclampdowu“hXy-”ycrguQsKem(exhintuiairway.ompe3aswar!ghHil*2ileow8TaL>1exlAss8͝qorre衲7 enqLexpl)possibileSt@QslQhҎ7sטPcblock)ramoHstup(Qful`ّʩparpular peowhoinmbadhoicЁamvx8gamb3 neɒڂrunk(opea ro noHdumpsfshack*@Y llapsSuxX"vorNڳI;qٗhalonWeremembe82sIgn'$ogmyfax;HobbeszwordI нZ-apitarponruth.IGGimx8t)yqssshиkeeҗ؏xÏo邪Q8@(Qg H'HgD. br>FARXbxwwWhi0InximǰRepucTssotetrwaUSt;y0cl1o hsyeaHbId"p4aure ahi8OJm,d,Q*JmYAm hВI(ludI)QaIcouHWٟtal†!hHpw hhmmq8few7ul8ڈy:aIma e08aWSw@c(!unfoldlii:,hsymhizQ jupedic.ararcurviv稀pIWohup,pickiruckweapbeecrestppȍ0 ,+wojuX oryhichaint sa*sometimesSly(ifiaBSecondpacsmhфqviewׂn.


    E3 >JWTȅ.n׋ernivilizai,Z7yaseenominanthiloso8c選sincejRomanmpiw8threnedyariinvaders.ׂearlihriaweHlarge|ts,Ӎug1negu ouldthlnscie҅’蒑mtahdutyollowingzd,߆1urvvelop0speIcrixiaor``)ꒀ0noted.ʍ䇹nguishtw(x:,3requmHs"ȔwagI",`0sڂ uc)oQitbstWWT߀W8{wtFdesign(Lnrase4ellug`esmey“laoQ.”foffdȀJp,uroئ}mportJxmb}HauseaWTY9rucqɁsr`ggsPΐPtoxureuPXphysoloug`ombcampa`YQբhntApopulZ:rʁ0JapH 8PȤ(o@ irWnenҏPU.S.dec.of9TexFreeI01abW?tyewPؑmǢnAepubl`ђgmXmplagbgulimilrtYczeP(`ax!rgu wnhip.̂J"$yiyp8N l0,vpiٕ πhcanaccdnyPlikV]"A!ouہ;OOOLw8/.0WW hrmotiprh@w"o؉oj80xpeapPϝro^]Q9hac촲plundpPcSaHupyjtaP0gc`ctabP.n73ߍߍߊaEsf valseemtHowa,w l)qgooH0day5P9pe(I1itya`nxalgiaI!,qШYb.normpeop؊:someellohd(bda"Z2exdealismgPQY(alssuحmY`wi(ڀqnȟ{ducX0b WorWXIImpthmserosurndb=eminNjŠnvol hȁYdid<mmlurknhnobon?ty.rui:µPu`<ȷ&adenɤxmawTdecl0АafHbombPHlar,Bitid*H$ڨx٣,r0pyHshwoɑrim/"Rehoyyk?Ɂy:"uppormjnXrhapsheyouldeegitimate.nhe(rand,firupportamerincipallyrom$ownembersndympaticil@aroups,ry\notvopauthority.

    E3ԆXfourthHerions reasonableccess:wahhn’t!pointl0,etIwrongoafihumanivequ8xeconom@resutcounlikelDemini )ddsfictoryioftdifultinvol plexlatbeaponryĎ:ieduntriefuel"ȀxunpredHfasAhser.tas0ugh HyInorWpII,ralizthateclaXgagain`Naziljan futileoreluyptccuȉ(effqh“TexFreedom”sixar؃doo`ilure2Kthusaspect/-pllA WWTdofulfiy`aPywagau`לLeturnHwissu`fF,HYmoraluYК8d8;`؀design`L8nɃ8bello,xlawp.⟲bneisidhflHnsئsitechniquachievit@a,gardقh(zr twoǀ.irdisꦣbmantifyW8argetЛkiوeoȦY(c yinnocmeasoldiIBivP90ghborhoodSmȣin0㎋,⧐\mQ@Qvp((lRipe(i?;,AHectbl9b ih@betweba9@2خkmayuickesx"sgecWks Oi؉`7zaPonam re0{iroalK9zoFӣp@trW:zma nypiXgoy*as ٲfun1GDҟnappPiau|!賉rwhi*wlaunȥ*.ǯǯǯǯ©▨ci(@؏abo –visphilosopxs8}aba`P(mҔ)addٗڔkuxoughB(b(toragmPsrk1grnӖҐish<Pacifism0Pi>iiFys ٷmDŽёxayJAug@8HZp+t筐pppoJQertair gni{ngag`؃: ,kGermኑJapWor`IIZlso'maak)agorgh@n-violaHricoycotshunn(lmunܻJca8igfilisZ񎨐0olu8*feep8witxcepӣYwr.ϏP/-objep ⟰/s9ipiсex؀ rcYٍqo;2)ng w`pl1wight="0pt"idthc>    E3onsideringowrucialomearsaveeenntoppaaggression,uchsorldarI,hyouaonehtobsoluteacifism?heostommonustcats religious:1contrary_teachs.̓scriptu0romrounPwJaYgenerdemnofill/“Thouhaltot”3T`C@andmentSologianinterpretesjuncsiallyщPanyق nqȅNev\elf-defenonimp.urr,킀AersBuddhaJesuЄucirhvnon-violly,bhfeelatsxdiweladopt.ґgt,ough,alargeыcque qPubtltBaaithradi.tthbepeڂXfXwhxXspeYP8ticrtp*f.

    E3hhgh3ishapte;runn$ёsenn:`!ppcip ca҂pavernment’sxencaItemaiitȌaa`tasWepO@\`g triminals,so0`eHomic:lo8,؃ty,fAHuwoЏupidi)ignvas .Ss0B,x,ؚ̂(roputo0dndividX⃦freedomhichthtf'#.ɍb*pyddgJ?nm9uniqu8ea(2;8hdoesnHearp9absolutru`hmu؀@oranch do逧religexampl8waknow(wheGPJ[realmc͉(g(tpturegؙ_humZqblish.؜ngȑ PgPb0mAɃsym1supX) ffa8Qu8mpto Tal`two祑ahe-size-fh-ʁYicY@doArئparuitorhSuldneXeXg<{2yriaisskHXe.ӑ/ɟ0shpchhllegdud"hordZhYus𲨟enorзتIuwnhip?@܏aϨxЈ[!obweНaXOÀvjylpximpXrole.br>FRewǁ>1.es80Hobеnnbҕٝw#2.wBHeXerRdilemma?OOO">3gock!cЊU\hИxaSyv߃4.ź`“hamism h;awwwp5質sozickj:inim𪫩ʋtaxchelpnyoooh6oRawlgIveiljgno7\Hlass;P0o2@fԄ8mxeepoQtihssHw8 yfkeypMarx׈79CO9oerc7$0gM)lrjarux “py”gu9eXwagapپwo?п"g߃7religseӆ}sZpacif??Analysisׁ׈On=PrXzxHo irobili@a@)pubjugЉȷt(mɁ(@espA]Wogu"n theubjectfaturalights.

3.riteialogueetweenozickndawlsnwqwelfareaxation4.Ãicizearx’siewycommunismromocke perspive//>5.efe@principlRleg@paternalagainstill“happyociety”rgument߃߃߃6auHwarorihiacifyymo鈠missibilityrarbr>REFERENCESNDURTHEREADING0wwvWorksÇdnrderAppearancelquo؂ggbDoc2ЇIn@imovـRepublicTexas჊isPbs: ttp://www.r-of-t.net/___]Hobbes,homa@Leviathan (1651).eced8bydwpCurly (In`napo:a0ttЅQshingompany, 1994)>,ohnbTwore ser89-1690TtPard>BAPepasl(Cambridge:À]nrЁxres1967">B`hameremAnarchicpFalles,nclus(ȁ`ʀed.owhg,ol. 2,. 522f.)ZPannomragz 33217.pthsitl``hunZsh`du‡2life. +,oberthSt,JUtopiai>(Oxford:Škl7G”G>AorrJicervёߑ777777PlatoC_c4cnCEtXsG.M.A.rubrsPC.e2">يuaOni)y1859ww(lud3Jso8EssayhnşcReligSs3Toronto:6Marx,ar, munMans048IPortableJrxcEugenka(New٧Y:8ngu8Book*83//////,EcocbPhilosop[uscripȆTtMulaProgŌ,oscow19ydždždždžAugInGo413-42J.ϧPM((0mondsth."OCr>(pGGCFuHxRead0PpϳΩpalowPmmXB쀠qual;R!" (Belt:a

***3*CHAPTER 8:OGIC80lockquoteǂǀb>1.hatsnrgum?OOOM2.nformalallacies?????3.roposition`logicGGGGG4G@O>5.omplexOH0d̄ConnectivW">6.estes.7.֑0d,pςOOOO>8.oundnes>9Alassxercis????0.akeomeOOJςOOJP!HATSNRGUMENT!???">anGreece,roupfravelingeachers Sophistsadheeputaabeableoe`yoint,oatowXsurd.ne@fer`follow<: /ww(1)idomyog///>(2/aor?????>(3)ԁeGOwAsizarresisteasparpieemel,peciflyirtwo@es`s8ngHou8߃ڏ"1rdppea0rom3goXhʂctructoQxrecognizeheneoseoXxrly,v0׏\,v thoughe1@tetidifyxact茘pro(m0.Ȁ,yI(sȭ!x痸WIfLjhiaadnouldhhu8SoooIʈɇcaxtiǙĕggwwooo>WheasxЊ!ews ngɜIHR ame8BsۑPemٖZclusQ. 3which@scon;8xjĂA0^ 1J2JSsupport~; 3y0n9)󚛃WVcanipwi0߂O///Y2.NFORMALALLACIESJibHhggg OOLTolppoeө(trick0ٽ},r@otwrAookidFHac力Scataxszen+pronin(m0fE0nmllčmonЂGh(chYincquaintar"t ffecti`waydetngb%atBSadmmawٱs؅.ƈea +Qexcepقʶy15,validQu/sp0psexrgulip˫qabsoluruؕ    E3AagPeri>(umቸomHm):tackYap’rqeۻ!A]3, “HeggpSpolosKmembNaziPrty.”Bobalcoholic0o@Qakpinvestdvi tooriouslOurJؐsgunrolfx,t2democrat.”

    E3 Argumentromgnorance (aumdtiam):oncludinghatomethyisrueiHouan’trovetfalse.orxample, “Godustist,,noneAemonstrateheoes mousfxlacySenat(JosephcCarthyhoccusedertainersonicommunxQnectith@eollowy-:I`RhaPmuchnforma(+exceptJgeneraltRReІ@"rȈ*#I0iltoisC߅߉GGGG'Fppe0XPitymisericord aPԑ8stuircum9asHwaygett)cps nepassȋcours8Ihllycholarshipfdi8oPfindrs.obbguiltmutilȆ0usbandifesXauacPleaThrem(I#idjsuppYesqmurd0HyrbuakeHwЕrphanGǒMȕȒ972populugolo0crowPn%9Geom,PuysolrryDdb r(sh,lizab hsuP r(rm햰8sleepoundϊAuthor7vcp''arg1a{(aEie believ`oABәlikButterg8dy*0y3goo߉߉߉߉WIlevبؑUnsequiturdran8i8&Ӳ뒁evidPgVMne0wьplayear,hQBus8b8shotrbroke;guɍRmeaitti(buynew!׊i>Fiappo hocrg!ocp(erZ8GRxnumbЛi@mhos؉ditlroт7tbubbreoad;PupySu(ssfuloP3expensiPcl;becaRl/-ύC韉R(oniciqgKHǪ/(|ABiaI"е 'ruы3Qwrotлt9`ossialkroȅword2j򓀊aඁ'WEHvoczSDtwoe(if+ ak r)񊐨ҍ@auldHXdJ`Ƀhman;0lowelp`riЂ73ѢrYb8dQsZp#le0•y=sOOOOoDssumBA蒘:eؠfP.ay2hml74A`mg蒀gX`Qbhd0%׊i>Divi=ʈYaWWW"vTQ0rtx eᙰNtu)sudyathEnglish91AߊGRH$nducBAevecondary subjectndherebyivertingttentionrom ain.orxample, “sidempairagsnarsooteallycPseafety,,es,ostwithςareapane8orts.”QWomeHhouldavefreedQohooPanbh;stric"thisƀXjuaHp(stancefl@ppsw)

    E3 Strawan:st9 pposaviewopatsasyrefutegevotggu(ontrol,hldvocateslierHnon3ow nypfiarmTpro-lifHҀͅwroxhh(awLJbr!Xustermv wh(ƒdangerɌbr>3.ROPOSITIONALOGIC.b OOOKLearn˅pnfor晠acimaylpouetspecificslogicerrorxbutSwill:guarante\qcȏu-ю(guPtځPra.pfoach}a,lledań"i>(als)ؚsQwhifvalids.Árcollow9:3nblockqu9wwr(1)IfQǦ hiaa,x@ׂurteo.~߃߃߃2۟jciGGGGGGA3)԰يXЃtoY{u`"`ύφifІnх߁߁߁߁ߊj1P7''77Tondv8u@)98vxHeg"elery1cepbuiupXsXSimilarB*geto񰰛sbashX:poi2lis!С_])a!@7߉߬ob>4g`S!߁'OOOIimp AI`uishtwethreld:?oUta1:oen@verbxpreՁݫ clude@nXGaobaKa,)we@tzs (s0nextxfinb)7771S3An0vey8ea1`OquB(Xwhm?`commhge!un mypce!{feegche @glory엩_______YPljne8 r8lV orld,BPbinyrattlesnake8PastJack"nXil򀸁AuPEdrecrfromH8r.Xo›l psXXywaemupbp@(i.@ߊ߂oߊ).Ɓ0exam0aHw؅Ϻsoo0`oهthoughAx؃ndoȴ!nePӀXqualifXqn:cPsgh.À0iXfollow(WϏGG">JoeA20iallggaSpeo0n’Hrow,llzЉ߀hobviousl2HowQ,ivxso0requirdpr$a7Eiǹ8,ereotequiredonowllheetailsftatement9ermineheXrts8proposition.onsidqfollowing:


“Grampsustw owhte .”f5`OMPLEXROPOSITIONSNDOGICALNNECTIVES>ampoorpa*1sŋogcOMolem`GCreferrsIsylPPGhschrouha+h)ng;lete򂨶9Q>‚ljjInPdinarykrsZa1HgrePregubutHteXisgui.torptseag8trlcealhOHin1aАnh (zbeə).ȕli0sH:/*blockquo8PQɁ~߁߁߁lth*QP;esidHhowe(󋝩GHadd蒺,Pncxsu٘ۃ0mpYXavierreomputeroftwareirates”ulderansldnto “Shermans772, andavi.

    E3QDisjunction:APorQ.nxamplef`d,momawn8edding)1soloodhcabbreviascor*eqst stheiproposi„,)96lementseacheferrx8=sq.ikn݋Xtwosmaylsoswitchyroumep*amhhx.Ăpmo(licthyirstppeaxince)oraryversajAw؈orcusچmt8tays.ƃ[ڌ Hlusively!PabovIfSȕ¹O?וтkyout$abiddXfruY_cwillrdieOtPGGGEOOOQw*=Prp_ZceQQl3equH†port0l!iASߺڱ+؈6cgeC񵟑EЗђ퐇!Ϗϊ(0GGitClHly@on@nghssurHay(o#wrb\s;H,ڂ' //osome akydivacc8ISPypiHXsguiy/(@br>0oHYsuffici8:>QnfromЂQnssary>Qmgg'gtimɩ2easydetermiiXkiXhlog `tiHbeauclexhak٧ ordintem駀AmerH: reTechnY1km,ۛd׻!must τ .”learlyhissisjunction,ivenerominencef“or”.πxromplexQposi reo(difficultoecognize.ake,orxa ,


XBestowingfts)goldrankinsendyrrhpoteacnecessarypnd"pass၉course.ЅIf
i>willaha7ߔoAbbrevi2would ww>ifЄnф___w,Jsz??aYQgf'6.ESTEDOGICALONNECTIVES.8x777 OOOKCOOoftؖtaiumb77nwin几.ÂhidЈqfollz:Inoturt"@Hladyfsi(yhYv2walletT;g wa/ȟOOOIʞa_ƅt!馑Z(p߀ډ)OO!s:wGGy(QR)OOρP =߂߂߂Q؊/////R/ό͂GGnef(ț)ɜ(J{siblXoutquici_0}HҁPor󃋘dis)@ Alus.ٗby.WWPxO’jovionyules@akpgexa!QMarsr̀alASeen W\canibq,ر؄#r0sslyoyȃ,{smustQ(WLJ)GGGWS-_YϤsayXOOOט(PQ)brP+),???oo77Ϥكߡ/''&IҨhorocognizey ?:erF\QetemQQ) clea*M̕X ashweפ_n`e(sub-?n(x-R odXsists ȁā@[,ў which߄߄ܒo(>7.ALIDRGUMENTORMS)bOOONSoapa@se@rϊmay≨xь]08e(:elzʰpargu_arlier,anyrgumentsPeadnes,ndhenonstructingogicaluroisokeo;.heirstlefationvalidityforpurposeseillefinevsllows:


VAQ:Pwhichpm (su@modusHns).(H胙dn_____>?<A@four8qvalidrgumentrms3aongntuiappeal.n@tunlyba!ooasyHccidywitchPnd.`hnotȠ!comary0cia`؄roduc)grofHaciouXxaYsXrmblangenuׂ_Ѕsequarer~(takHrHqזTXXsireٌGwi>FMsЦns:yarm8gOwWWWW_]therefore,
(peight="0pt"idthc>Fallaciousod0Tollens:yfenyinghentecetconcl.    (3)irefore,QDisjunctiveyllogismassertanlterna)orц3WWɁn/ WWWWƒύύύɀ߀߀ۑ?ww(>8.OUND UNdRGUMENTS.8p777 OOOKAsIed,jfirsttepnormJoodrgum@sha@tubealid.owever,Ane؀Aǁ @andaЕPrues.hpcedoundness:hώ>S|+which (a)(Pws(c,d (b)snlya7T8Ghi_xs@AoutseJexamplˁsincHZboth-rYfews rawhy?{Ѓ1WǃWRY2ϋIutooh???WW">YEi՟eobennHsho@or72golfɁ9O>qI↱ca郏畷畲aboA7&ͣRY.ut,0bobvAxssoZsnҒa!l@somO?=,D{ϕ͂likew1F:7WWfPidpilAiryOn[nҒioulh‚Uiallan_?Ïyc(777߃???ww؈OGGAoo>А 񮚇(z͏yy3ߥۧXacY}d0pnboђInrntailidit(8atwopyL׎kP::in ,r+ܯ#teaX*Wggb>9pNLASSXERCISESȽрzHhIfhinysea㴤-36“Deadilk”r⌨.opeowhHomUU.S.zn@d.٣xs!at’eig!___Hey,geboElizabethhe0hpech!nyߟA#akiyqonsZsxltestine?ӃonaXlle0on+o:sԆ`Ofreajk$ArmyfershodhreoppunitieHۘHmHhimself؄ggg`4)Ƀӊ#go(wiyoux arŵsugggggc5)׫ ⇓facul3tppytahUn8rs Dr.ilbur.runkard,hoeachesere,soodacultyember.


Determineetheollowingreropositions.fomenot,eef)yaneewrittenswp:7773-36A(6)averyfdnsemell.___7)΅Ȋ#Billyob!ׁׁׁ8)think’m)to0ll8leoinlryO''{InyGidentifylogicalonnectibe1usandrantent(rmw9)aJOBri(w arElizabPnX9irstehsiesthЃ샧10waccept)ta`Unry,utdu r;adhriftommunxPllege1)nessadoXappearBookLifԊ/-iaw-X)ǚoww2)P9n (Qr)Wρρ3) (PQ)4R8Q?5)1(8Q; TG@premisЂٙclus阷decȌvalirgum`+fallaciou𜷌i#b9“SaPitchk”era 0wn,ӜplayH,weetȩɂy GG9dudg蛠.o?9,gg`Eiڬ[goIkrupt,h.t߃׃׃׃ԮfacPhosaariu(hroJTominxit对Ig@.ǀف>Makep?YthXdon.պruindpnؙ.outeintosimp𤟔your߇HtߌܳP8antPracker. (disjun;syXgism72fPsultdm,Ғhosp@(hypAtZσσσσ˲Claraotnrapabl(modpnsׂׂׂԮȷWWQaXodc!t WWsA׵snLsoun8unb???? FidxDalmatia[nwouldalo ssSlockquopWWIaǃƅvheeGGEhas_(2xJosephӕ`had.S.z`hipEbeborn?WW?oiw@ggg''$estknowled8Aness/ǂǍ׍5aH'#aalЭK26KAnswerʋclassxercI(3)rgumentgainstheerson.histtacksnalributefArmyajor,xthoutxaminingcontb’W.

(6) oPXritȈ///+7?noe\.ɍanee7follow: IXqueXo8hereŽyob.0e /@mponׂ@edp_\. . yLJLJLJ8džwrׄ k 9ad((if-nperzonif@,nd hanslatFarϙBriXmarryTHENhuHfir0leavhod׆׆׆10߆junc(HcceptpYaXU_ANDɇxdxr eThriftommpCege1aega;ja8BJHsznameIear@BookLif12weform17773`WWn(aogicxnepneedprecede(bnc (p)gg7774p7777774validypotsygismȩBd8Ʉb:br>WWP߀crackϋgga߇)WWGG20Edhyouߌߌߌߌ߆w+younsultd’sother,HENillitou.IF)s Pgohospital>REFORE,fins߃߃߃߃r>(p߃"-36(21)ossiblereatedroitions “Claraartian.”Ԅ8argument,n`sHis:OOWWWWW refore,2ifacyemberserunks@.oakeuaega appeaxinconclus,et`eserveeriginal(aningftipulʁZnhouldeewordsollows:!ItinotaseHatriftommuniCegeqaadchoolόϔ{OOO7>ITSOTASEHATOOOOOOOO/(ggggoooj3)Xqnvalid(llaciouyd0tnq=sinceQmiwoeniantecenste0sequ.ɓ鑉u0bandnsoundx4abHowevI%1ЀXU.S.㟘zdontavoborʁj(i.e.yhn!naturHzed)bXuter)a\;25ъD:(uch liЁ֠JsdpU`eobtennH0eBVѕonlerșormhtru6ۇanɇ.7#-mech8sm; 酨hrus (I)Srr oڗWWߡ(>10hAKEOMEXERCISESb>(XQue hReview!pbl(bookiXrnoa alysiډHpter)xA0Qsn?f,owy:phr(Bns?>(1)󞐷\ICIApyn0OO)ЊXdownouru@comwiڒdspIQacspirit;doooixYoun@w p)thoryst0хaAgGْhndarjm/o:>(xetW__XPfWWWP7n ssarb w''!8)alugh⁇9mp00!Ʉ[oWhi`􌏞pel3ߚGGG Prцgy8(c(R*S)߁߁߁٘`nсJ[P0S)];TWWxWpna#rlacyJblockquoteA3Bၿht="0pt" width="0pt">therefore,ot
(peight>(17)hatsheamefbfollowingrgumentrmrallacy?Imtracelancaneelv0memorabilia???IJIcaseH߂߂߂߂ߌ//*WWWoLmbp:pagebreak/>

    E3Ȗq''m򔸁aluڔԎɝitHkt`p isKcknowHglexenkputdlAuth)limititough.irsz۔hpfoYwh9lix(uripaJfG)wopularm8hilosops;co8reiadvaHgenehBociciis2giї`eng;viewC{0 Hcaus\reje؍o qavmism,iwindSe{ihappҖ08@:ҟ RiؓXi)2I ڳyߟperXȰholɅ9t8ngel^nhapvacjtottroۈшguxPnegaЙir8rimBѝXempex8wӁj9kzRclexidequ9nCPuspfl3hurrican)whihaxhTdo\baeopenbst׌ߋߋ>ւ5s8sfGC.ɘH"t8XnjunsUيbx˰gmaybumblqblocktHppHWxXogniz Xǃǟ29Ȑ74BzmeonȬ𿨚ym1!amilbr>EAITHNDEASONׁؓSohل]s؄xag!(ok`spicixH{ ictr*]`)sett0Adis ё.easonemqeutJub:@wheR ф)m*Iw?ρɫ,ad@3osi>agnospȘ9ȽDn0Ƚ.ڄ'!simp8?absɕof:Nthrrth.́Yrgi5:BtgAs2oute,rguinghateasonasoiheffectner’ssychologicalcepti(towardsligiousPef.aithlone,eyrgu`shoulduideurathsn/att,ndou.ertullianarlyhristdvocatf -based,hmAsthment“Icve@causet bsurd.”ȀxHƒZqsoYnfrom571essialirraial'aosibЁHherxtrXwoore(deeefen`sefma whilnoni-,
    E3 Pas:agPBcGodʐirsf!pFrenchposopQBlai8 (1623-1662).ePi`rxA`o!agȃex0hJ felLneutr2ٙ.ud\,}saywsumbeP0anI;quepimpo `mu decn!y`Itaiw,ء wytak[(spf1 mw9ppss—thlifȔPxt.proeI:si9XseHniN:)blockquo//*LetsO풠pyheas.̂'"t(c Ifou,V(lރ0 U1hp.!oЂi؏@2H0i0[,Tps]X>LjChart8a y2"WWWWW8uP/Wgbdoesitmake
)dROO1ɁG є@hiPtriggerenuineelief.

NMxody>FLISAFCIS